And by the way, Bonanzas certainly don't have
anything to brag about, safetywise.
Well, I don't know about that. The numbers for Bonanza are actually pretty
good. Overall, they're right in the averages for single-retracts. Exclude
the early v-tails (up to about 1960) and they're better than average.
Include just the F33A and A36 straight-tails, and they're about best in the
fleet, only slightly below the best (C182RG). The rates are noticeably
better than the C210 and big Cherokee retracts.
Someone is probably going to cry foul over excluding the early Bonanzas, but
pre-1960 airplanes have very poor accident rates in general and it doesn't
make sense to me to compare the accident rates of a brand new design with
one first produced in 1947. A 1980 Bonanza is quite a different airplane
from a 1947 V-tail.
- Mark
|