Pete,

Beating a dead horse...

I'm with you on this issue that ATC doesn't care too much about VFR ac in
IMC and can't go after someone based on a PIREP of an ac near the same point
in space. But I understood Dave's comment. He's trying to say you're being
way too technical. It's like someone saying, "We all know the sun will come
up tomorrow" and you arguing, "Well, technically you're incorrect. You
really can't say that with 100% accuracy. There is a mathematical
possibility that it will not."


"Peter Duniho" wrote in message
...
"Dave" wrote in message
...
Answers the question really!

What "answers the question really"? My reply to the question answers it?
Then please, tell me...am I the type of guy that wonders every day if the
sun will rise?

For extra credit, explain how ANY answer to that question has anything to
do
with the reliability of a PIREP.

Pete