"Tom Fleischman" wrote in message
rthlink.net...

Without knowing what exactly was said by the controller on the second
call we can go around and around on this until the cows come home and
not come to a definate conclusion about whether he was legal to
proceed. Any debate is really meaningless without knowlege of exactly
what was said by the controller on the second call.


If he was issued an instruction that overrode the previous instruction to
remain clear of Class C airspace then he was legal to enter Class C
airspace. If he was not issued an instruction that overrode the previous
instruction to remain clear of Class C airspace then he was not legal to
enter Class C airspace. There is no gray area here.