"Peter" wrote in message
news:Ras%b.127906$jk2.539687@attbi_s53...

You seem to be assuming things that were never part of the stated
scenario - specifically that there were additional controller
transmissions to the pilot and that the pilot did not respond to them.


I just assume a real-world scenario, what else can I do?



Here was Michael's post initiating this discussion:

"Consider the following scenario.

You take off outside the Class C and would like to transit it. You are
instructed to remain clear. You circumnavigate it, reach your destination,
and return without landing. You again approach the Class C with the
desire to transit rather than go around. You call up ATC again and they
reply with your tail number but no instructions. Can you go in or not?
I'm positing on the order of an hour or more elapsing between the two
attempts to transit."


Right. The aircraft was instructed to remain clear. That's done when
workload or traffic conditions prevent immediate provision of Class C
services. If the controller didn't anticipate being able to provide those
services in a short time he wouldn't have established communications.

So a short time later the controller will call the aircraft again. If the
airplane responds, he will get the desired services.