"Morgans" wrote in message
...

"Julian Scarfe" wrote

On a twin with an engine out, or even a trijet, perhaps. On a 4-engined
aircraft which has just crossed the Atlantic on 3 engines on the basis of
having sufficient redundancy to do so safely, that would smack a little
of
having your cake and eating it too, doesn't it? ;-)

I *love* all of the Monday morning quarterbacking going on around here.

I always make an effort, to not tell brain surgeons how to do their job.

I don't see how you can argue that a comment on Standard Operating Procedure
is Monday-morning-quarterbacking.

Julian