In article ,
wrote:
I think everybody is losing sight of the fact that the idea is to fly
the approach safely.

BINGO!

We can nit pick on the rules all we want, but in the end what is most
important is that we fly safely! There are things that are legal, but not
safe, and there are things that are safe, but not legal. What we want
to do in stay in the intersection of the two: both safe AND legal.

-- Dane