"George Patterson" wrote in message
news:9OpYe.7576$N35.4708@trndny09...
Can #1 log this at all since he's not current or just log it as non-PIC?

Pilot #1 can log it. I agree that I would not do so.

Why wouldn't you?

Or are you simply agreeing that Pilot 2 should be qualified to fly the
airplane?

Pete