OK thanks for all the opinions, looks like I should stick with a phone
with analog capabilities for a while longer. 99% of my usage is in a
digital area, but its pretty important to have the analog available for
when I fly out of town.

I chose the LG VX5200. Not a particularly highly-rated phone, but not
any worse than what I have now (CDM8900). It is however, one of the few
analog-capable phones Verizon offers at this point. And cheap enough
that I can upgrade later if something better comes along.