View Single Post
  #108  
Old October 2nd 06, 10:42 PM posted to rec.aviation.piloting
Larry Dighera
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 3,953
Default NW_Pilot's Trans-Atlantic Flight -- All the scary details...

On Mon, 2 Oct 2006 11:32:30 -0700, "NW_Pilot"
wrote in
:

"Larry Dighera" wrote in message
.. .
Given the fact that the aux fuel system was a modification upon which
your safety depended, did you personally take the time to analyze its
intended operation from the schematic diagram and description of
system operation (not its use, but how it was engineered to operate)?
I believe you are intelligent enough to have done a reasonable job of
system analysis without benefit of specific training or an appropriate
college degree.


Yes, I looked at the system!


And your analysis failed to discern what would occur to the fuel from
the return line when operating from the aux tank while the main tanks
were full?


and so did the engineer that designed it and
wrote the instructions for it's usage! I would also assume so did the faa
inspector that approved the system description and usage instructions.
Once
you go changing the factory fuel system design you go from the engineered
description of the now modified fuel system.


If I understand your story correctly, the cause of the wing tank
venting was a result of the fuel return line pouring fuel that was
being feed from the separate aux tank fuel system into the wing
tank(s). Is that correct?


The aux tank was connected directly to the engine after the aircraft fuel
system, Not to the wing and the provided documentation and system
description mentioned nothing about the fuel return to the main tanks. The
description also stated that it was connected after the aircraft fuel
system.


As long as the aux fuel line was ahead of the fuel
filter/gascolator(?), or the aux fuel system contained its own filter,
that is the logical point to feed aux fuel to the engine. Without a
check valve between the Cessna fuel shutoff valve and the point
between it and the engine where the aux fuel line was attached, there
is also the possibility of back feeding fuel into the wing tanks if
the Cessna shutoff valve is left open while the aux tank fuel pump is
in operation. Did the instructions mention such a check valve or
closing the Cessna shutoff valve?


They left out something very very important in the new systems
description!


Are you referring to the necessity to burn fuel from the wing tanks
before switching to the aux tank, so that there would be adequate room
in the wing tanks to hold the fuel being returned from the fuel
injection system?


Correct, They failed to mention this the description and instruction
provided!

therir instruction basicaly short and simple! Climb to altitude on both
tanks aircraft tanks once at altitude switch to ferry tank until specified
mark on aux tank near empty then switch back to aircraft fuel.


Do you know the name of the individual who wrote that? Do you know
the name of the FSDO inspector who certified the aux fuel tank
installation? I would contact those people personally, and make them
aware of the hazard they caused.

Now!! If the instructions stated to run on the left tank till near empty
then switch to the ferry tank and monitor the left tank fuel quantity and
return to aircraft fuel and switch ferry tank off when left tank was almost
full about 2 hours flight time this little problem would not have happened.


Given the inoperative fuel gages, the wing tanks could have filled up
at any time without your being aware of it. Considering your mission
and the operation of the aux fuel system, fuel gages are critical to
an Atlantic crossing. Cessna, FSDO, and Telford should be made aware
of that fact.

The Greenland CAA took a copy of the instructions and fuel system
description and copy of Cessna description of the problem and will be
contacting the ferry tank mfg and installer telling them to correct their
system instructions.


That's a good thing, but I'd make sure Cessna, FSDO, and Telford
appreciate the hazard they caused.


Can you provide the manufacturer's name and model number for the aux
fuel system installed in the aircraft you delivered?


The Ferry tank was Manufactured And Installed By Telford Aviation In Bangor,
Maine.


That would be these folks: http://www.telfordaviation.com/contact.html

Given their mission statement:

TELFORD SERVICES - Mission

------------------------------------------------------------------
The mission of The Telford Group, Inc. is to integrate teamwork,
dedication and vision to excel in the aviation industry in quality
and customer satisfaction. It is our foremost goal to continually
enhance our products and services to an unsurpassed level and
create a mutually prosperous and beneficial relationship for our
customers and associates.

I would contact these people (all six of them):

TELFORD SERVICES - Contact Information

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Office and Mailing Address:
The Telford Group
154 Maine Avenue
Bangor, Maine 04401
Telephone: 1-207-262-6098
Facsimile: 1-207-262-8708
Email:
Telford Allen III, Chairman of the Board
Larry Wilson, CEO, Telford Canada, Ltd.
Bob Ziegelaar, President, The Telford Group
Monique Plummer, Administrative Assistant
Aircraft Maintenance - Telford Aviation Services
Travis Allen, V.P. Operations
General Aviation - Telford Aviation Services
Ray Lane, Manager, General Aviation

And make them aware of the hazard they caused.

In the future I will try and avoid this company or flying with this
company's installed equipment if at all possible and if I am to use them
(Not Likely) I will require them to provide a full schematic of the system
and talk with them more to support their documentation.


See what experience does for you? Here's hoping your bag of
experience fills up before your bag of luck is exhausted. :-)

Another thing that ****es me off when I called the company (telford) to help
with the problem they were rude and said there instruction were correct and
that it was not their problem!


Did you get the name of the individual who said that? Don't forget to
mention that in your correspondence to Telford.

Cessna support and the weekend A&P in Greenland were the best
they had a solution with in a few hours after faxing the instructions to
them and are also writing a letter to Telford explaining the problem with
their instructions.


You should do the same, IMO. See if they dig themselves a deeper
hole, or if Telford management wants to make it right.


How large is the documentation of the aux fuel system? Is it possible
you could make a scanned copy available? In particular, I'd like to
see a schematic drawing of the system and the description of its
operation, and its operation use instructions, in that order.


No schematic was available only textual description of the fuel system and
its operation. All paperwork was given to new owner and there was no photo
copy machine available in Beirut at time of delivery for me to make a copy
for myself. The Greenland CAA made copies of all paperwork and said they
will forward me copies of all paperwork.


It would be good for you to have a copy.

You have made the crossing before, right? Who manufactured and
installed the ferry tank(s) you used on previous Atlantic crossing(s)?

If we don't hold these folks feet to the fire, who will?