Neil Gould wrote:


Well, *all* restrictions go away in an emergency

Yes, but irrelavant to the discussion.


, so that doesn't really
address the root of the problem.



You missed the root of the problem completely.







The reason why you can't file such an
alternate is that you don't have the minimum information required to
safely fly that approach.




No, that's not why. As a matter of fact you do have all the
information. The reg is there to provide redundancy.