Neil Gould writes:

Perhaps you are confused over the meaning of the word "YOU" in my comment?

Maybe, although my reply would be valid in any case.

Because he is a pilot with a multi-engine rating, and you aren't even a
student pilot. DUH...

He hasn't performed the maneuver in question, therefore he doesn't
know if it can be done or not, irrespective of his rating or status.

--
Transpose mxsmanic and gmail to reach me by e-mail.