On Fri, 17 Nov 2006 20:29:51 GMT, Lobby Dosser
wrote:

Don Homuth wrote:

On Fri, 17 Nov 2006 18:18:58 GMT, Lobby Dosser
wrote:



DID YOU OR DIDN'T YOU KNOW THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN RIGHT AND WRONG?

Would it be right to fire into a crowd coming to lynch you and your
family?

Just answer the question. That's how this works.

Not when the assumption within the question is Wrong.

Unless you're a lying sleazeball politician.

No lying involved, and as a Politician, no one in My community has
used such terms in any descriptive way.

You have Moral Perfection on your side here, Lobby.

So -- use it and answer My question.

The situation is clear:

The Mob is half a block away, armed and coming to kill You and three
members of Your family. Unless stopped, it'll be here in ten minutes.
It is not open to negotiation on your fate.

The helicopters called to evacuate you and your family are 20 minutes
away, though. Not enough time to get you and yours out before the
confrontation starts.

So -- gotta Decide something right quicklike.

My mission as explained was specifically and explicitly to protect
Murken Lives whenever possible. It is possible for me to do that by
opening fire. There is apparently no other option available at the
moment.

My troops are good folks. I trained them. They are competent shots,
highly disciplined, have sufficient ammunition to last through any
firefight, their positions and fields of fire are in good order. I
trust Them and They trust Me.

The decision is mine to take: Do I open fire into the mob in order to
save the lives of You and Your Family?

Make the call, Dosser.

Use your highly developed sense of Perfect Morality that does not
depend on the situation at hand to do it.

Do I open fire into the crowd or not?

What is Right and what is Wrong here?

Do you know?

How?