View Single Post
  #3  
Old September 20th 10, 06:03 PM posted to rec.aviation.piloting
Mark
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 815
Default POLL: Would you participate in a rec.aviation.piloting.moderated newsgroup?

On Sep 20, 12:03*pm, Jim Logajan wrote:
Jim Logajan wrote:
The RFD would simply state that posts will be approved so long as they
are reasonably on-topic and non-inflammatory in the subjective
judgement of the moderators.


Scratch all that!

It is quicker and easier for all involved if users must perform a one-time
registration post (in which their e-mail address, posting handle, and NSP
are recorded, though if a posting handle is used the e-mail address is not
published.) The registration is manually validated by a moderator who
approves all registrations. After registration approval, when the user
posts, the NSP and posting handle are automatically checked against the
record list and the post is approved if a record is found.

Pros:
No delay in postings.
No extra work for moderators.
No easy nym-shifting by malevolent posters.

Cons:
De-registration for abuse can only occur after-the-fact.


Well let me ask you this Jim, what would be your
criteria for acceptable posts?

---
Mark