View Single Post
  #6  
Old January 17th 11, 02:46 PM posted to rec.aviation.soaring
[email protected]
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 194
Default Mandating Radios? (WAS: Another midair in the pattern)

On Jan 17, 9:22*am, JJ Sinclair wrote:
*Scott wrote........
Absolutely not. Just a freedom loving American who doesn't need
government to grow ever bigger and dictate every aspect of my life. I
consider myself to be responsible enough to watch out for myself.
Powered planes (modern ones with electrical systems) almost always have
radios and they sometimes meet in midair. I think they call these events
'accidents', same as car crashes. Do cars need radios installed so
drivers can communicate their every move to each other? If everyone
cries to the government to "Please, save us!" they certainly will step
up to the task. I'm not looking for a Nanny State...


Oh come on Scott, that argument is pathetic. Its like saying cars use
head lights to aid in seeing each other at night, but we still have
accidents at night, soooooooooooooooo we don't need headlights! No,
make that ludicrous!
The radio is an aid, it helps to show who is near you especially when
trying to take off or land. Many power pilots who reguraly fly near
soaring operations will make a call in the blind like......GLUDER
GLIDER * * GLIDER * * * *thei is turbo bla bla I'm descending over the
pine nuts passing 12,000 any gliders in my area? No government madate
told him to do this, he just used is common sense and did it, like he
does when entering the pattern.............or how about prior to
takeoff? Can you see everyone who may be in the pattern? Wouldn't
listening to one of those hated radios be prudent?
JJ


You gave a perfect example of a MISUSE of the two way radio.
Radio calls like "Anybody in the pattern?" Or "Anybody on base or
final?" Or, "What runway are you using?" are among the many misuses
of the radio............

Cookie