For many years I was criticised that the literary devices I employed to make my points (e.g., irony and satire) were too oblique. So true then as now.

To wit: Mr. Andrzej Kobus and I are in accord. My recent, somewhat colourful post (Top Ten Reasons to “Like” Sean F) was, in fact, a personal attack on Mr. Sean Fidler, and a mean-spirited one at that--intentionally so.

In recent days I watched in dismay as the discussion over Mr. Tim Mara in this thread grew increasingly shrill and uncivil. Even certain individuals whom I regard highly for their opinions and style seemed to be pulled inexorably into that wretched fracas.

I had hoped the shock of my low-grade despatch would cause the unruly combatants to take a deep breath and soberly consider the dangerous course upon which they were embarked. Similarly, I had hoped that most would concur that this thread was ALSO a personal attack, one that I fear has already unfairly damaged not only Mr. Mara’s reputation but also his livelihood. If my maths are correct, some 6% of the participants have stated they would likely look elsewhere for spares as a result of the mud being flung about. I should think the actual impact on Mr. Mara’s business might be substantially higher, at least in the short term, as the preponderance of those who would be uneasy are not so inclined to express their views publicly.

This forum has served gliding very well for many years, providing a venue for pilots from around the globe to exchange ideas and opinions helpfully and courteously. Information is now far more widely disseminated and at a much faster rate. And every man (and woman, of course) has a right to speak. But that right is encumbered by responsibility.

I ask a simple question: are there any amongst us who believe they have the right to take money from another's pocket and defame him over the matter first raised in this thread? For that is where we have arrived.

I am aware that Mr. Fidler is a much more pleasant, less belligerent chap in person than he often seems to be on this forum and I offer my apologies for using him as a foil, albeit a highly cooperative and convenient one.

I hope, even now, that he and others who continue to quarrel here over Mr. Mara’s policy and actions may find a way to resolve a disagreement sparked by a silly tiff that never should have risen to this level, to restore Mr.. Mara’s reputation and good standing, to rehabilitate Mr. Fidler’s, and to allow all to forget that this lamentable scuffle ever took place.

SoarPoint