On Friday, May 10, 2013 7:19:27 AM UTC-6, son_of_flubber wrote:

Okay. I do have a few observations/opinions:

1)That the payout winch payouts more line and keeps line tension constant when the glider hits lift seems an inherent advantage of this approach when compared to a traditional winch launch.

If a glider can hit at thermal, it can also hit sink. A conventional winch can call on huge reserves of power to pull the glider through sink but the payout winch is more limited in this ability.


2)Don's suggestion that traditional winch launching is proven and that there is therefore no reason to experiment with payout winching misses the point. In a country where beefy pickup trucks are common, the start-up costs for payout winching are much lower than traditional winching. Secondly, far fewer humans need to be deployed and coordinated to run a payout winch. The relevant question is "Which is better to use on a dry lake bed, 1)autotow with payout winch or 2)traditional autotow? What are the tradeoffs?

If space is essentially unlimited, as is sometimes the case on dry lakes, a traditional auto-tow is both simpler and safer. When space is limited, as on a runway, conventional winches will prove more efficient and, I think, safer. I've run the numbers several times and a conventional winch will always get you higher than a payout winch given a limited runway length. Don's point that a conventional winch is simpler is valid. In the extreme it only requires as many people as aero tow.

The conventional winch is a very mature technology with an enormous body of safety data. In the 7 or 8 decades of its history, the potentially dangerous aspects have been found and procedures developed to minimize them. Germans manage 180,000 winch launches or so between accidents where we have an aero tow accident roughly every 26,000 tows. Unfortunately, the Brits suffer a winch accident every 16,000 launches which calls their methods into question. No one knows what the accident rate with payout winches would be, but until everyone climbs the learning curve, I suspect it won't be stellar.