On Sunday, July 31, 2016 at 11:46:23 AM UTC-7, wrote:
I may have mentioned this before, but the series of my articles and tests currently being printed in Soaring magazine will continue for a few more months. As a result of this discussion, I am submitting a rather lengthy article about landing procedures / technique. My guess is it will not be published until early next year.

If I send in two pages of my popular Glider Flight Training Manual each month, it will take 15 years to publish all the information it contains.

You might consider upgrading to this new version rather than waiting.

Tom Knauff

I thought of four situations when this "military",or button hook, landing pattern MIGHT be appropriate:

1. Terrain/buildings forced a tight base leg, such as an airstrip in a canyon.
2. Remaining altitude is at an absolute minimum for landing.
3. Unusual local weather conditions, like microbursts, are occurring.
4. The pilot wanted to impress his/her girl/boyfriend (just JOKING!).

In all other situations a square pattern (or a modified square pattern) is far safer. Flying a button hook pattern puts the runway out of sight to the pilot, so it is hard to judge how far you have flown, making it much more likely that an overshoot or undershoot landing will occur.

An important aspect of the square pattern, in addition to the visibility part, is to assess the winds aloft by the amount of crab required. I have been flying lately in conditions of high cross winds (10-20 kt) and even higher gusts (20-30 kt). Having a stabilized base leg is essential to judge this (the AWOS is just to old to be relied upon). If I were to fly a button hook pattern I would have a ground speed of 110-130 kt, given the high density altitudes we are flying and an 80 kt IAS (100 kt TAS + 10-30 kt tail wind)! This translates to up to 220 ft/sec (a 180 deg turn takes 10-20 sec and complicates the design point on when to start the turn). If you hit unexpected sinking air during this turn you could be in a real pickle! You may not experience these conditions where you fly, but a lot of accidents occur when flatlanders venture into high density altitude airports.

I also like to have A LOT of altitude when entering the pattern (2,000 ft). It is easy to burn off that altitude in modern gliders and it gives me options if something unexpected happens (like a plane pulling out onto the runway unannounced). Altitude lost is like runway behind you - it doesn't do you any good.

Tom