"Denyav" wrote in message
...
A spectacular event that would shock the nation = a surprise attack - it
never had to succeed.

Read Part six of McCollum's eight part plan.

Yeah, try reading some history.



o the US govt should believe the utterances of EVERY single foreign
diplomat in the world?

And act on them? should the US have gone to war on 2nd hand information
from a PERUVIAN minister?

If you'd planned to make this event happen you would not believe even
this
message had come from Jesus Crist.
Who is a Peruvian minister to spoil FDRs plans?

No, the question is who is a peruvian minister and why should info from
another Govt be given credence.

Other govts have their own agendas.


and M Dies agenda was?


Good question,He was the Chairman of the Committeee,

and you didn't answer the question.


He may well have deduced that, but since the Germans didn't know about
any
attack on Pearl Harbour until after the event and the Brits were reading
German codes, it seems likely that it was ignored as trivial.

We know British knew Pearl Harbor attack ,Popovs trstimony was for Brits
not
new.


No, you believe the Brits knew, do try to distinguish between fact and your
opinion.


You don't think that the "Korean underground" had reasons to be making
stuff
up that might draw the USA into a war with the Japanese?

For those who decided to set Pearl Harbor trap for Japanase,of course
every
warning is very suspicious.

Or to put it another way, you believe it so you accept it as fact.


Interesting, given that the Japanese didn't transmit that information.
ever.

Thats biggest lie of whole story,IJN sent dispatces too and their
dispaches
were even more easy than diplomatical ones.

No, the IJN sent none - reality is not your friend is it?

But since the US had a limited number of Japanese speaking translators and
those they had were tasked on the Diplomatic codes, it doesn't matter does
it.

But the person responsible for IJN dispatches was McCollum,the Architect
of
Pearl Harbor trap.
Thats the most important part of whole Japan story.

and a complete lie like the rest of your story.



Interesting, given that the Japanese didn't transmit that information.
ever.


See above.

No, the IJN sent none - reality is not your friend is it?


Yes, why do you make this **** up?


Because there is only one reality and this is the reality.

No, it is your opinion.


Clashes with reality, the US didn't have to lose to be in the war, just
get
attacked.

US did not lose war.

They didn't have to lose that battle and by sinking the Japa carriers that
launched the attack, they'd have ended it then and there.

Reality is not your friend is it?


Even planners of Pearl Harbor paid attention to this detail,Japanase were
only
allowed to sink and destroy obsolete equipment.

You mean the equipment they refloated and used, that obsolete equipment?




A final war warning issued to all commanders in the army and navy on
November 27 was not heeded because Pearl Harbor was not mentioned as a
possible target.


So Called war warning was issued for places thousands miles away from
Hawaii,but not for Hawaii,even though Washington knew the exact position
of
Japanese Carriers and the name of their target.
Capt.Ranneft of Dutch Navy,the dutch naval arrache, learned the exact
position
of Japanase Carriers in McCollums department.
At that day,they were 300-400 miles northwest of Pearl Harbor
The day was Dec,6.1941

So you actually believe that the commander of a pacific fleet base who was
competent would have ignored a war warning involving Japan, believing
perhaps that it had nothing to do with his duties?

it was obvious that you were not sane, but it is clear that you are stupid
to boot.