View Single Post
  #24  
Old November 24th 15, 06:03 PM posted to rec.aviation.soaring
Richard[_9_]
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 551
Default Is FLARM helpful?

On Tuesday, November 24, 2015 at 9:45:06 AM UTC-8, James Metcalfe wrote:
At 12:26 24 November 2015, Ramy wrote:
... (With handful of Flarm saves in over 1000 hours with Flarm)


Interestingly, my experience is just the opposite: in 1593 hours in
the French Alps since 2007 (only 208 hours of which were without
Flarm), I have had no relevant alert from Flarm but hundreds of
false alarms. However I have experienced several dangerous or
very dangerous events (and many more daft ones) which can only
reasonably be ascribed to Flarm - or rather the false expectations
that some pilots seem to have of it.
The most stupid of these was two gliders simultaneously overtaking
me at speed from directly behind on a ridge, one each side, at
exactly my height, and with a horizontal separation of about a
wingspan. Fortunately, I had insisted that my pupil did *not* take
evasive action from the Flarm-announced threat, pointing out that
we might just turn into the path of the (imagined) single overtaker.
(I presume that the 2 overtakers thought "they know we're coming,
so they won't do anything stupid"!)
In the 2000+ hours in the Alps before Flarm I saw no such
dangerous behaviour; nor in the 208 hours 'gap' without Flarm in
2008.
Of course, nothing can be proved. But enthusiasts for Flarm should
be aware it has its down-sides.


Really James, I suspect something is very wrong with your Flarm.

I have approximately 1000 hours with PowerFlarm and have not experienced any issues with false alarms. 6 camps and contests with as many as 65 gliders.

Richard
www.craggyaero.com