On Aug 22, 10:02*pm, Eric Greenwell wrote:
On 8/22/2011 5:50 PM, Cookie wrote:

- Show quoted text -

Ramy do you really need "reminding" to realize that low passes are
dangerous?

So a guy gets killed doing a low pass....Do you need the SSA, *FAA,
NTSB, and whoever else to tell you "Don't do that".

It's not obvious to me the low pass was the cause of the Idaho fatality,
and given the cursory investigation the FAA can afford, we might never
know. Was it

* a medical problem
* a mechanical failure
* hypoxia
* malfunctioning airspeed indicator
* pilot incompetence with pattern turns

I'm sure others can think of more factors that would have led to
spinning in, even if the pilot did not do a low pass beforehand. And
that is part of the problem with the SSA coming out with "generic"
advice immediately after an accident: it may completely miss the cause,
and lull us into an unfounded complacency.

Cookie and others suggest "Don't do low passes", but that's generic
advice not yet supported by this accident. That advice can stand on it's
own without this accident. We should still strive to understand this
accident, though it will be difficult, instead of assuming it was just a
botched low pass.

We can't do a full investigation ourselves, but we can at least consider
those factors I mentioned. Can we rule out a medical problem? Will
someone inspect the glider for mechanical malfunction? Did he have
oxygen left in the tank, a functioning delivery system, an oximeter,
experience in using oxygen? Is the airspeed system potentially
over-reading? Could he always fly a good pattern, or did he
over-rudder/under-bank at times? Was his glider (HIS glider, not BG's in
general) well tested and benign (no surprises) in it's handling?

There are many ways for things to go wrong, and even after 35 years of
"trying", I still - more infrequently now - discover new ones.

--
Eric Greenwell - Washington State, USA (change ".netto" to ".us" to
email me)
- "A Guide to Self-launching Sailplane Operation Mar/2004" Much of what
you need to know tinyurl.com/yfs7tnz


Eric,

I am not trying to say what actually happened in any of these recent
accidents...we are just talking about accidents in general..that there
are certain categories of accident that seem to repete...and how to
help prevent them.

* a medical problem
* a mechanical failure
* hypoxia
* malfunctioning airspeed indicator
* pilot incompetence with pattern turns


You give 5 possible potential "causes" for accidents......we can
easily address each...and figure out how each of us could improve our
odds, or prevent the accidents caused by them.


I'm going to start with "malfunctioning airspeed indicator"........A
glider pilot should be able to fly safely without reference to an
airspeed indicator.......I can think of no accident where the cause
should be a malfunctioning airspeed indicator..airspeed indicator does
not seem to be a factor in any of the recent accidents.

Mechanical failure is very very rare..(unless caused by improper
flying)...annual inspections, 100 hour inspections and preflight
inspections insure us against mechanical failure.....the onus falls on
the PIC to insure the aircraft is airworthy. I don't see where
mechanical failure enters into any of the recent accidents.

Hypoxia is a good one.........we all should have received some degree
of training about hypoxia, its symptoms, and effects.
Many of us fly where this is seldon a concern..others use O2 on a
regular basis and better be proficient on this topic.
Again...don't see this relating to any of the recent accidents...

Medical problems.....we supposedly "self certify" and are required to
not fly during peroids of medical defeciency...does everybody do this?

Lastly pilot incompetence...........BINGO! That's the one! I
see this in accident after accident!


Cookie