Coordinated turns without rudder, and autopilots

Ron Natalie wrote:
Matt Whiting wrote:


Not true. The vertical fin can only provide a weather-vane affect
when a slip or skid has been induced.

You have no clue what you are talking about. The skid and slip are the
result of the airplane NOT weather vaning into the wind. There are
a number of reasons for this. The primary one in turns is the "adverse
yaw" due to the differing drag caused by the displaced ailerons. Many
designs do a lot of things to mitigate this. Still it takes a lot of
aileron displacement to overcome the natural desire for the airplane
to track into the wind (due to the vertical stab).

In coordinated flight there is no slip or skid and hence the fin
provides no lateral force.

This is the definition of coordinated flight, not cause and affect.

The rudder isn't there to help the vertical stab do its job, it is
there to do a job that the vertical stab can't do.

Sorry. The incorrect. You need the vertical stab to even fly
coordinated when you are not turning. If it is two small the
airplane will tend to yaw on it's own (the more bulbous your
fuselage, the more this is a probelm...there was a design Piper
tried that used an almost helicopter like bubble on the front...
without the slab sides to help the vertical stab, the plane
just would as well fly slipping as nromal).

The vertical stab is nearly always set up to get the aircraft
to fly coordinated in normal cruise level flight. It is frequently
slightly offset to correct for other aerodynamic unbalances.

The rudder is just at trim to handle other flight regimes.
It's mostly there for the high AOA regimes of Take-off and
landing.

I don't know where you got your engineering degree, but you better
demand a refund. A vertical stabilizer does not provide any lateral
force unless there is some degree of slip or skid. In coordinated
flight, it is just along for the ride. Many airplanes will oscillate
slight in the yaw axis for this reason. It takes a very large vertical
stab to keep the excursions small enough to not be detectable,
especially in a longer fuselage airplane. The rudder can provide a side
force in anticipation of a slip or skid and thus maintain coordinated
flight and never allow the slip or skid to develop in the first place.

Matt