For Keith Willshaw...

Now we are into claims being simply recycled, so be aware around 95%
of my text is simply putting back in the text Denyav simply has to drop,
nothing new here really, apart from the modern quotes. I timed my effort
at 10 minutes plus the 5 minute

You are very versed in using many detractors in your posts,but you seem to
forget the main rule:

Bad Policy cannot be corrected by excellent Strategy,bad Strategy cannot be
saved by excellent tactics.

If we put your detractors aside and summarize your most current position,we
find out :

1)According to you every statement no matter if they originated from
Stimson,Dulles,Churchill,Casey,Popov,Weiijeman,Gen .Thorpe,Hoover,Capt.Holc
wick,Dies Lieb etc is IRRELEVANT for the Pearl Harbor incident if they point to
a direction other than official direction.

2)You have finally admitted,after resisting long time to do so,that the
Japanase blundered away JN25B code.
You have also finally admitted that US took advantage of Japanase blunder and
recovered almost 5000 JN25B codes before March 1941.
But according to you US,that was able to recover 5000 codes in only a few
months,suddenly stopped recovering codes in March 1941 !!!!!.

I guess in March 1941, USN came under command of Yamamato and he stopped all
code recovering work as that could be dangerous for IJN in nearing conflict.


Thats your current position absent your detractors.
Truly amazing position indeed.
Cheers.