For Keith Willshaw...

Nice to see you in the forum again,I guess you dont work,oops I meant
post,on
weekends.

This is becoming very funny, ever heard of a weekend away?
Ever heard of the idea things can wait a few days?

Perfect enjoy it.

No what the people are saying does not match what Denyav is
saying.

Unfortunately what people says,from Churchill to Dulles,from Stimson to Hoover
and countless others is IRRELEVANT for you because they do not match what you
are telling us.

You see folks, Denyav has decided where I work without proof and
has to pretend he is a majority.

Did I say "You are a gov' t employee"?
NO.
But your response to that is interesting.

Denyav is into self pity. The conspiracy to lie about a conspiracy.

Which reminds me your posts.

As people can see the evidence is deleted.

Detractors sir,nothing but detractors.
Strange that, but Denyav needs to go off and pretend about what I said,
from a post where I gave the recovered code values totals until the end
of 1941, Denyav keeps deleting the totals.

Only after claiming that recovery work had been stopped in March after recovery
of almost 5000 codes.As you now say recovery work did stop in March.
BTW 5000 code recoveries in three months is a good performance and enabled
US,as Safford stated enough to read the most of Japanase traffic.

Secondly ignoring the fact the "5" version of the code stopped being
used in January 1941 and the USN stopped working on the A version
in around March 1941, since the IJN decided to stop using the A code

Now your correction comes?

Move away from the fact that if the
failure to change additive books compromised the B code it
must have compromised the A code, since the US had only 5%
of the A code book when work ended on it around March 1941.

Actually work never ended.

percentage went down by April/May 1942, when the allies were trying
to figure out Midway and Coral Sea? Or that the all knowing intelligence
system missed the IJN battleships coming out at Midway and the way
the IJN carriers came into the

Could you tell me ,surely you know the story,how US only a couple of months
after Pearl Harbor were able to read IJN messages in entirety.?
Midway is based almost solely on intelligence superiority.
Sometimes you are contradicting yourself.

April 1, 1941: "approximately 300 values recovered"
May 1, 1941: "approximately 400 values recovered"
June 1, 1941: "approximately 1100 values recovered"

uly 1, 1941: "approximately 1100 values recovered"
August 1, 1941: "approximately 2000 values recovered"
Sept 1, 1941: "approximately 2000 values recovered"
Oct 1, 1941: "approximately 2400

Roughly 10000 values according to Safford more than enough to read the most of
the IJN traffic.

Translation Denyav chooses to supply URLs with no evidence.

I think anybody with subs.to the Proceeding can access to article.

been
in on the conspiracy right. After all if any arm of the US government
does the same the claim is it was part of a conspiracy.

So this documentary is on Pearl Harbor right?


No,but on a copy cat version of Pearl Harbor.

Willey is like Stinnett, the evidence does not match the claims.

Of course,only official's claims match evidences,because they are the ones who
produce official evidences.

Post war would be easily possible, as part of the investigations even.


No,dont you know some selected senators always meet behind closed doors.

This should be funny, presumably Denyav can read Dutch,
including the Captain's shorthan

You bet.

custody of. Meantime
Denyav quotes the conspiracy custodians, the ones who have
custody of the conspiracy to lie about the events of 1941, people
like Stinnett and Willey

I think you are the conspiracy custodian,sir
Numbers declining but still exist.