If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
"John Carrier" wrote in message ... While there will be those who fixate completely on large raids by large bombers, how about ... Taranto. Eliminated the Italian navy's influence in the Mediterranean theatre. Pearl Harbor. Flawed in many ways (didn't eliminate ship repair facilities or oil storage, nor did it catch the carriers in port AND didn't anticipate US population's reaction), but certainly accomplished Yamamoto's goal to allow him to "run wild" in the Pacific for 6-12 months (well, 5 months and 4 weeks actually). In terms of tactical execution (strike force performing as the script required), absolutely brilliant. Incendiary attacks on Japan. Switch from high altitude bombing to fire raids quickly decimated Japan's small manufacturing base and its ability to supply armaments factories with the subassemblies for its weapons of war. Israeli raid on Osirak nuclear facility. Linebacker 2. Brought North Vietnam back to the table to negotiate the alleged end of the Vietnam war. The difficulty in reviewing "great" strategic air missions is that what seemed like a good idea at the time turns out to be not so good, or too expensive or results in an unintended consequence (Pearl Harbor). While the need for the nuclear attacks upon Hiroshima and Nagasaki seemed overwhelming to the national command authority at the time, with the clear perspective of hindsight they contributed little to the defeat of Japan and certainly opened up Pandora's box for the postwar world. Actually I believe that if we hadn't used Atomic weapons at Hiroshima and Nagasaki then they would have been used at some point in past history most likely with far greater death and destruction. Hiroshima and Nagasaki taught the world how horrible atomic weapons are. Similarly, the urgency to strike the Norwegian heavy water facilities seemed an imperative, but there's little doubt that Germany's nuclear program was not (and could not be) supported adequately to produce a weapon in time for use. Not something known at the time of the attack A lot of ink is thrown at the 8th Air Force's campaign against Germany. Certainly valor was in overwhelming supply as the crews hurled themselves at a well-integrated defense in broad daylight with little escort (to start). OTOH, the strategy looks remarkably similar to that British Expeditionary force in the battle of the Somme, 1916: "Here we come, try and stop us." Fortunately, by late 1944, they couldn't. But it was an expensive effort. Yamamoto shootdown Brilliant tactical execution. Strategic consequences? After all, Yamamoto brought the Japanese the flawed Midway campaign (and overlooked some important strategic targets at Pearl Harbor). Would his leadership have had an impact on Philippine Sea or Leyte campaigns? See answer to Emmanuel Gustin post Hiroshima See above Paul Doumer bridge LGB That and the Thahn Hoa raids introduced precision weapons to the tactical air power game, but did either raid accomplish significant alterations in the strategic picture? How long were the bridges out of action compared to previous missions? Dambusters One of my favorites. Tirpitz Freed RN for other duty. But considering Tirpitz never did anything in her service life, kind of a non-event. Norwegian heavy water See above Midway In terms of fleet placement and combat orders, I'd have to agree. Tactical execution defined "luck" for the dive bombers (Luck = when preparation meets opportunity). When gamed by the Naval War College, the US loses Midway just about every time. I thought you said "Yamamoto brought the flawed Midway campaign?" ;-) Doolittle raid Amen! Any time you can influence the enemy to change his game plan in your favor, it's a good thing. |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
Russian recon planes fly ten missions over Baltics | B2431 | Military Aviation | 4 | March 2nd 04 04:44 AM |
New Story on my Website | ArtKramr | Military Aviation | 42 | February 18th 04 05:01 AM |
OT (sorta): Bush Will Announce New Space Missions | Dav1936531 | Military Aviation | 0 | January 9th 04 10:34 AM |
French block airlift of British troops to Basra | Michael Petukhov | Military Aviation | 202 | October 24th 03 06:48 PM |
Strategic Command Missions Rely on Space | Otis Willie | Military Aviation | 0 | September 30th 03 09:59 PM |