If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
Unintentional fully-developed spins...
OK, I'm curious. How many of you have had to recover from a fully
developed (greater than one turn), unintentional spin that occurred during normal non-aerobatic flight? I've got close to 1000 hours in roughly 25 different types of single seat and higher performance two seat gliders, with stall/spin characteristics ranging from "benign" to "interesting", and while I've had my share of accidental spin entries (all while thermaling in turbulent conditions), I can't remember a single one that went beyond a quarter turn before recovery. Where I first learned to fly gliders, everyone went up in for a single flight in a 2-32 to do their "spin training" prior to solo. The 2-32 spins quite nicely, but the whole thing was such a bizarrely alien experience, that was seemingly irrelevant to "normal" flying. I experienced much more relevant spin training when I was being checked out in a K-13 a few years later. We had about 8000 feet to waste, so the instructor had me to set up a moderately banked turn, feed in a bit of extra bottom rudder, then asked me to see how slowly I could fly. After the "what the f*ck" moment as the ground and sky swapped places, I managed to recover in a turn or so. He spent the rest of the flight showing me how to induce and recognize different kinds of spin entries, and how to recover from them as quickly as possible. These days, at the beginning of each season, I make sure I have the spin recovery procedure in the manual memorized, and try various types of spin entries with slightly delayed recovery (roughly one quarter to one half turn). When I first fly with water, I do the same. I have not tried fully developed spins in any glider I've owned, other than my DG-303 Acro. Some have been placarded against spins, in the others, I just haven't felt it to be necessary or appropriate. Marc |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
Marc Ramsey wrote "OK, I'm curious. How many of you have had to recover
from a fully developed (greater than one turn), unintentional spin that occurred during normal non-aerobatic flight?" [snip] Not me personally, but I have known, or known of, several pilots who did. Most died, after cable breaks, mismanaged aftermath, and spins into the ground from about 600 feet. Of two who survived, one couldn't explain why he didn't effect prompt recovery - has since given up gliding. The other I referred to earlier - didn't realise it was a spin, thought tail had come off. You may not get many first person replies, because those who did are mostly no longer with us. I would hope our training regimes strive to prevent too many more, not only by Eric Greenwell's 4, 3 and 2 (which I entirely support) but also by 1, time and again, until people no longer fail to realise what they have done when they somehow skip over 4, 3, and 2, stop panicking, and can recover. Chris N. |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
Chris Nicholas wrote:
Marc Ramsey wrote: "OK, I'm curious. How many of you have had to recover from a fully developed (greater than one turn), unintentional spin that occurred during normal non-aerobatic flight?" [snip] Not me personally, but I have known, or known of, several pilots who did. Most died, after cable breaks, mismanaged aftermath, and spins into the ground from about 600 feet. Of two who survived, one couldn't explain why he didn't effect prompt recovery - has since given up gliding. The other I referred to earlier - didn't realise it was a spin, thought tail had come off. What I asked is if anyone here has properly recognized a spin entry, immediately attempted recovery, and not been able to do so in well under a turn. For my own education, I would like to know the circumstances. You may not get many first person replies, because those who did are mostly no longer with us. I would hope our training regimes strive to prevent too many more, not only by Eric Greenwell's 4, 3 and 2 (which I entirely support) but also by 1, time and again, until people no longer fail to realise what they have done when they somehow skip over 4, 3, and 2, stop panicking, and can recover. I feel that I, personally, benefit a great deal more from practicing to properly recognize and recover from a spin entry immediately, than I do from practicing initiating a spin, holding it for a few turns, then recovering. Marc |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
Marc Ramsey wrote:
OK, I'm curious. How many of you have had to recover from a fully developed (greater than one turn), unintentional spin that occurred during normal non-aerobatic flight? Well I haven't. An interesting aside, especially in view of the comments about spinning (or not) ballasted. I still have on my shelf a copy of George Moffat's "Winning on the Wind" which includes his account of the 1970 Worlds at Marfa (which he won). He mentions a hair-raising inadvertent spin in the (presumably ballasted) Nimbus 1 in which he lost 1500 ft and recovered by "flexing the floppy wings by yanking on the stick". Don't try this at home. -- Soar the big sky The real name on the left is richard |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
In article ,
Marc Ramsey wrote: Chris Nicholas wrote: Marc Ramsey wrote: "OK, I'm curious. How many of you have had to recover from a fully developed (greater than one turn), unintentional spin that occurred during normal non-aerobatic flight?" [snip] In slightly more than 1000 hours in all types of soaring, in ships ranging from old wood, old metal, old glass, and new glass, I have never had any inadvertant spin go more than 1/2 turn. That was in a 1-26 that went "over the top" with me due to a terrrifically strong gust in a turbulent thermal. Took me a sec to realize it was a spin entry and not just the gust overpowering my aileron control. I have witnessed two fully developed unintentional spins. Both by the same pilot in two different ships. First was in a Ka-6 at altitude. I was cruising over to join this fellow in a thermal when he just tucked and spun two rotations before affecting recovery. He made a rather excited radio call about the glider "spinning out from under him". I chose not to join him in that or any other thermal. The second I saw from the ground. The same guy was returning to the airport too low in an SGS 1-23D. On entry to downwind (estimated to be about 700 agl), the nose dropped sharply and the glider rotated a bit more than one full rotation. We all thought he was going to buy the farm on that one. Fortunately, he recovered and pulled back to wings level with about 200 feet to spare (we lost him behind the trees from our viewing angle). He managed to land on the airport but didn't make the runway. He stopped flying gliders after that. |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
Earlier, Marc Ramsey wrote:
OK, I'm curious. How many of you have had to recover from a fully developed (greater than one turn), unintentional spin that occurred during normal non- aerobatic flight? I've watched an ASW-20, flown by a well-respected pilot, flick into a spin while thermalling. Including the recovery, it went about a turn and a half. The thing that impressed me about it was the dynamic and asymmetric flexing of the wings in the entry. I seem to recall that it was an over-the-top entry, but I could be wrong on that. I have no idea what precipitated the entry, but I can say that it made more of an impression on my opinion of the ship than on my opinion of the pilot. I came away from that incident wondering to what degree the limber structures of second-generation composite wings might interact with hard-to-predict post-stall aerodynamic behaviors to incite spin entries and perhaps inhibit recovery. Thanks, and best regards to all Bob K. |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
During the Dutch Nationals quite a few years ago I was flying a Pik-20D. My
experience with this glider was that it was very reluctant to enter a spin. My son flew an asw-20 borrowed from a friend at the same occasion. While seriously banking at a turnpoint in order to take a photo the glider started a steep turn. After about one full rotation my son managed to stop the spin, but guess what the asw-20 dove straight away in rotation again but now in the other direction. He recovered within one rotation again and came out with the nose of the glider pointing vertically to the ground. Luckely high enough to return to the normal flying mode. We decided that he would fly the PIK-20D in following competitions. Karel, NL "Bob Kuykendall" schreef in bericht ... Earlier, Marc Ramsey wrote: OK, I'm curious. How many of you have had to recover from a fully developed (greater than one turn), unintentional spin that occurred during normal non- aerobatic flight? I've watched an ASW-20, flown by a well-respected pilot, flick into a spin while thermalling. Including the recovery, it went about a turn and a half. The thing that impressed me about it was the dynamic and asymmetric flexing of the wings in the entry. I seem to recall that it was an over-the-top entry, but I could be wrong on that. I have no idea what precipitated the entry, but I can say that it made more of an impression on my opinion of the ship than on my opinion of the pilot. I came away from that incident wondering to what degree the limber structures of second-generation composite wings might interact with hard-to-predict post-stall aerodynamic behaviors to incite spin entries and perhaps inhibit recovery. Thanks, and best regards to all Bob K. |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
On 29 Jan 2004 21:46:51 GMT, Bob Kuykendall
wrote: I've watched an ASW-20, flown by a well-respected pilot, flick into a spin while thermalling. Including the recovery, it went about a turn and a half. The thing that impressed me about it was the dynamic and asymmetric flexing of the wings in the entry. I seem to recall that it was an over-the-top entry, but I could be wrong on that. I have no idea what precipitated the entry, but I can say that it made more of an impression on my opinion of the ship than on my opinion of the pilot. Typical for an ASW-20 in flap setting 4. My only unintentional spin also happened in a 20. At flap setting 4 the 20's departure can be aprupt and if the CG is halfways backwards it immediately enters a spin with an over-the-top entry if not immediate corrective measures (anti-spinwise rudder, flaps to neutral or even negative) are applied. Time from stall to spin less than two seconds. Really impressive. My spin happened when I was hit by strong lift while flying along a cloud street at very low speed (below 75 kp/h) and flap setting 4. I consciously delayed my correction with the rudder when the 20 began to turn towards one wing because I wanted to see what would happen, and was amazed how quickly I was going trough inverted into a fully-developed spin. Immediate application of rudder had prevented that, and at neutral or even flaps the 20 has very docile stall manners. Bye Andreas |
#9
|
|||
|
|||
Marc:
I had an unintentional spin from a thermalling turn in a Baby Lark. There was no warning (at least that I noticed), the entry was over the top and the glider ended up spinning oposite the direction I had been thermalling. Once I realized that it was spinning, it recovered normally but I lost a lot of altitude before I figured it out. At 12,000 feet where it happened, it was a non-event. At 1,000 feet it most likely would have killed me. In turning stalls, this particular Baby Lark ALWAYS dropped a wing, but this was quite different. In a turning stall, my own ship just mushes until the nose drops. It will spin, but it has to be put there. The Lark was, BTW, a rental ship and I don't remember any special emphasis on its spin characteristics during my checkout. I continued to fly it afterwards until it was destroyed by someone who tried to land it perpendicular to a road. I never let it get slow near the ground or unintentionally again, though. Ray Warshaw Marc Ramsey wrote in message om... |
#10
|
|||
|
|||
Bob Kuykendall wrote in message ...
Earlier, Marc Ramsey wrote: OK, I'm curious. How many of you have had to recover from a fully developed (greater than one turn), unintentional spin that occurred during normal non- aerobatic flight? I've watched an ASW-20, flown by a well-respected pilot, flick into a spin while thermalling. Including the recovery, it went about a turn and a half. The thing that impressed me about it was the dynamic and asymmetric flexing of the wings in the entry. I seem to recall that it was an over-the-top entry, but I could be wrong on that. I have no idea what precipitated the entry, but I can say that it made more of an impression on my opinion of the ship than on my opinion of the pilot. I came away from that incident wondering to what degree the limber structures of second-generation composite wings might interact with hard-to-predict post-stall aerodynamic behaviors to incite spin entries and perhaps inhibit recovery. Thanks, and best regards to all Bob K. Do you also mean high aspect ratio wings with poorly glued spar caps? |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
AOPA Stall/Spin Study -- Stowell's Review (8,000 words) | Rich Stowell | Aerobatics | 28 | January 2nd 09 02:26 PM |
Spin Training | Captain Wubba | Piloting | 25 | April 12th 04 02:11 PM |
12 Dec 2003 - Today’s Military, Veteran, War and National Security News | Otis Willie | Naval Aviation | 0 | December 12th 03 11:01 PM |
Cessna 150 Price Outlook | Charles Talleyrand | Owning | 80 | October 16th 03 02:18 PM |
AOPA Stall/Spin Study -- Stowell's Review (8,000 words) | Rich Stowell | Piloting | 25 | September 11th 03 01:27 PM |