If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
DC X11 vs Bose
Tried both the DC X11 and the Bose over a 15 hour holiday trip. Short
version: The DC got returned and I'm keeping the Bose. It wasn't a tough call in my mind. Longer version: I've had a DC H10-80 for 17 years now. About 10 years ago I had Headsets Inc add their ANR kit to it. That all continues to work fine, but it does get tiring after 6 hours or so due to the weight and clamping. I liked the DC X 11 in the shop, but their reviews I've seen have been somewhat negative. So I got a set and a set of the Bose and compared them on the trip. Compared to my old H10-80s, both the X 11 and the Bose are lighter, have significantly less perceived clamping pressure, and more effective ANR. So state of the are has evidently advanced. I really wanted to like the X 11s - some nice added features and less money. I found the ANR on the X 11s to be less effective than the Bose, and the speakers to produce sound that was "thinner" - less full and rich. But for our needs the X 11 was useless. It evidently depends on a very tight/effective seal on your head. If that seal is disturbed - even by turning your head and flexing - the X 11s will 'thum'. That is somewhat annoying, but if you wear glasses - as both of us do - you can't get a consistent seal, and the slightest movement causes the 'thum'. Short of holding both hands over your ears and applying constant significant pressure to the headset, I don't see a way these can be used with glasses. The Bose, by contrast, doesn't 'thum'. If the seal on the Bose is less than perfect - due to glasses or movement - their white noise level simply increases slightly. Noticeable if you're looking for it but not annoying. I like the music and phone inputs on the DC and their price, and my DCs have been good to me - but the fact that the X 11s simply 'don't work' in my environment negates all of that. The Bose has better/fuller sound, better (to me) ANR, and works with no fuss or muss. We kept the Bose. It was an easy decision. |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
DC X11 vs Bose
Dave Anderer wrote:
We kept the Bose. It was an easy decision. Thanks for the feedback, Dave. I have two Bose now and am considering slowly adding more for additional passengers/family. When the DCs came out, I was very curious about how they stood up to the Bose. -- Peter |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
DC X11 vs Bose
Hi Dave!
Could you point me to the "Negative Reviews" of the DC X-11? I posted several time on various groups in the past looking for comments .... very little response.... and no negatives on the DC's, some negatives on the Bose... although both considered very good. You are correct on the "richer " sound of the Bose though. They sound better when music is playing, but the coms.. dono We are currently testing them "side by each".. And I wear glasses... I am going to try and duplicate the symtoms you describe.. We are now BOTH tending to keep the DC's, but not by much!.. Did you happen to test the DC's with the Bose earpads? (they fit!) We are thinking his may be the ultimate combo... (?) Dave On Sat, 23 Dec 2006 03:49:30 -0500, Dave Anderer wrote: Tried both the DC X11 and the Bose over a 15 hour holiday trip. Short version: The DC got returned and I'm keeping the Bose. It wasn't a tough call in my mind. Longer version: I've had a DC H10-80 for 17 years now. About 10 years ago I had Headsets Inc add their ANR kit to it. That all continues to work fine, but it does get tiring after 6 hours or so due to the weight and clamping. I liked the DC X 11 in the shop, but their reviews I've seen have been somewhat negative. So I got a set and a set of the Bose and compared them on the trip. Compared to my old H10-80s, both the X 11 and the Bose are lighter, have significantly less perceived clamping pressure, and more effective ANR. So state of the are has evidently advanced. I really wanted to like the X 11s - some nice added features and less money. I found the ANR on the X 11s to be less effective than the Bose, and the speakers to produce sound that was "thinner" - less full and rich. But for our needs the X 11 was useless. It evidently depends on a very tight/effective seal on your head. If that seal is disturbed - even by turning your head and flexing - the X 11s will 'thum'. That is somewhat annoying, but if you wear glasses - as both of us do - you can't get a consistent seal, and the slightest movement causes the 'thum'. Short of holding both hands over your ears and applying constant significant pressure to the headset, I don't see a way these can be used with glasses. The Bose, by contrast, doesn't 'thum'. If the seal on the Bose is less than perfect - due to glasses or movement - their white noise level simply increases slightly. Noticeable if you're looking for it but not annoying. I like the music and phone inputs on the DC and their price, and my DCs have been good to me - but the fact that the X 11s simply 'don't work' in my environment negates all of that. The Bose has better/fuller sound, better (to me) ANR, and works with no fuss or muss. We kept the Bose. It was an easy decision. |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
DC X11 vs Bose
Dave wrote: Hi Dave! Could you point me to the "Negative Reviews" of the DC X-11? http://www.vansairforce.com/communit...ad.php?t=12505 |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
DC X11 vs Bose
Dave-
If possible, would you please post any further results from your comparison. I am in the market for a new headset and the X-11s seem very appealing. I work at and FBO and I have only experienced one customer that flies with them and they loved them (more so than the Bose) and I know he was wearing glasses. Thanks! Jon |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
DC X11 vs Bose
Hi Jon!
Yes I will.. We expiremented with the headsets, and were able to reproduce the issue that Dave (above thread) spoke of..We were successful... DC is sending us new (different) earseals.. We have an extension on the "trial period" to wait for these and test again. I will post the results here.. Cheers! Dave On 11 Jan 2007 09:51:16 -0800, wrote: Dave- If possible, would you please post any further results from your comparison. I am in the market for a new headset and the X-11s seem very appealing. I work at and FBO and I have only experienced one customer that flies with them and they loved them (more so than the Bose) and I know he was wearing glasses. Thanks! Jon |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
DC X11 vs Bose
Dave-
Thanks for the help. I look forward to reading your findings! I Jon Dave wrote: Hi Jon! Yes I will.. We expiremented with the headsets, and were able to reproduce the issue that Dave (above thread) spoke of..We were successful... DC is sending us new (different) earseals.. We have an extension on the "trial period" to wait for these and test again. I will post the results here.. Cheers! Dave On 11 Jan 2007 09:51:16 -0800, wrote: Dave- If possible, would you please post any further results from your comparison. I am in the market for a new headset and the X-11s seem very appealing. I work at and FBO and I have only experienced one customer that flies with them and they loved them (more so than the Bose) and I know he was wearing glasses. Thanks! Jon |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
DC X11 vs Bose
Dave-
Thanks for the help. I look forward to reading your findings! Jon Dave wrote: Hi Jon! Yes I will.. We expiremented with the headsets, and were able to reproduce the issue that Dave (above thread) spoke of..We were successful... DC is sending us new (different) earseals.. We have an extension on the "trial period" to wait for these and test again. I will post the results here.. Cheers! Dave On 11 Jan 2007 09:51:16 -0800, wrote: Dave- If possible, would you please post any further results from your comparison. I am in the market for a new headset and the X-11s seem very appealing. I work at and FBO and I have only experienced one customer that flies with them and they loved them (more so than the Bose) and I know he was wearing glasses. Thanks! Jon |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
OK ! We did the Bose / Dave Clark flight! | Dave | Piloting | 11 | December 27th 06 01:47 AM |
LightSpeed QFR CC ANR vs Bose Aviation X | jbskies | Owning | 6 | December 9th 06 04:27 PM |
Bose active headsets | Matt Johnson | Piloting | 0 | November 22nd 05 08:38 AM |
Bose active headsets | Mark Manes | Piloting | 0 | November 13th 05 01:52 AM |
Bose X | smf | Owning | 5 | July 28th 03 04:22 PM |