If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#11
|
|||
|
|||
Glider accident near Altoona... interview with pilot
Instead of choosing a "SPOT or PLB", why not consider a SPOT and a PLB? In aviation redundancy is good!
Wayne http://www.soaridaho.com/ "brianDG303" wrote in message ... The question I have about this is the effectiveness of the different alert devices while upside down. Would the SPOT get a message out, would the PLB? Where I fly there would be no cellphone coverage and no way to get a fire truck with an airhorn, so it would be SPOT or PLB and a very long wait. Brian |
#12
|
|||
|
|||
Glider accident near Altoona... interview with pilot
On May 17, 8:15*am, brianDG303 wrote:
On May 16, 11:42*am, nimbus wrote: On 16 mai, 19:21, jim archer wrote: "Poor weather conditions, close to the mountains ridges, no outlanding fileds and still having water ballasts full of water? " *was not in the article anywhere Strange? *Not when you consider the pilots actual comments... "winds were pretty strong" "skies were overcast" * "He said he was ridge soaring when his glider stalled and spun into the side of a mountain" *were some of the pilots and authors comments, so I'm not sure what people are getting at here. *Sounds like he is genuinely grateful and amazed to be alive after an admitted stall/spin. Extract out of the provided link : "He was flying lower and lower, without finding lift, and had not dropped his water ballast—which increases stall speed. " The question I have about this is the effectiveness of the different alert devices while upside down. Would the SPOT get a message out, would the PLB? Where I fly there would be no cellphone coverage and no way to get a fire truck with an airhorn, so it would be SPOT or PLB and a very long wait. Brian SPOT needs to see the Globalstar satellites to get a message out. It's a planar antenna and needs to be pointing (mostly) skyward. If you are trapped upside down unless you can push the SPOT messenger outside the cockpit someway the distress signal will not be seen. SPOT will send a 911 distress even if it cannot get a GPS fix. But I suspect it most cases if it can transmit to Gloabalstar then either the SPOT 1 or 2 will get a GPS fix. Although improved GPS performance was one of the claims of the SPOT 2. 406 MHz PLBs use a whip antenna, you have to be able to manually depoy the whip antenna and get it outside say the upside son cockpit, but it would have less sensitivity to orientation (should be held mostly vertical). A 406 MHz ELT with a rod or whip antenna mounted on the upper fueslage surface like on many power aircraft would probalby not work if it survived the crash at all. ELTs antennas installed inside the cockpit may work extremely poorly even in an undamaged glider sitting upright (no ground plane, proximity of conductive surfaces/metalwork and broad shielding from carbon fiber, etc). I have a low confidence that ELTs will activate in significant number of crashes that would cause injury in a glider and given all the hassle with mounting them and trying to find a location for the antenna that will work well (and not be destroyed in likely crash scenarios). I think a 406 MHz PLB (on a parachute harness) is much more likely to be useful than an ELT. The benefit of SPOT tracking is that it has worked up until the point that you have crashed and are upside down. With some flight path guessing and knowledge this gives a useful area to start an aerial search on based on the last 10 minute position report. With very occasional delays of apparently an hour or so for SPOT back-end processing it would take several hours for me to want to really start worrying just based on the SPOT tracking suddenly stopping, but maybe a good time to try tracking people down on radio, radio relay, etc. Hopefully with improved future devices/technology this will improve even more. e.g. ADS-B data could ultimately provide altitude and very frequent updates, but with concern in some area for ADS-B coverage near terrain (e.g. may be an issue for ridge runners, as in this accident). I fly with SPOT tracking, with the SPOT messenger mounted on my canopy rail for good satellite visibility and a 406 MHz PLB with GPS on my parachute harness. And I've got signal mirrors, whistles, etc. carried in the glider and on the parachute. Darryl |
#13
|
|||
|
|||
Glider accident near Altoona... interview with pilot
On May 17, 9:17*am, Darryl Ramm wrote:
On May 17, 8:15*am, brianDG303 wrote: On May 16, 11:42*am, nimbus wrote: On 16 mai, 19:21, jim archer wrote: "Poor weather conditions, close to the mountains ridges, no outlanding fileds and still having water ballasts full of water? " *was not in the article anywhere Strange? *Not when you consider the pilots actual comments... "winds were pretty strong" "skies were overcast" * "He said he was ridge soaring when his glider stalled and spun into the side of a mountain" *were some of the pilots and authors comments, so I'm not sure what people are getting at here. *Sounds like he is genuinely grateful and amazed to be alive after an admitted stall/spin. Extract out of the provided link : "He was flying lower and lower, without finding lift, and had not dropped his water ballast—which increases stall speed. " The question I have about this is the effectiveness of the different alert devices while upside down. Would the SPOT get a message out, would the PLB? Where I fly there would be no cellphone coverage and no way to get a fire truck with an airhorn, so it would be SPOT or PLB and a very long wait. Brian SPOT needs to see the Globalstar satellites to get a message out. It's a planar antenna and needs to be pointing (mostly) skyward. If you are trapped upside down unless you can push the SPOT messenger outside the cockpit someway the distress signal will not be seen. SPOT will send a 911 distress even if it cannot get a GPS fix. But I suspect it most cases if it can transmit to Gloabalstar then either the SPOT 1 or 2 will get a GPS fix. Although improved GPS performance was one of the claims of the SPOT 2. 406 MHz PLBs use a whip antenna, you have to be able to manually depoy the whip antenna and get it outside say the upside son cockpit, but it would have less sensitivity to orientation (should be held mostly vertical). A 406 MHz ELT with a rod or whip antenna mounted on the upper fueslage surface like on many power aircraft would probalby not work if it survived the crash at all. ELTs antennas installed inside the cockpit may work extremely poorly even in an undamaged glider sitting upright (no ground plane, proximity of conductive surfaces/metalwork and broad shielding from carbon fiber, etc). I have a low confidence that ELTs will activate in significant number of crashes that would cause injury in a glider and given all the hassle with mounting them and trying to find a location for the antenna that will work well (and not be destroyed in likely crash scenarios). I think a 406 MHz PLB (on a parachute harness) is much more likely to be useful than an ELT. The benefit of SPOT tracking is that it has worked up until the point that you have crashed and are upside down. With some flight path guessing and knowledge this gives a useful area to start an aerial search on based on the last 10 minute position report. With very occasional delays of apparently an hour or so for SPOT back-end processing it would take several hours for me to want to really start worrying just based on the SPOT tracking suddenly stopping, but maybe a good time to try tracking people down on radio, radio relay, etc. Hopefully with improved future devices/technology this will improve even more. e.g. ADS-B data could ultimately provide altitude and very frequent updates, but with concern in some area for ADS-B coverage near terrain (e.g. may be an issue for ridge runners, as in this accident). I fly with SPOT tracking, with the SPOT messenger mounted on my canopy rail for good satellite visibility and a 406 MHz PLB with GPS on my parachute harness. And I've got signal mirrors, whistles, etc. carried in the glider and on the parachute. Darryl- Hide quoted text - - Show quoted text - Only addressing the upside down SPOT question -and purely anecdotal but my SPOT 1 unit is upside down on my patio at home and tracking away.. So far the first and third messages got through and the second one was lost. YMMV -jim |
#14
|
|||
|
|||
Glider accident near Altoona... interview with pilot
Off PLB and spot for a moment, does anyone know what happened here?
Was this an altoona crossing that ended halfway up the ridge, not enough to ridge soar? If so, northbound or southbound? Or was it on the back ridge behind the Altoona gap? John Cochrane |
#15
|
|||
|
|||
Glider accident near Altoona... interview with pilot
We often note how some pilots incorrectly fly directly over the crest
of a mountain, rather than above the steeper slope which may be well in front, and lower than the crest. The wind goes up the slope, level over the crest, then down the back side. There are many places where the top of a mountain is well back behind the lower, steeper part of the ridge. Being low and slow over the crest may place the pilot at considerable risk if it is not possibe to glide upwind to the steeper slope. The book, "Ridge Soaring The Bald Eagle Ridge" explains this. Tom Knauff |
|
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
Glider accident in France claims two | zurchman | Soaring | 1 | July 9th 09 01:53 AM |
Reno Newspaper Defends Reporting on Glider Accident | SoarPoint | Soaring | 15 | September 1st 06 07:49 AM |
Glider accident near San Antonio | Duster | Soaring | 0 | June 26th 06 08:43 PM |
TV Interview With Pilot From ADIZ Incident | Jay Beckman | Piloting | 64 | May 27th 05 11:38 AM |
Interview of Finnish Curtiss Hawk 75 pilot Jarl Arnkil | Jukka O. Kauppinen | Military Aviation | 0 | January 31st 04 05:42 PM |