If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
SkyTec Starter sticking?
Hey all. I put a lightweight SkyTec starter on my Cherokee 180 a bit over a
year ago. Recently, I've begun to notice that it's sticking in the ring gear on the engine for a second or two after startup. I thought it would be like a stock starter and require some silicone spray, but on a whim I called SkyTec. They said that this is normal. Since it's a permanent-magnet motor, when you shut off the power it generates enough juice to keep the solenoid engaged as it spins down. Consequently, there's a sprag clutch to prevent the engine from driving it in this condition forever. I'll buy the argument, but recently I've noticed it more. Any thoughts on this from people who've experienced this? I'm sure that little gear is haulin' ass with the engine running a 800-1000 RPM on startup. It's almost a "whiz-rattle"... sprag going bad? Sticky shaft? Worn ring gear? Do I worry too much... shut up and fly it? Thanks, -Cory -- ************************************************** *********************** * Cory Papenfuss * * Electrical Engineering candidate Ph.D. graduate student * * Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University * ************************************************** *********************** |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
I wonder what the overall opinion of SkyTech is? Personally, my advice is to
ignore anything they say. I have not been happy with my experience. They always have an excuse not to honor the warranty, and I am tired of sending them money. It seems to be a scam to get you to keep coming back to them for repairs. Next time, I intend to igmore the warranty, and just buy a new starter from someone else. wrote in message ... Hey all. I put a lightweight SkyTec starter on my Cherokee 180 a bit over a year ago. Recently, I've begun to notice that it's sticking in the ring gear on the engine for a second or two after startup. I thought it would be like a stock starter and require some silicone spray, but on a whim I called SkyTec. They said that this is normal. Since it's a permanent-magnet motor, when you shut off the power it generates enough juice to keep the solenoid engaged as it spins down. Consequently, there's a sprag clutch to prevent the engine from driving it in this condition forever. I'll buy the argument, but recently I've noticed it more. Any thoughts on this from people who've experienced this? I'm sure that little gear is haulin' ass with the engine running a 800-1000 RPM on startup. It's almost a "whiz-rattle"... sprag going bad? Sticky shaft? Worn ring gear? Do I worry too much... shut up and fly it? Thanks, -Cory -- ************************************************** *********************** * Cory Papenfuss * * Electrical Engineering candidate Ph.D. graduate student * * Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University * ************************************************** *********************** |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
|
#4
|
|||
|
|||
Interesting. I was thinking a free-wheeling diode might help the situation,
but in order do it, you'd need a true isolator-type diode arrangement. That would require a diode in the starter motor path... not too great of an idea (WAY too much current to be reasonable/reliable). The separate contactor for the solenoid would probably work fine, but the FAA goons are already circling on that one. It's not a PMA'd replacement if you need to install additional stuff on the airframe. Then it's an STC and would require more certification and paperwork, etc. The more I think about it, the more I realize that it was probably a necessary compromise. Even if you put the contactor *ON* the starter for just the solenoid, there's no way for it to "know" that the voltage on the starter motor lug is from the battery vs. the back EMF in the motor. I suppose you could measure the motor current with a shunt (haha!) or winding, but again... it's more complicated and failure-prone. The system they have is safe and simple, if a bit inelegant. I doubt the starter gear could damage the ring gear much since there's no load on it at the time. All it's doing is free-wheeling the sprag clutch. I suppose it would be good to keep the RPMs as low as possible until it stops (but then again I do that anyway while the oil pressure comes up). Interesting... I think it might even be worth it for the 10 lb weight savings, though. -Cory -- ************************************************** *********************** * Cory Papenfuss * * Electrical Engineering candidate Ph.D. graduate student * * Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University * ************************************************** *********************** |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
B. Jensen wrote:
: Cory, : I have had 2 lightweight Skytec starters in the past. I had problems : with both! (one completely ruined my ring gear $$$) : I now use the B&C LW starter on my Lycoming IO-360, and it has been : flawless. My opinion, get rid of the Skytec and get a B&C....from : personal experience. : BTW, if you want to get rid of the sticking shaft on the Skytec, you : must get rid of the small jumper wire on the unit and rewire the ground. : BJ This information may have been nice to know when we decided to go with Skytec last year when our old started broke. It's only a year old, so we'll stick with it for awhile. It definately starts better and weighs less. How did the starter hose your ring gear? Did it just never let go? I'm interested in the "mod" (legal or otherwise... just info) for the sticking shaft. I haven't looked at it recently to see how it's wired. -Cory -- ************************************************** *********************** * Cory Papenfuss * * Electrical Engineering candidate Ph.D. graduate student * * Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University * ************************************************** *********************** |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
Cory,
The ring gear was ruined because the starter gear stayed extended too long after the engine started. Thus the starter gear broke off the ring gear teeth. This mod (bypass) is only for experimental aircraft usage only. Basically the jumper wire retains residual power for a second or two after the start switch is released, and cases the starter to stay engaged. If the jumper wire is removed, then all power is removed immediately from the starter when the ignition switch is released. I don't remember the exact wiring mod, but it was easy to do. If you call Skytec and tell them you have an experimental aircraft, they "might" give you the diagram. I learned of it when I took my Skytec to an automotive starter repair shop, and they were dumbfounded that Skytec used the jumper wire the way they do. They gave me the correct instructions on how it "should" be wired. The Skytec is basically a Ford automotive starter, so any automotive starter repair shop can probably help you. It's been several years since I switched to the B&C, so I don't remember the details offhand. VERY happy with the B&C! BJ wrote: B. Jensen wrote: : Cory, : I have had 2 lightweight Skytec starters in the past. I had problems : with both! (one completely ruined my ring gear $$$) : I now use the B&C LW starter on my Lycoming IO-360, and it has been : flawless. My opinion, get rid of the Skytec and get a B&C....from : personal experience. : BTW, if you want to get rid of the sticking shaft on the Skytec, you : must get rid of the small jumper wire on the unit and rewire the ground. : BJ This information may have been nice to know when we decided to go with Skytec last year when our old started broke. It's only a year old, so we'll stick with it for awhile. It definately starts better and weighs less. How did the starter hose your ring gear? Did it just never let go? I'm interested in the "mod" (legal or otherwise... just info) for the sticking shaft. I haven't looked at it recently to see how it's wired. -Cory |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
I had a MagnaFlite on the O-360 on my Tiger and it worked
great. wrote in message ... Hey all. I put a lightweight SkyTec starter on my Cherokee 180 a bit over a year ago. Recently, I've begun to notice that it's sticking in the ring gear on the engine for a second or two after startup. I thought it would be like a stock starter and require some silicone spray, but on a whim I called SkyTec. They said that this is normal. Since it's a permanent-magnet motor, when you shut off the power it generates enough juice to keep the solenoid engaged as it spins down. Consequently, there's a sprag clutch to prevent the engine from driving it in this condition forever. I'll buy the argument, but recently I've noticed it more. Any thoughts on this from people who've experienced this? I'm sure that little gear is haulin' ass with the engine running a 800-1000 RPM on startup. It's almost a "whiz-rattle"... sprag going bad? Sticky shaft? Worn ring gear? Do I worry too much... shut up and fly it? Thanks, -Cory -- ************************************************** *********************** * Cory Papenfuss * * Electrical Engineering candidate Ph.D. graduate student * * Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University * ************************************************** *********************** |
#9
|
|||
|
|||
B. Jensen wrote:
: Cory, : The ring gear was ruined because the starter gear stayed extended too : long after the engine started. Thus the starter gear broke off the ring : gear teeth. : This mod (bypass) is only for experimental aircraft usage only. : Basically the jumper wire retains residual power for a second or two : after the start switch is released, and cases the starter to stay : engaged. If the jumper wire is removed, then all power is removed : immediately from the starter when the ignition switch is released. I Cory, it sounds like this is the 2 starter contactor situation like I mentioned. The jumper wire he's referring to goes between the solenoid and the PM motor itself. I liked your idea about a freewheeling diode, but you'd need a series diode on the input to the PM motor too (to keep the voltage in the PM motor to freewheeling diode circuit). I wouldn't worry about the current handling capacity here, 600 A diodes are easy to get, but the Vf of the diode would probably be like 1.0V. When cranking the voltage at the PM motor is probably only about 6 or 7 V (piper uses a 6V contactor for the starter) so 1V lost in the diode is a large fraction of the available power! -- Aaron Coolidge |
#10
|
|||
|
|||
wrote in message ... Hey all. I put a lightweight SkyTec starter on my Cherokee 180 a bit over a year ago. Recently, I've begun to notice that it's sticking in the ring gear on the engine for a second or two after startup. A friend of mine installed one of those SkyTecs on his O-200. It was mounted on the rear accessory case. On final a large chunk of his crankcase blew out and he damn near didn't make it to the runway. I tore down the engine and saw all the damage including the rearmost connecting rod where the big end struck the starter pinion pivot, a device used on the original starter, and shoved it up through the crankcase. Now how this pinion pivot came loose from its dowel securing it in place I have yet to understand. The FAA, so I understand, is investigating this problem as well as many more with the SkyTec starter. |
|
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
Starter Questions | Aaron Coolidge | Owning | 4 | June 30th 04 02:52 PM |
Stuck starter solenoid? | Paul Lee | Home Built | 4 | April 16th 04 02:58 PM |
LIghtweight starter recommendations for PA24-250? | Chris Kennedy | Owning | 4 | April 8th 04 12:01 AM |
Starter selection -- seeking input | [email protected] | Owning | 3 | April 5th 04 12:43 AM |
Sticking Starter | Wayne | Owning | 5 | September 2nd 03 07:26 PM |