If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
|
#1
|
|||
|
|||
"Joy of Soaring" Book
On Sep 6, 2:37*pm, Bill D wrote:
On Sep 5, 12:24*pm, Tom wrote: The SSA has recently mailed a letter to the membership regarding the continuing unacceptable accident rate. Studies have shown one of the primary reasons for a high accident rate is a fundemental lack of knowledge. The Joy of Soaring was written as a simple coffee table book. It was never designed to be a flight training manual. Tom Knauff Right on all points. Bill Daniels I always found any knowledge is a good thing, the Joy of Soaring is a wonderful place to start and expand on from it's basic concepts, speaking for myself I am/was no Chuck Yeager and anything I can learn from is welcomed.. |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
"Joy of Soaring" Book
On 9/6/2011 1:08 PM, ray conlon wrote:
On Sep 6, 2:37 pm, Bill wrote: On Sep 5, 12:24 pm, wrote: The SSA has recently mailed a letter to the membership regarding the continuing unacceptable accident rate. Studies have shown one of the primary reasons for a high accident rate is a fundemental lack of knowledge. The Joy of Soaring was written as a simple coffee table book. It was never designed to be a flight training manual. Tom Knauff Right on all points. Bill Daniels I always found any knowledge is a good thing, the Joy of Soaring is a wonderful place to start and expand on from it's basic concepts, speaking for myself I am/was no Chuck Yeager and anything I can learn from is welcomed.. "What Ray said." N.B.: I greatly respect Tom Knauff's opinions regarding instruction methodologies, the importance of the law of primacy, which books do a better/not-so-good job presenting the basics, etc. Why? Quantity of students instructed-to-license: Tom Knauff - Lots, over 3+ decades. Me - Zero. That said, and with a nod to the law of primacy's power over what Tom calls the reptilian part of our brain (which Tom argues takes over in moments of great stress), the rational part of my brain genuinely struggles with the precept that 'proper training' in conjunction with 'accurate self-generated continuing analyses' are INcapable of overcoming the law of primacy. In a nutshell, that's what (any) training is all about. In other words, even if a person has - for whatever reason and in whatever manner - managed to initially learn some bad/incorrect/potentially-life-threatening information prior to obtaining 'Knauff-worthy' instruction on the matter, I'm inclined to believe that the new information can indeed permanently and successfully replace the old/bad/incorrect information...even in moments of great stress. For example, consider stalls. I dare say some measurable percentage of existing glider pilots once thought pulling back on the stick was 'the thing to do,' even if only when 10 years old. I also believe it's possible for this bad information to be 'trained out of wannabe pilots.' It may take more time, and it's probably the wise instructor who tends to probe new-to-them, ab-initio students' concepts of certain potentially life-threatening situations/ideas/concepts (e.g. stalls - what they are and what to do about incipient ones). In any event, I'd expect some insightful (aka 'sneaky') instruction to see if said student really *has* absorbed the correct idea(s) and applies 'em when immediately necessary; in hindsight, I realized my instructor did precisely this. Consequently I tend to think it's somewhat misguided thinking to hold 'bad == *initial* == ideas' up as the primary contributor to the U.S. soaring community's dismal safety record of the past two summers. That's not to suggest some misguided thinking has NOT contributed, though. Hence, "What Ray said." Information is good. Prior bogus 'knowledge' (may? can? might?) make it more difficult to retrain us, but should not make it impossible to do so. Bob W. P.S. I rather enjoyed "The Joy of Soaring" when it was loaned to me way back in 1972 when I got into the sport, because I inhaled anything I could get my hands on regarding soaring and flight. I never felt it hurt me in any way...nor did I ever imagine it was the end all and be all in written soaring flight instruction. |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
"Joy of Soaring" Book
On Sep 6, 2:37*pm, Bill D wrote:
On Sep 5, 12:24*pm, Tom wrote: The SSA has recently mailed a letter to the membership regarding the continuing unacceptable accident rate. Studies have shown one of the primary reasons for a high accident rate is a fundemental lack of knowledge. The Joy of Soaring was written as a simple coffee table book. It was never designed to be a flight training manual. Tom Knauff Right on all points. Bill Daniels Again: Whose studies? Published Where? From the title page "The Joy of Soaring -- A Training Manual" From the Forward "...As part of the preparation of this manual, its authors visited numerous gliding schools from coast to coast in order to ensure that the text represented the best practices of commercial and club schools as well as to hear the ideas of many prominent soaring pilots....." etc. etc. written by Harner Selvidge, SSA training manual project manager. From the Acknowledgements: "This training manual had its genesis in a suggestion by Mrs. Catherine Hiller, SSA governor of Mass. As a member of the FAA Women's Advisory Committee for Aeronautics she proposed that FAA publish a glider training manual similar to the one they have for power pilots, and that it be prepared for FAA by SSA... SSA undertook the complete job of preparation and publishing on its own. The real authors of this manual are the operators and instructors of the following schools and clubs as well as other individual pilots who gave so generously of their time and experience to make this manual possible and even authoritative...." Okay, so I think we can dispense with the notion that Joy of Soaring was not intended to be flight training manual. I still want to know what objective study has been done and published that supports the claim that pilots are crashing due to "fundamental lack of knowledge". This is a serious subject, it deserves better than sweeping statements without backing and opinion asserted as fact. -Evan Ludeman / T8 |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
"Joy of Soaring" Book
"T8" wrote in message ... I still want to know what objective study has been done and published that supports the claim that pilots are crashing due to "fundamental lack of knowledge". This is a serious subject, it deserves better than sweeping statements without backing and opinion asserted as fact. And I would like to see the logical "dotted line" from this particular book to our (admittedly terrible) accident rate. ....because I have yet to see where one has anything to do with the other. Vaughn |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
"Joy of Soaring" Book
On Sep 5, 11:24*am, Tom wrote:
The Joy of Soaring was written as a simple coffee table book. It was never designed to be a flight training manual. That merits a big ol' [citation needed] in my mind. The foundation for this assertion would be...? Thanks, Bob K. |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
"Joy of Soaring" Book
On Sep 7, 10:02*am, Bob Kuykendall wrote:
On Sep 5, 11:24*am, Tom wrote: The Joy of Soaring was written as a simple coffee table book. It was never designed to be a flight training manual. That merits a big ol' [citation needed] in my mind. The foundation for this assertion would be...? Thanks, Bob K. On the contrary...From the forward of the book; "The title of this Book, "The Joy of Soaring-A Training Manual" may at first seem like a contradiction, but this is not the case...." Signed by Harner Selvidge, SSA Training Manual, Project Manager. It is spelled out quite clearly that it is a training manual, and was in fact part of the training syllabus at Schweizer Soaring School, whose staff including the schools owners, manager and chief test pilot contributed to its content, as did many other notable soaring pilots from around the country. Mike Carris |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
"Joy of Soaring" Book
Response from Tom Knauff:
Sorry for the delay. We have been busy pushing back the flood waters. It was more than 50 years ago when I began learning to fly, more than 40 when I began to learn to fly gliders. The first training manual (fortunately) was “Stick and Rudder” by Wolfgang Langeweische. My glider flight instructor was from Germany, and recommended Derek Piggott's book, “Gliding.” During flight training, (power and gliders) I experienced differing opinions how things are done as I switched from instructor to instructor. In 1975, Doris and I started Ridge Soaring Gliderport. Shortly after the school opened, we attempted to conform with the national standards, and ordered the SSA recommended flight training manual, “The Joy of Soaring,” and sold it to the students. It soon became apparent this book contained information different than the other texts. Eventually, we stopped using the SSA manual because of these differences, and concerns about complying with flight training standards established by other countries. Derek Piggot first came to the USA at my invitation. He spent considerable time at Ridge Soaring Gliderport, and I returned the favor with a couple of visits to the United Kingdom. Wolfgang Langeweishe made several visits to our gliderport at my invitation, and we had many conversations about flight training matters. I don't recall the year, (late '70s?) however, the SSA had a convention in California, and I was fortunate to have a lengthy conversation with the author of "The Joy of Soaring." When asked about some of the issues about "The Joy of Soaring," he told me the book was not originally intended to be a flight training manual. It was originally only to be a coffee table book. This explains the limited scope of the book. The laws of learning include the “law of primacy,” which states “the first experiences creates a strong, almost unshakable impression.” This means what is taught the first time must be correct and complete. Further, correcting what is incorrectly taught the first time can be very difficult. It is very important for first presentations of information be correct. The FAA also is contributing to the horrendous safety problems our sport is experiencing with the publication of the seriously flawed “Glider Flying Handbook.” I am sure every experienced glider flight instructor recognizes the numerous errors in this publication. The soaring community accknowledges the safety problems the community has experienced for many years. Despite a highly educated, mature population, the fatality rate in our sport is worse than ANY other activity. It is long past time to fix problems and make necessary changes. Tom Knauff |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
"Joy of Soaring" Book
On 9/7/2011 1:22 PM, Tom wrote:
Response from Tom Knauff: Sorry for the delay. We have been busy pushing back the flood waters. It was more than 50 years ago when I began learning to fly, more than 40 when I began to learn to fly gliders. The first training manual (fortunately) was “Stick and Rudder” by Wolfgang Langeweische. My glider flight instructor was from Germany, and recommended Derek Piggott's book, “Gliding.” During flight training, (power and gliders) I experienced differing opinions how things are done as I switched from instructor to instructor. In 1975, Doris and I started Ridge Soaring Gliderport. Shortly after the school opened, we attempted to conform with the national standards, and ordered the SSA recommended flight training manual, “The Joy of Soaring,” and sold it to the students. It soon became apparent this book contained information different than the other texts. Eventually, we stopped using the SSA manual because of these differences, and concerns about complying with flight training standards established by other countries. Derek Piggot first came to the USA at my invitation. He spent considerable time at Ridge Soaring Gliderport, and I returned the favor with a couple of visits to the United Kingdom. Wolfgang Langeweishe made several visits to our gliderport at my invitation, and we had many conversations about flight training matters. I don't recall the year, (late '70s?) however, the SSA had a convention in California, and I was fortunate to have a lengthy conversation with the author of "The Joy of Soaring." When asked about some of the issues about "The Joy of Soaring," he told me the book was not originally intended to be a flight training manual. It was originally only to be a coffee table book. This explains the limited scope of the book. The laws of learning include the “law of primacy,” which states “the first experiences creates a strong, almost unshakable impression.” This means what is taught the first time must be correct and complete. Further, correcting what is incorrectly taught the first time can be very difficult. It is very important for first presentations of information be correct. The FAA also is contributing to the horrendous safety problems our sport is experiencing with the publication of the seriously flawed “Glider Flying Handbook.” I am sure every experienced glider flight instructor recognizes the numerous errors in this publication. The soaring community accknowledges the safety problems the community has experienced for many years. Despite a highly educated, mature population, the fatality rate in our sport is worse than ANY other activity. It is long past time to fix problems and make necessary changes. Tom Knauff It would be very enlightening for those of us who haven't looked at the "Glider Flying Handbook" recently to highlight some of the errors that are in that publication. -- Mike Schumann |
#9
|
|||
|
|||
"Joy of Soaring" Book
Tom wrote:
Response from Tom Knauff: Sorry for the delay. We have been busy pushing back the flood waters. It was more than 50 years ago when I began learning to fly, more than 40 when I began to learn to fly gliders. The first training manual (fortunately) was “Stick and Rudder” by Wolfgang Langeweische. My glider flight instructor was from Germany, and recommended Derek Piggott's book, “Gliding.” During flight training, (power and gliders) I experienced differing opinions how things are done as I switched from instructor to instructor. In 1975, Doris and I started Ridge Soaring Gliderport. Shortly after the school opened, we attempted to conform with the national standards, and ordered the SSA recommended flight training manual, “The Joy of Soaring,” and sold it to the students. It soon became apparent this book contained information different than the other texts. Eventually, we stopped using the SSA manual because of these differences, and concerns about complying with flight training standards established by other countries. Derek Piggot first came to the USA at my invitation. He spent considerable time at Ridge Soaring Gliderport, and I returned the favor with a couple of visits to the United Kingdom. Wolfgang Langeweishe made several visits to our gliderport at my invitation, and we had many conversations about flight training matters. I don't recall the year, (late '70s?) however, the SSA had a convention in California, and I was fortunate to have a lengthy conversation with the author of "The Joy of Soaring." When asked about some of the issues about "The Joy of Soaring," he told me the book was not originally intended to be a flight training manual. It was originally only to be a coffee table book. This explains the limited scope of the book. The laws of learning include the “law of primacy,” which states “the first experiences creates a strong, almost unshakable impression.” This means what is taught the first time must be correct and complete. Further, correcting what is incorrectly taught the first time can be very difficult. It is very important for first presentations of information be correct. The FAA also is contributing to the horrendous safety problems our sport is experiencing with the publication of the seriously flawed “Glider Flying Handbook.” I am sure every experienced glider flight instructor recognizes the numerous errors in this publication. The soaring community accknowledges the safety problems the community has experienced for many years. Despite a highly educated, mature population, the fatality rate in our sport is worse than ANY other activity. It is long past time to fix problems and make necessary changes. Tom Knauff No doubt you will all have read this one from 2005: http://www.gliding.co.uk/accidents/r...s4dtreport.pdf Section 1.1.1 "Surviving Pilot's Statement" seems to say that he tried to recover from a spin by pulling back hard on the stick and lowering the flaps. Is this a translation error, or did a 4DM owner really think this was the correct procedure ? Gilbert |
#10
|
|||
|
|||
"Joy of Soaring" Book
The FAA's "Glider Flying Handbook" and Tom's books.
On Sep 5, 2:10*pm, Carl B wrote: I have just heard that the SSA is no longer going to supply "The Joy of Soaring". *This is the book that I have recommended to ab initio students and it has been well accepted. *What are other instructors recommending to their ab initio students? *Thanks. Carl |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
Feedback needed on Advanced Soaring Made Easy book for Soaring Magazine review | Paul Remde | Soaring | 1 | April 14th 11 03:57 AM |
New aviation history book for Norwegians and Scandinavians "GLADIATOR" | north_weald | Aviation Marketplace | 0 | October 4th 09 07:37 PM |
FS: 1995 "Apollo 13 The Movie Storybook" 1st Edition Book | http://books.google.com/books?id=ifqnAAAACAAJ&dq=inauthor:%22Russ+Manning%22&lr=&as_brr=0&rview=1&so | Aviation Marketplace | 0 | September 10th 09 12:51 PM |
Library Seeks "Soaring" and "Technical Soaring" Magazines | [email protected] | Soaring | 0 | November 18th 08 12:07 AM |
FS: 1986 "Fighting Jets" Hardcover Edition Book | J.R. Sinclair | Aviation Marketplace | 0 | May 7th 06 11:38 AM |