If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
Long wing twisting
I survived an unexpected twisting of my ASH-25 wing a few years back.
The situation was as follows; speed 145 knots, altitude 50 feet (finish line). After receiving my "Good Finish JJ", I initiated a climbing left turn to exchange speed for altitude, about 30 degrees nose up and banked 45 degrees left to reverse my track, to land on the ramp 1/2 mile behind me. To my surprise the ship kept rolling left. I applied full right aileron and rudder and it stopped rolling left, but fill right control input didn't make the ship roll back to level flight. As I climbed and speed decayed, my right turn command eventually became effective and the ship rolled out to level flight. The next day I spoke to the fellow that was on the finish gate. He said the inboard portion of my wing was bent up in the normal high speed bow, but my left wing tip was bent down. He said my wing looked like a sine wave! Why did this happen? I believe the left wing tip dug in as I applied left turn control at high speed. The aileron input caused the outboard section of the left wing to twist (L/E down) resulting in the tip digging in and giving me much more roll than I had commanded. Why did I survive? Because I was in a climb and my airspeed was decreasing. As speed decayed, the wing un-twisted and normal control was restored. Had this happened from level flight, I believe the wing twist (digging in) would have quickly resulted in a nose down attitude and I don't believe it would be possiable to recover from this situation. The wing tip is dug in and causing an un-commanded roll which will shortly cause the nose to drop resulting in even more speed. Opposite aileron won't (can't) make it roll out and back stick won't (can't) make it slow down, it will only tighten the spiral dive. After this experience I placed a personal maximum speed on the ship of 120 knots and was careful to limit my aileron input to about 50% of full throw at that speed. I told the new owner about my experience and recommended he adopt these limits. Is this what happened to Ivans and Egan? JJ Sinclair |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
I seem to recall on my assistant instructors course in '95 that above
maneuvreing speed one should not use any more than 1/3 of full deflection on any control, and in combination even less than that, since that would overstress the aircraft. Isn't it likely that in doing what you did at VNE you were flying the aircraft outside of it's design limits and therefore ran into an aeroelastic phenomenon which caused the wing twisting you observed because the wing had been stressed outside the limits of its torsional stiffness? Rgds, Derrick Steed |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
line). After receiving my "Good Finish JJ", I initiated a climbing left
turn to exchange speed for altitude, about 30 degrees nose up and banked 45 degrees left to reverse my track, to land on the ramp 1/2 mile behind me. To my surprise the ship kept rolling left. I applied full right aileron and rudder and it stopped rolling left, but fill right control input didn't make the ship roll back to level flight. As I climbed and speed decayed, my right turn command eventually became effective and the ship rolled out to level flight. You should have practiced this maneuver at 5000 feet first. That way you have the altitude to recover in case of something unexpected happening.. |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
What is the manoevring speed of an ASH25? Any control deflection above this speed should be a max of one t hird of the total movement -- pawnee_pilot22 ------------------------------------------------------------------------ Posted via OziPilots Online [ http://www.OziPilotsOnline.com.au ] - A website for Australian Pilots regardless of when, why, or what they fly - |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
Well what JJ was asking was not the groups opinion
on what he did...rather was this a possible scenario for the Ivans/Engen accident. An interesting theory...how would the spoilers being deployed have helped/hindered this condition? Interestingly in both these Nimbus crashes, spoilers and/or flaps were deployed to help recover...contrary to the POH. Although no one will really know what happened in the case of the Minden accident. My guess is for a brief few moments...the two pilots may have thought the other had the stick. |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
At 23:06 26 June 2005, Pawnee_Pilot22 wrote:
What is the manoevring speed of an ASH25? Any control deflection above this speed should be a max of one t hird of the total movement -- pawnee_pilot22 My control input was about 1/3 full throw as I started the climbing left turn. Full opposite input was applied only after it wouldn't stop rolling left. My purpose in posting this was to alert other long wing drivers to this potential problem area. JJ ------------------------------------------------------------------ ------ Posted via OziPilots Online [ http://www.OziPilotsOnline.com.au ] - A website for Australian Pilots regardless of when, why, or what they fly - |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
At 21:00 26 June 2005, Jj Sinclair wrote:
Is this what happened to Ivans and Egan? That's Don Engen. The accident reports indicated that the outer wing panels departed following a (more or less) symmetric pull-up, probably out of a spiral dive. It's unlikely that there was much asymmetric twisting at work. The twisting aeroelastic effect comes from high aileron hinge moments associated with high speeds and large control deflections. Happened to my Dad in an F-86 doing max-Q testing below sea level. It's less common at glider speeds, but long, floppy wings might permit it. I consider it a good idea to execute the symmetric maneuver (pull-up) before the asymmetric one (roll), particularly at high speed. This helps to avoid JJ's experience. 9B |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
The accident reports indicated that the outer wing
panels departed following a (more or less) symmetric pull-up, probably out of a spiral dive. It's unlikely that there was much asymmetric twisting at work. My thought was that wing twisting (digging in) might have gotten them (Ivens & Engen) into the spiral dive in the first place. Once you get a big ship pointed down with the speed near red-line and increasing, you might very well have already had the snitz. JJ |
#9
|
|||
|
|||
Great input there JJ.
I dont like flying my ASW22 much above 120knots. There really isnt much point to it either. Wasnt there an ASW17 crash along similar lines to what you describe. Washout over powering the wings structural integrity. Al |
#10
|
|||
|
|||
Thanks for the heads up JJ. I have flown the Nimbus 3D a bit above 120 kts
but it really doesn't like to go that fast (lots of very hard forward pressure required which makes me nervous in that a hiccup ends up in a loop at best and broken wings at worst) so I think that I'll be sticking to less than that for the future. I was taught years ago that smooth control movements not only make aerodynamic sense (less drag) but also make safety sense due to less stress on the aircraft. I don't do strong pulls in anything anymore....I'll leave those to the powered aerobatic dudes. Besides that I've forgotten how to do the tensing excercises so would probably get syncopal! Casey Lenox KC Phoenix |
|
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
Announcing THE book on airshow flying | Dudley Henriques | Piloting | 11 | January 9th 04 07:33 PM |
Tyvek material for wing covers | Eric Greenwell | Soaring | 2 | October 18th 03 04:51 AM |
Props and Wing Warping... was soaring vs. flaping | Wright1902Glider | Home Built | 0 | September 29th 03 03:40 PM |
Across Nevada and Part Way Back (long) | Marry Daniel or David Grah | Soaring | 18 | July 30th 03 08:52 PM |
Wing Extensions | Jay | Home Built | 22 | July 27th 03 12:23 PM |