If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
Chelton vs. Garmin - what am I missing?
Lots of chatter about Garmin's, but no one talks about the Chelton
avionics. Looking at TAP recently it seems the prices are very close to the same for similarly equipped panels. I understand that Garmin appears to be cheaper to piece meal together and that the Chelton appears to be an all or nothing solution, but other than that what am I missing? Why don't I see more Chelton in the discussion groups? |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
Chelton vs. Garmin - what am I missing?
Chelton vs. Garmin - what am I missing?"Jim Carter"
wrote in message news:000501c7292a$c5e31f70$4b01a8c0@omnibook6100.. . Lots of chatter about Garmin's, but no one talks about the Chelton avionics. Looking at TAP recently it seems the prices are very close to the same for similarly equipped panels. I understand that Garmin appears to be cheaper to piece meal together and that the Chelton appears to be an all or nothing solution, but other than that what am I missing? Why don't I see more Chelton in the discussion groups? Are yoy talking about the G1000 are the new G900x & G600. If you are talking about the G1000 then the reason is that they are in planes from the factory and there are a lot more of them. As far as the G900x & G600 I haven't seen much talk about them at all. The G600 seems like it is competing with Chelton but the G900 is like the G1000 in that it has the com/nav/xponder/gps... Of course the G900 is uncertified so it is only available for experimentals. |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
Chelton vs. Garmin - what am I missing?
-----Original Message----- From: Gig 601XL Builder [mailto:wrDOTgiaconaATcox.net] Posted At: Tuesday, December 26, 2006 3:40 PM Posted To: rec.aviation.owning Conversation: Chelton vs. Garmin - what am I missing? Subject: Chelton vs. Garmin - what am I missing? Chelton vs. Garmin - what am I missing?"Jim Carter" wrote in message news:000501c7292a$c5e31f70$4b01a8c0@omnibook6100.. . Lots of chatter about Garmin's, but no one talks about the Chelton avionics. Looking at TAP recently it seems the prices are very close to the same for similarly equipped panels. I understand that Garmin appears to be cheaper to piece meal together and that the Chelton appears to be an all or nothing solution, but other than that what am I missing? Why don't I see more Chelton in the discussion groups? Are yoy talking about the G1000 are the new G900x & G600. If you are talking about the G1000 then the reason is that they are in planes from the factory and there are a lot more of them. As far as the G900x & G600 I haven't seen much talk about them at all. The G600 seems like it is competing with Chelton but the G900 is like the G1000 in that it has the com/nav/xponder/gps... Of course the G900 is uncertified so it is only available for experimentals. I wasn't thinking of any model specifically, but I pulled the 1st Dec issue of TAP just now and was looking at prices. The Chelton EFIS basic system is around 30K and the Garmin Deluxe IFR stack (not G1000) is also around $30K. I haven't even looked at prices for the G900 or G600 yet and haven't seen much on them really. I just find it interesting that Chelton is almost never mentioned on the newsgroups. |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
Chelton vs. Garmin - what am I missing?
Gig 601XL Builder wrote:
Chelton vs. Garmin - what am I missing?"Jim Carter" wrote in message news:000501c7292a$c5e31f70$4b01a8c0@omnibook6100.. . Lots of chatter about Garmin's, but no one talks about the Chelton avionics. Looking at TAP recently it seems the prices are very close to the same for similarly equipped panels. I understand that Garmin appears to be cheaper to piece meal together and that the Chelton appears to be an all or nothing solution, but other than that what am I missing? Why don't I see more Chelton in the discussion groups? Are yoy talking about the G1000 are the new G900x & G600. If you are talking about the G1000 then the reason is that they are in planes from the factory and there are a lot more of them. As far as the G900x & G600 I haven't seen much talk about them at all. The G600 seems like it is competing with Chelton but the G900 is like the G1000 in that it has the com/nav/xponder/gps... Of course the G900 is uncertified so it is only available for experimentals. What are the associated costs? The G900 is $60,000. The G600 is $30,000. How much do the Chelton units cost? |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
Chelton vs. Garmin - what am I missing?
Gig 601XL Builder wrote:
Are yoy talking about the G1000 are the new G900x & G600. If you are talking about the G1000 then the reason is that they are in planes from the factory and there are a lot more of them. As far as the G900x & G600 I haven't seen much talk about them at all. I'm not sure Garmin has shipped any 600's yet. |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
Chelton vs. Garmin - what am I missing?
"Jim Carter" wrote in message news:001001c7293b$f37ccc40$4b01a8c0@omnibook6100.. . I wasn't thinking of any model specifically, but I pulled the 1st Dec issue of TAP just now and was looking at prices. The Chelton EFIS basic system is around 30K and the Garmin Deluxe IFR stack (not G1000) is also around $30K. I haven't even looked at prices for the G900 or G600 yet and haven't seen much on them really. I just find it interesting that Chelton is almost never mentioned on the newsgroups. That's apples and oranges then. The Garmin deluxe IFR stack and the Chelton are two different things. The Chelton replaces the six pack and the IFR stack is a bunch of radios. There was some talk about the Chelton unit a while back in the RAH group but the damn thing is just so pricey that it pushes itself right out of the homebuilt market except for the Lanceaire and high end RVs. As I said in my first reply it's competition in the certified market is the G600 and they cost about the same if I'm not mistaken. |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
Chelton vs. Garmin - what am I missing?
"Ron Natalie" wrote in message ... Gig 601XL Builder wrote: Are yoy talking about the G1000 are the new G900x & G600. If you are talking about the G1000 then the reason is that they are in planes from the factory and there are a lot more of them. As far as the G900x & G600 I haven't seen much talk about them at all. I'm not sure Garmin has shipped any 600's yet. I'm not either. Have they shipped a G900X yet? If I had 60 or 70 K to spend on a panel and had room for the thing it would be very cool. I'll have to live with the Dynon though. |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
Chelton vs. Garmin - what am I missing?
-----Original Message----- From: Gig 601XL Builder [mailto:wrDOTgiaconaATcox.net] Posted At: Tuesday, December 26, 2006 4:53 PM Posted To: rec.aviation.owning Conversation: Chelton vs. Garmin - what am I missing? Subject: Chelton vs. Garmin - what am I missing? .... That's apples and oranges then. The Garmin deluxe IFR stack and the Chelton are two different things. The Chelton replaces the six pack and the IFR stack is a bunch of radios. There was some talk about the Chelton unit a while back in the RAH group but the damn thing is just so pricey that it pushes itself right out of the homebuilt market except for the Lanceaire and high end RVs. As I said in my first reply it's competition in the certified market is the G600 and they cost about the same if I'm not mistaken. I thought the Chelton included the avioncs because of how the 3D maps were being presented. Does Chelton just provide the MFD and EFIS but we have to supply nav and comm from elsewhere? Or am I seeing display only prices for full-up ads? |
#9
|
|||
|
|||
Chelton vs. Garmin - what am I missing?
"Jim Carter" wrote in message news:001201c72944$4d471ed0$4b01a8c0@omnibook6100.. . I thought the Chelton included the avioncs because of how the 3D maps were being presented. Does Chelton just provide the MFD and EFIS but we have to supply nav and comm from elsewhere? Or am I seeing display only prices for full-up ads? The Cheltons have a GPS in them and I, looking at their web site, can't tell if it is IFR certified or not and may just be there for VFR or to display the synthetic vision. But NAVs, COMs and may be even IFR GPS have to come from some where else. They have a pretty extensive list of avionics that work with the unit on their website. |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
Garmin 530 WAAS? | Al G | Instrument Flight Rules | 53 | November 21st 06 11:30 PM |
Missing approach in Garmin 530 database | Viperdoc | Instrument Flight Rules | 11 | April 28th 06 02:10 PM |
Amateur Review of the Garmin GPSMAP 296 GPS | Rhett | Piloting | 10 | March 23rd 05 01:16 AM |
Pirep: Garmin GPSMAP 296 versus 295. (very long) | Jon Woellhaf | Piloting | 12 | September 4th 04 11:55 PM |
Amateur Review of the Garmin GPSMAP 296 GPS | Rhett | Products | 10 | April 29th 04 06:57 AM |