A aviation & planes forum. AviationBanter

If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.

Go Back   Home » AviationBanter forum » rec.aviation newsgroups » Soaring
Site Map Home Register Authors List Search Today's Posts Mark Forums Read Web Partners

Why are side sticks unpopular in sailplanes



 
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
  #21  
Old February 23rd 17, 05:41 PM posted to rec.aviation.soaring
Andreas Maurer
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 345
Default Why are side sticks unpopular in sailplanes

On Wed, 22 Feb 2017 15:00:08 -0800 (PST), Soartech
wrote:

I also flew a gimbaled side-stick for 8 years in a Millennium ultralight sailplane. It was so smooth, natural and comfortable I looked for a sailplane with the same arrangement. But alas, all I could find were clunky setups with sliding sticks. No wonder side sticks get a bad rap in our little world. The center stick is OK, side stick is better, more natural.


Just a question:
How do you fly with a side stick if you need your right hand to, say,
take a leak? Or change a setting on the panel?

Did you train yourself to do all these things with the left hand?
  #22  
Old February 23rd 17, 06:23 PM posted to rec.aviation.soaring
Bob Whelan[_3_]
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 400
Default Why are side sticks unpopular in sailplanes

On 2/23/2017 9:41 AM, Andreas Maurer wrote:
On Wed, 22 Feb 2017 15:00:08 -0800 (PST), Soartech
wrote:

I also flew a gimbaled side-stick for 8 years in a Millennium ultralight
sailplane. It was so smooth, natural and comfortable I looked for a
sailplane with the same arrangement. But alas, all I could find were
clunky setups with sliding sticks. No wonder side sticks get a bad rap in
our little world. The center stick is OK, side stick is better, more
natural.


Just a question: How do you fly with a side stick if you need your right
hand to, say, take a leak? Or change a setting on the panel?

Did you train yourself to do all these things with the left hand?


Oh goody! Is this where the conversation degenerates into increasingly loud
personal protestations of "bestness?"

Color me perplexed to understand how a side stick fundamentally differs from a
center stick in regard to these sorts of matters. Save for my (rightside)
stick hand, every glider cockpit in which I've flown has always depended on
the left hand for everything but (with one exception - and it was in a
center-stick-cockpit) cycling the landing gear. None of them *required*
switching hands to operate anything on the instrument panel.

That said, I understand "natural lefties" might choose - with a center stick -
to set up their instrument panels so as to favor use of the right hand to
operate panel stuff. I also understand the profusion of electronics today with
still-increasing gobs of fiddly bits may - in many a glider pilot mind - make
it "necessary" to use both hands to operate stuff. Coming soon to a glider
cockpit near you - a ship with a one-channel autopilot so both hands can
operate panel bits simultaneously? Ah, progress!

Bob W.
  #23  
Old February 23rd 17, 06:56 PM posted to rec.aviation.soaring
Bruce Hoult
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 961
Default Why are side sticks unpopular in sailplanes

On Thursday, February 23, 2017 at 8:23:23 PM UTC+3, Bob Whelan wrote:
On 2/23/2017 9:41 AM, Andreas Maurer wrote:
On Wed, 22 Feb 2017 15:00:08 -0800 (PST), Soartech
wrote:

I also flew a gimbaled side-stick for 8 years in a Millennium ultralight
sailplane. It was so smooth, natural and comfortable I looked for a
sailplane with the same arrangement. But alas, all I could find were
clunky setups with sliding sticks. No wonder side sticks get a bad rap in
our little world. The center stick is OK, side stick is better, more
natural.


Just a question: How do you fly with a side stick if you need your right
hand to, say, take a leak? Or change a setting on the panel?

Did you train yourself to do all these things with the left hand?


Oh goody! Is this where the conversation degenerates into increasingly loud
personal protestations of "bestness?"

Color me perplexed to understand how a side stick fundamentally differs from a
center stick in regard to these sorts of matters. Save for my (rightside)
stick hand, every glider cockpit in which I've flown has always depended on
the left hand for everything but (with one exception - and it was in a
center-stick-cockpit) cycling the landing gear. None of them *required*
switching hands to operate anything on the instrument panel.

That said, I understand "natural lefties" might choose - with a center stick -
to set up their instrument panels so as to favor use of the right hand to
operate panel stuff. I also understand the profusion of electronics today with
still-increasing gobs of fiddly bits may - in many a glider pilot mind - make
it "necessary" to use both hands to operate stuff. Coming soon to a glider
cockpit near you - a ship with a one-channel autopilot so both hands can
operate panel bits simultaneously? Ah, progress!


Which channel?

Gliders seem to in general be fine hands-off for 30 seconds or so at a time. Usually the thing that makes me nudge the stick first is bank/heading, as it takes quite a lot longer for the phugoid to get out of control.
  #24  
Old February 23rd 17, 09:15 PM posted to rec.aviation.soaring
Jonathon May
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 82
Default Why are side sticks unpopular in sailplanes

At 17:56 23 February 2017, Bruce Hoult wrote:
On Thursday, February 23, 2017 at 8:23:23 PM UTC+3, Bob Whelan wrote:
On 2/23/2017 9:41 AM, Andreas Maurer wrote:
On Wed, 22 Feb 2017 15:00:08 -0800 (PST), Soartech
wrote:

I also flew a gimbaled side-stick for 8 years in a Millennium

ultralight
sailplane. It was so smooth, natural and comfortable I looked for a
sailplane with the same arrangement. But alas, all I could find were
clunky setups with sliding sticks. No wonder side sticks get a bad

rap
in
our little world. The center stick is OK, side stick is better, more
natural.

Just a question: How do you fly with a side stick if you need your

right
hand to, say, take a leak? Or change a setting on the panel?

Did you train yourself to do all these things with the left hand?


Oh goody! Is this where the conversation degenerates into increasingly

loud
personal protestations of "bestness?"

Color me perplexed to understand how a side stick fundamentally differs

from a
center stick in regard to these sorts of matters. Save for my

(rightside)

stick hand, every glider cockpit in which I've flown has always

depended
on
the left hand for everything but (with one exception - and it was in a
center-stick-cockpit) cycling the landing gear. None of them *required*


switching hands to operate anything on the instrument panel.

That said, I understand "natural lefties" might choose - with a center

stick -
to set up their instrument panels so as to favor use of the right hand

to

operate panel stuff. I also understand the profusion of electronics

today
with
still-increasing gobs of fiddly bits may - in many a glider pilot mind

-
make
it "necessary" to use both hands to operate stuff. Coming soon to a

glider
cockpit near you - a ship with a one-channel autopilot so both hands can


operate panel bits simultaneously? Ah, progress!


Which channel?

Gliders seem to in general be fine hands-off for 30 seconds or so at a
time. Usually the thing that makes me nudge the stick first is
bank/heading, as it takes quite a lot longer for the phugoid to get out

of
control.


Is it just me,
With the centre stick I fly with both hands,sometimes at the same time,I
never think about it.
Gear,ballast vent on the right ,brakes ,trim release on left
Center stick has to be best.



  #25  
Old February 23rd 17, 10:32 PM posted to rec.aviation.soaring
sisu1a
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 569
Default Why are side sticks unpopular in sailplanes

On Thursday, February 23, 2017 at 9:23:23 AM UTC-8, Bob Whelan wrote:
On 2/23/2017 9:41 AM, Andreas Maurer wrote:
On Wed, 22 Feb 2017 15:00:08 -0800 (PST), Soartech
wrote:

I also flew a gimbaled side-stick for 8 years in a Millennium ultralight
sailplane. It was so smooth, natural and comfortable I looked for a
sailplane with the same arrangement. But alas, all I could find were
clunky setups with sliding sticks. No wonder side sticks get a bad rap in
our little world. The center stick is OK, side stick is better, more
natural.


Just a question: How do you fly with a side stick if you need your right
hand to, say, take a leak? Or change a setting on the panel?

Did you train yourself to do all these things with the left hand?


Oh goody! Is this where the conversation degenerates into increasingly loud
personal protestations of "bestness?"

Color me perplexed to understand how a side stick fundamentally differs from a
center stick in regard to these sorts of matters. Save for my (rightside)
stick hand, every glider cockpit in which I've flown has always depended on
the left hand for everything but (with one exception - and it was in a
center-stick-cockpit) cycling the landing gear. None of them *required*
switching hands to operate anything on the instrument panel.

That said, I understand "natural lefties" might choose - with a center stick -
to set up their instrument panels so as to favor use of the right hand to
operate panel stuff. I also understand the profusion of electronics today with
still-increasing gobs of fiddly bits may - in many a glider pilot mind - make
it "necessary" to use both hands to operate stuff. Coming soon to a glider
cockpit near you - a ship with a one-channel autopilot so both hands can
operate panel bits simultaneously? Ah, progress!

Bob W.


Ergonomics, human factors... something not touched on yet is that a center stick allows your body to become the 'armrest', which adds a whole lot more nerves to the biological servo feedback loop, plus your leg even gets involved in stabilizing inputs under certain conditions.

A center stick also allows a larger 'throw range', spreading the same inputs across a larger physical area translates into finer granular resolution.

Center stick can be flown with eitehr hand in case you need to do something with your right hand.

Center stick is a longer lever, thus allowing less muscle to hold it steady or affect inputs, which generally translates into increased precision, plus allows the use of 2 hands as Jonothon points out.
  #26  
Old February 23rd 17, 11:34 PM posted to rec.aviation.soaring
Michael Opitz
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 318
Default Why are side sticks unpopular in sailplanes


Is it just me,
With the centre stick I fly with both hands,sometimes at the same

time,I
never think about it.
Gear,ballast vent on the right ,brakes ,trim release on left
Center stick has to be best.



OK, here my glider/slow speed analysis... At the speeds we fly, and
thus the relatively small circle diameters, the outboard wing will be
going marginally faster than the inboard wing. This means that it
creates more lift than the inboard wing due to relative speed alone,
and thus to keep from over-banking I find the need to apply a very
small amount of top aileron (against the turn) in order to keep a
stable bank angle and equalize the lift generated by both wings.
Because the outer wing goes faster, it also generates more drag as
well, so I find that I have to hold slight bottom rudder pressure
along with the top aileron in order to have the yaw string going
straight back.

So, now think about how that translates to operating the stick. With
a center stick, it is easier to make left turns and pull the stick
straight back towards your right elbow and right hip, than it is to
make right turns and be pushing the stick towards your left hip (all
while using your right hand). I have trained myself to fly with
either hand so that I use the opposite hand to the direction I am
thermalling in. George Moffat and Dick Johnson did this as well, so
I am not alone. This may partially explain why so many glider pilots
prefer to make left turns (always flying with their right hands). I
also know that George and Dick initiated right hand turns whenever
they could (in order to set the turn direction of a thermal) as a
competitive trick, knowing that most of their competitors would be
less comfortable in a right hand turn than they were.

Translate this to a gimballed side stick where all motion is in the
wrist, and then I don't believe that the ergonomics will preference
one turn direction over another, but with a center stick there are
good reasons to be able or want to switch hands on the stick.

RO



  #27  
Old February 24th 17, 02:11 AM posted to rec.aviation.soaring
Jonathan St. Cloud
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 1,463
Default Why are side sticks unpopular in sailplanes

I have heard from several very experienced pilots that it is easier to turn left than right, but in my thousands of hours of flying gliders, helicopters and various powered aircraft I have not found this to be true for me, a turn in either direction is the same other than if torque or LTE considerations. A glider has neither consideration. I do try to change thermal direction every other thermal. But I am confused as to why a pilot would think it is easier to turn in one direction.

On Thursday, February 23, 2017 at 2:45:04 PM UTC-8, Michael Opitz wrote:
Is it just me,
With the centre stick I fly with both hands,sometimes at the same

time,I
never think about it.
Gear,ballast vent on the right ,brakes ,trim release on left
Center stick has to be best.



OK, here my glider/slow speed analysis... At the speeds we fly, and
thus the relatively small circle diameters, the outboard wing will be
going marginally faster than the inboard wing. This means that it
creates more lift than the inboard wing due to relative speed alone,
and thus to keep from over-banking I find the need to apply a very
small amount of top aileron (against the turn) in order to keep a
stable bank angle and equalize the lift generated by both wings.
Because the outer wing goes faster, it also generates more drag as
well, so I find that I have to hold slight bottom rudder pressure
along with the top aileron in order to have the yaw string going
straight back.

So, now think about how that translates to operating the stick. With
a center stick, it is easier to make left turns and pull the stick
straight back towards your right elbow and right hip, than it is to
make right turns and be pushing the stick towards your left hip (all
while using your right hand). I have trained myself to fly with
either hand so that I use the opposite hand to the direction I am
thermalling in. George Moffat and Dick Johnson did this as well, so
I am not alone. This may partially explain why so many glider pilots
prefer to make left turns (always flying with their right hands). I
also know that George and Dick initiated right hand turns whenever
they could (in order to set the turn direction of a thermal) as a
competitive trick, knowing that most of their competitors would be
less comfortable in a right hand turn than they were.

Translate this to a gimballed side stick where all motion is in the
wrist, and then I don't believe that the ergonomics will preference
one turn direction over another, but with a center stick there are
good reasons to be able or want to switch hands on the stick.

RO

  #28  
Old February 24th 17, 03:21 AM posted to rec.aviation.soaring
Bob Whelan[_3_]
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 400
Default Why are side sticks unpopular in sailplanes

With the centre stick I fly with both hands, sometimes at
the same time, I never think about it. Gear, ballast vent on the right,
brakes, trim release on left. Center stick has to be best.



OK, here my glider/slow speed analysis... At the speeds we fly, and thus
the relatively small circle diameters, the outboard wing will be going
marginally faster than the inboard wing. This means that it creates more
lift than the inboard wing due to relative speed alone, and thus to keep
from over-banking I find the need to apply a very small amount of top
aileron (against the turn) in order to keep a stable bank angle and
equalize the lift generated by both wings. Because the outer wing goes
faster, it also generates more drag as well, so I find that I have to hold
slight bottom rudder pressure along with the top aileron in order to have
the yaw string going straight back.

So, now think about how that translates to operating the stick. With a
center stick, it is easier to make left turns and pull the stick straight
back towards your right elbow and right hip, than it is to make right
turns and be pushing the stick towards your left hip (all while using your
right hand). I have trained myself to fly with either hand so that I use
the opposite hand to the direction I am thermalling in. George Moffat and
Dick Johnson did this as well, so I am not alone. This may partially
explain why so many glider pilots prefer to make left turns (always flying
with their right hands). I also know that George and Dick initiated right
hand turns whenever they could (in order to set the turn direction of a
thermal) as a competitive trick, knowing that most of their competitors
would be less comfortable in a right hand turn than they were.

Translate this to a gimballed side stick where all motion is in the wrist,
and then I don't believe that the ergonomics will preference one turn
direction over another, but with a center stick there are good reasons to
be able or want to switch hands on the stick.


Interestingly (to me, anyway) enough, early-on I found myself preferring
left-hand circles in a (center-sticked) 1-26, which bothered me
intellectually...but upon transitioning to a (center-sticked, 15-meter)
Concept 70 I could detect no turn direction bias. Eventually I concluded my
in-turn visibility was better in the 1-26 in a left turn than in a right turn,
almost certainly due to the (somewhat poor, for 5'9" me) straight-ahead viz in
the 1-26, and it was easier to bias my whole torso to the left for best
in-turn viz than it was to the right. Doing so to the right felt somehow
"forced," perhaps due to where my right elbow ended up, somewhat scrunched
into a corner of the cockpit. For whatever reason, it never occurred to me to
try a right hand turn using my left one on the stick.

With no apparent visibility bias in the ("normal/semi-reclined" pilot
position) C70, there was no turn-direction bias...which remained the case
until I transitioned into my (side-sticked, similar-to-C70-seating position)
Zuni, when (briefly) a left-turn bias reappeared. Once my right forearm
muscles adapted to/strengthened from the grunt required to lift/horse the
(heavy in roll) stick to the right, the bias again disappeared, and - as it
should be, IMO - whichever side on which I encountered the thermal lift
dictated initial bank direction.

Having essentially zero experience in earlier-generation, long-spanned, ships
(commonly flown by Moffat and Johnson), perhaps some aspect of muscle power
bias might be a factor for some in them? In any event, these sorts of
considerations seem to me to be pretty much toward the fringe of ship-handling
attributes...real enough, but far from deal-killers to (most?) potential
purchasers. Of course, if money were no object, then I might think about "ship
quirks" differently!

Bob W.
  #29  
Old February 24th 17, 06:29 PM posted to rec.aviation.soaring
Dan Marotta
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 4,601
Default Why are side sticks unpopular in sailplanes

I've always felt it was easier to push the stick to the left while
pulling it back (pitch control) than it was to pull it right while
pulling. For me it has to do with the mechanics of the wrist and elbow
joints. The more stick throw required, the more apparent it is to me
sitting on my couch and pretending to fly. It's obvious to me that,
with a long throw, a center stick is preferable, with a short throw, not
so much. I really think it comes down to preference and I can get used
to anything. In the Stemme, I take off with my left hand so I can keep
my right on the throttle. I land with my right hand so I can keep my
left on the dive brake lever. After securing the engine, I switch off
hands now and then to fiddle with an instrument (the soaring stuff is in
the middle of the panel to my right), to eat an apple, or just for a
change of pace.


On 2/23/2017 7:21 PM, Bob Whelan wrote:
With the centre stick I fly with both hands, sometimes at
the same time, I never think about it. Gear, ballast vent on the right,
brakes, trim release on left. Center stick has to be best.



OK, here my glider/slow speed analysis... At the speeds we fly, and
thus
the relatively small circle diameters, the outboard wing will be going
marginally faster than the inboard wing. This means that it creates
more
lift than the inboard wing due to relative speed alone, and thus to keep
from over-banking I find the need to apply a very small amount of top
aileron (against the turn) in order to keep a stable bank angle and
equalize the lift generated by both wings. Because the outer wing goes
faster, it also generates more drag as well, so I find that I have to
hold
slight bottom rudder pressure along with the top aileron in order to
have
the yaw string going straight back.

So, now think about how that translates to operating the stick. With a
center stick, it is easier to make left turns and pull the stick
straight
back towards your right elbow and right hip, than it is to make right
turns and be pushing the stick towards your left hip (all while using
your
right hand). I have trained myself to fly with either hand so that
I use
the opposite hand to the direction I am thermalling in. George
Moffat and
Dick Johnson did this as well, so I am not alone. This may partially
explain why so many glider pilots prefer to make left turns (always
flying
with their right hands). I also know that George and Dick initiated
right
hand turns whenever they could (in order to set the turn direction of a
thermal) as a competitive trick, knowing that most of their competitors
would be less comfortable in a right hand turn than they were.

Translate this to a gimballed side stick where all motion is in the
wrist,
and then I don't believe that the ergonomics will preference one turn
direction over another, but with a center stick there are good
reasons to
be able or want to switch hands on the stick.


Interestingly (to me, anyway) enough, early-on I found myself
preferring left-hand circles in a (center-sticked) 1-26, which
bothered me intellectually...but upon transitioning to a
(center-sticked, 15-meter) Concept 70 I could detect no turn direction
bias. Eventually I concluded my in-turn visibility was better in the
1-26 in a left turn than in a right turn, almost certainly due to the
(somewhat poor, for 5'9" me) straight-ahead viz in the 1-26, and it
was easier to bias my whole torso to the left for best in-turn viz
than it was to the right. Doing so to the right felt somehow "forced,"
perhaps due to where my right elbow ended up, somewhat scrunched into
a corner of the cockpit. For whatever reason, it never occurred to me
to try a right hand turn using my left one on the stick.

With no apparent visibility bias in the ("normal/semi-reclined" pilot
position) C70, there was no turn-direction bias...which remained the
case until I transitioned into my (side-sticked,
similar-to-C70-seating position) Zuni, when (briefly) a left-turn bias
reappeared. Once my right forearm muscles adapted to/strengthened from
the grunt required to lift/horse the (heavy in roll) stick to the
right, the bias again disappeared, and - as it should be, IMO -
whichever side on which I encountered the thermal lift dictated
initial bank direction.

Having essentially zero experience in earlier-generation,
long-spanned, ships (commonly flown by Moffat and Johnson), perhaps
some aspect of muscle power bias might be a factor for some in them?
In any event, these sorts of considerations seem to me to be pretty
much toward the fringe of ship-handling attributes...real enough, but
far from deal-killers to (most?) potential purchasers. Of course, if
money were no object, then I might think about "ship quirks" differently!

Bob W.


--
Dan, 5J
 




Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

vB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Forum Jump

Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Neat Video Shows Two Passenger Jets Landing Side-By-Side at the Same Time Miloch Aviation Photos 0 June 14th 16 04:28 AM
HP310 and hx4705 - side by side, first impression Darryl Ramm Soaring 0 February 22nd 09 03:42 AM
Saturn V S-IC (first) stage are placed side by side prior to commencement of the mating of the two stages 6416485.jpg [email protected] Aviation Photos 0 April 12th 07 01:28 AM
For Mitchell Holman, if you want them... - F-15 & F-16 on pedestals WPAFB side by side.JPG (1/1) Blue Oval/Dan Edwards Aviation Photos 4 January 19th 07 02:19 AM
Is That a Resistor Wired Between the Hot Side and the Switch Side of the Solenoid? jls Owning 3 April 11th 04 04:55 PM


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 11:04 AM.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004-2024 AviationBanter.
The comments are property of their posters.