If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
|
#1
|
|||
|
|||
S-turns on final
On Wednesday, February 15, 2017 at 11:51:27 AM UTC-8, wrote:
If the pilot has the skills and judgement to use S turns on final without reducing safety margins, he or she most likely would have the skills and judgement to not need them. UH Heh, heh. Irony. If I have a lot of room before touchdown (and even more than a lot of height in this scenario) and I need to make space I'll extend a leg or two in my pattern or make a circle. If I'm on short final I really want my velocity vector pointed at the runway and not a lot of bank on. I especially don't like the idea of a lot of maneuvering, reversing turns, etc when I'm close to the ground and needing to focus on a dozen other really important things. A stabilized approach makes a lot of other potential problems less problematic. It should be sufficient to use spoilers, landing flaps if you got 'em and an aggressive slip (which also guards against spin entry since it's the opposite of a skidding turn). Maybe there is a place for S-turns between turn to final and short final if you are ridiculously high and flying a really slippery glider with weak spoilers and no flaps. Fortunately, I don't fly one of those. 9B |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
S-turns on final
"S" turns were taught to me in early stages of hang glider training. It is used as inexperience to judging height when too high on final. Most I saw used on first few flights then used a more standard approach. From the ground it really looks like an inexperienced pilot, but the judgement for approach was right on for those that I saw using it. I think there were a lot of hang glider pilots that did/do not have any other type of flight training and so no good judgement of height, and I think the tendency of new hang glider solo would tend to be high on final.
I have never been taught "S" turns in glider training. I would much rather track slightly away on downwind, and or extend, than to have to "S" turn on final. If that video is from the 40's, I wonder when this was stopped being taught.. |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
S-turns on final
On Thursday, February 16, 2017 at 2:44:26 AM UTC+3, Casey wrote:
"S" turns were taught to me in early stages of hang glider training. It is used as inexperience to judging height when too high on final. Most I saw used on first few flights then used a more standard approach. From the ground it really looks like an inexperienced pilot, but the judgement for approach was right on for those that I saw using it. I think there were a lot of hang glider pilots that did/do not have any other type of flight training and so no good judgement of height, and I think the tendency of new hang glider solo would tend to be high on final. I have never been taught "S" turns in glider training. I would much rather track slightly away on downwind, and or extend, than to have to "S" turn on final. If that video is from the 40's, I wonder when this was stopped being taught. It's good to have as many techniques in your arsenal as possible. Even NASA does (did) S-turns in the circuit. |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
S-turns on final
On Wednesday, February 15, 2017 at 7:10:55 PM UTC-8, Bruce Hoult wrote:
It's good to have as many techniques in your arsenal as possible. Even NASA does (did) S-turns in the circuit. Gosh, I would hesitate to call the roll reversals "S-turns" Read below article, very interesting. https://www.nasa.gov/centers/johnson...pgs226-241.pdf |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
S-turns on final
Le jeudi 16 février 2017 08:38:18 UTC+1, Jonathan St. Cloud a écritÂ*:
On Wednesday, February 15, 2017 at 7:10:55 PM UTC-8, Bruce Hoult wrote: It's good to have as many techniques in your arsenal as possible. Even NASA does (did) S-turns in the circuit. Gosh, I would hesitate to call the roll reversals "S-turns" Read below article, very interesting. https://www.nasa.gov/centers/johnson...gs226-241..pdf Great article. |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
S-turns on final
On Wed, 15 Feb 2017 23:38:17 -0800, Jonathan St. Cloud wrote:
On Wednesday, February 15, 2017 at 7:10:55 PM UTC-8, Bruce Hoult wrote: It's good to have as many techniques in your arsenal as possible. Even NASA does (did) S-turns in the circuit. Gosh, I would hesitate to call the roll reversals "S-turns" Read below article, very interesting. https://www.nasa.gov/centers/johnson...in_Wings-ch4d- pgs226-241.pdf Thanks for posting that. However, whether you consider those S-turns or not, they were certainly not in the circuit (the shuttle flew straight-in patterns IIRC), rather they were en route to destination. BTW, somewhere I have an ancient shuttle landing simulator (for Win 95) that was interesting to experiment with. Does anybody know if a Linux version is available? There should be a port - NASA's original version ran on a Unix-based laptop that got sat on the Shuttle glare shield during command pilot training. The PC sim started you at 350kts and 55,000ft and no matter what you did with it, you were on the ground after 2.5 - 3 minutes. -- martin@ | Martin Gregorie gregorie. | Essex, UK org | |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
S-turns on final
With the very high degree of spoiler effectiveness on most gliders, if "said pilot" is regularly "forced" to slip or S-turn in order to make their intended touch down point, there is probably something else wrong "upstream" in said pilots landing pattern decision making process. Also, the majority of sailplane landing patterns appear to me to be rather high (again, IMO).
I commented here only to state (I'll say it again now) that slipping a high performance glider is almost useless (IMO). It requires such an aggressive slip angle (in order to result in any measurable increase in descent rate) that it is uncomfortable (and unnecessary) for me, personally (IMO). I'm surprised to hear otherwise, but that certainly doesn't change my opinion or practices. Perhaps their fuselages are the "slab sided" ASG29 version ;-). Perhaps I am a poor pilot. Perhaps this is a skill I need to work on. Oh well, for now, I don't slip unless absolutely necessary. I prefer docile S turns, but can only really recall one time I have done this. I have never needed a slip in my ASG29 or (ex) Lak17a (in the execution of many, many land-outs) That said, slips are an important skill in glider pilot training. To need to use them on a regular basis (or even rare basis) is perhaps indicative of some other concerns or areas of potential landing pattern/planning skill improvement. The need to slip or S-turn means that to that point in the approach, the pilot has misjudged the approach extremely high in terms of altitude and/or total energy, requiring a last resort maneuver (slip or S-turn) in order to bleed it off. Desperate. Poor planning. Poor energy management. This is how people get hurt. For those who have not yet flown higher performance glider, when you do, I would strongly suggest practicing slips at high altitude before trying (or being forced to exectute) a true, aggressive (full rudder) slip, with full spoilers (and perhaps 25-30% water remaining, simulating real world stress, for example) and at low (minimum possible) final approach speed while at very low altitude into a short land-out field (perhaps with tall trees on both ends and in some wind). I strongly prefer striving to execute consistent, well managed, stable approaches without big transitions from slip to non slip (close to the ground, at the last moment), especially when flying in a high performance glider (in which I feel slips are ineffective). Gliders have outstanding glideslope control with spoilers (and perhaps flaps). My goal is to fly the entire approach (from midfield downwind to near touchdown) with a set pitch, set flap setting, set speed and set spoiler setting (33%, I have a mark I use). The exact same approach every time. This takes significant practice. I prefer focusing on precisely controlling my energy (not too fast, not too high, good base turn decision) as early as possible in every approach. That is the critical moment in the approach for me, not the final leg. Everything flows from this mindset of setting the approach up with great precision and getting stable early.. If necessary, I prefer managing my glideslope with spoilers (only) and in a very smooth, controlable manner. If I must use them, I try and minimize adjustments rather than making constant adjustments (unstable). If I ultimately need to S turn, or slip, it means I have really (enormously) misjudged the approach and/or the landing area (perhaps the height of the trees on the approach end, wires I didn't see, or the usable length of the field (perhaps identifying a rock or a post on final)). If I started experiencing gross errors in general landing pattern decisions regularly (landouts or normal landings at an airport), requiring slips or S-turns to make the touchdown point (and stress), I would schedule some meaningful time with a respected flight instructor and sort myself out. Perhaps I'll be having a talk with one about slips in my 29 in fact. So, thanks for this discussion. Sean 7T |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
S-turns on final
On Wednesday, February 15, 2017 at 6:44:26 PM UTC-5, Casey wrote:
"S" turns were taught to me in early stages of hang glider training. It is used as inexperience to judging height when too high on final. Most I saw used on first few flights then used a more standard approach. From the ground it really looks like an inexperienced pilot, but the judgement for approach was right on for those that I saw using it. I think there were a lot of hang glider pilots that did/do not have any other type of flight training and so no good judgement of height, and I think the tendency of new hang glider solo would tend to be high on final. I have never been taught "S" turns in glider training. I would much rather track slightly away on downwind, and or extend, than to have to "S" turn on final. If that video is from the 40's, I wonder when this was stopped being taught. As a hang glider pilot for 38 years I agree Casey.... but we didn't have air brakes on Hang Gliders. I still used pattern approaches then but I landed in small fields surrounded by trees most of the time. Dennis.... DC |
#9
|
|||
|
|||
S-turns on final
Let us not forget that turns below 200 ft AGL potentially expose us to wind gradient having unequal and undesirable effects on the high vs low wing.
|
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
Are 'Single 180 Turn From Downwind to Final' and 'Stall-spin on Turnfrom Base to Final' mutually exclusive? | son_of_flubber | Soaring | 122 | December 17th 16 11:36 PM |
Downwind to final turns | Jonathan St. Cloud | Soaring | 18 | June 7th 15 02:19 PM |
Final Approach, pt 3 - KFME final.jpg (1/1) | Mitchell Holman[_3_] | Aviation Photos | 0 | April 8th 09 12:56 PM |
Landing KMBO - Shallow S turns on final Video | [email protected] | Piloting | 2 | July 2nd 08 10:50 PM |
Question: Standard rate turns, constant rate turns, and airspeed | Robert Barker | Piloting | 5 | April 15th 07 04:47 PM |