If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
*********A DEFENCE FOR MXMORAN***********
Beechsundowner,
I agree with a lot you are saying. I agree that putting anyone with no experience of that type of aircraft into the flightdeck and expecting them to know what and where each switch is would be very difficult. My main defense on this forum was for the Simulator and it's benefits on learning certain aircraft. Everyone here just argues 'its a toy for children' when in fact it's a 'tool for learning'. I know if I sat on the flightdeck of a 747-400 i WOULD know what button to push or knob to rotate when instructed by ATC because I have years of 'experience' yes it's on a pc but really what difference does that make (I mean really, they are modelled in a fully 3D photorealistic digital Virtual Cockpit in the exact same position to the real aircraft?). I've seen commercial pilots sitting in front of large full sized cardboard mockups of the flightdeck's panels prior to examinations. I agree if I sat down in a Sundowner (never even heard of one of them) it would be hard to decipher what ATC is asking me to do. I have a lot of good quality payware aircraft on FSX from the Cessna 152, 172, 182, 206, Twin Otter and the 744 so would only be fairly familiar with most of their cockpit layouts but sitting in an Airbus or even the older generation 737's without Glass Cockpits would be challenging like you say. You have it backwards..... *It's the sensation of movement that will make you a lawn dart and learning to ignore that sensation of movement is the key. I think I was following on from your comment (or someone elses as too many ppl on here) about managing to keep the aircraft straight and level and in controlled flight when reaching across to change switches etc. Even with TrackIR on FSX and a 24" widescreen monitor you lose peripheral vision so the Primary Flight Display is out of view in the sim (so you cannot see the attitude of the aircraft). Because you also cannot 'feel' what the aircraft is doing and no outside view of the horizon you could find yourself inadvertantly in a turn. IRL you would know this immediately. I fully appreciate in IMC conditions you use your instruments fully and don't rely on what you can/cannot see outside.. Again, talk to a pilot that is instrument rated. *Until you do so, you have no clue what flying is all about just on what you say above. Again this sim has taught me a hell of a lot on instrumentation, flight programming the FMC, how to track VOR radials, NDB's, ILS's, SIDS and STARS. I agree there is a HELL of a lot more to learn but it is a start and certainly an advantage to those that do not use it and I would defend it's benefits fully. I DO know a retired commercial Airbus A320 pilot who uses FSX and enjoys it and sees its merits amongst other trained pilots. If you dont like using it that's your perogative and I respect that. A big question asked by both myself and MX is have those on here who have tried MSFS done it with good quality commercial addon aircraft which are COMPLETELY different to that which comes as standard on an FSX installation. The default 747 is total **** and a kid could operate it compared to the highly complex PMDG models. Ibby |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
*********A DEFENCE FOR MXMORAN*********** | BeechSundowner | Piloting | 106 | March 13th 09 02:13 AM |
*********A DEFENCE FOR MXMORAN*********** | Morgans[_2_] | Piloting | 17 | March 9th 09 10:45 PM |
*********A DEFENCE FOR MXMORAN*********** | Maxwell[_2_] | Piloting | 0 | March 3rd 09 10:34 PM |
*********A DEFENCE FOR MXMORAN*********** | BeechSundowner | Piloting | 0 | March 3rd 09 09:18 PM |
UK Defence Shakeup | Ian MacLure | Military Aviation | 0 | July 22nd 04 03:40 AM |