A aviation & planes forum. AviationBanter

If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.

Go Back   Home » AviationBanter forum » rec.aviation newsgroups » Soaring
Site Map Home Register Authors List Search Today's Posts Mark Forums Read Web Partners

How does an aerotow rope break in two places?



 
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
  #11  
Old October 19th 18, 04:46 PM posted to rec.aviation.soaring
Bret Hess
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 121
Default How does an aerotow rope break in two places?

Direct observation of a simultaneous break on both ends:

Three years ago I was flying in the front seat of a Grob 103 (nose tow hook) with an instructor for a spring checkout. He wanted me to try a slack rope recovery method that was very different from normal (and later we agreed was not the right approach). When I did the maneuver, we had a spectacular rope break...I could see the rope break simultaneously at the tow plane end and the glider end and fall away.

This has an aerodynamically interesting ending.

The instructor could hear the broken rope segment on our end making noise against the fuselage. We had plenty of height, so we let the tow plane land, and moved over the runway to drop our short length of rope so the tow ring, etc could be recovered easily. When I pulled the nose tow release to drop the rope, a second or two later I noticed something at the open canopy window to my left. There was a foot or less of rope flapping around just inside the cockpit, so I pulled gently on it, and the entire three feet or so of the broken rope segment with the tow ring on the end came in through the window. It was trapped in some low pressure region against the fuselage which was connected to the flow through the window!

I agree with the wave/propagation idea.
  #12  
Old October 20th 18, 12:12 AM posted to rec.aviation.soaring
2G
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 1,439
Default How does an aerotow rope break in two places?

On Friday, October 19, 2018 at 8:46:48 AM UTC-7, Bret Hess wrote:
Direct observation of a simultaneous break on both ends:

Three years ago I was flying in the front seat of a Grob 103 (nose tow hook) with an instructor for a spring checkout. He wanted me to try a slack rope recovery method that was very different from normal (and later we agreed was not the right approach). When I did the maneuver, we had a spectacular rope break...I could see the rope break simultaneously at the tow plane end and the glider end and fall away.

This has an aerodynamically interesting ending.

The instructor could hear the broken rope segment on our end making noise against the fuselage. We had plenty of height, so we let the tow plane land, and moved over the runway to drop our short length of rope so the tow ring, etc could be recovered easily. When I pulled the nose tow release to drop the rope, a second or two later I noticed something at the open canopy window to my left. There was a foot or less of rope flapping around just inside the cockpit, so I pulled gently on it, and the entire three feet or so of the broken rope segment with the tow ring on the end came in through the window. It was trapped in some low pressure region against the fuselage which was connected to the flow through the window!

I agree with the wave/propagation idea.


Before the rope breaks, it is stretched a considerable percentage, storing energy in the fibers. When the rope breaks at some point, this energy is released in the form of a travelling wave from the point of breakage in both directions with the long portion having the greatest energy. Upon reaching either end, it encounters an impedance discontinuity (the tow release) and is reflected backwards along the rope. This reflection can add to the still oncoming wave, amplifying its magnitude. If this exceeds the ultimate strength of the rope at this point, it will, too, break.

This travelling wave phenomena also occurs in electronics, and is exploited in antennas.

Tom
  #13  
Old October 20th 18, 03:45 AM posted to rec.aviation.soaring
Steve Koerner
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 430
Default How does an aerotow rope break in two places?

On Friday, October 19, 2018 at 4:12:53 PM UTC-7, 2G wrote:
On Friday, October 19, 2018 at 8:46:48 AM UTC-7, Bret Hess wrote:
Direct observation of a simultaneous break on both ends:

Three years ago I was flying in the front seat of a Grob 103 (nose tow hook) with an instructor for a spring checkout. He wanted me to try a slack rope recovery method that was very different from normal (and later we agreed was not the right approach). When I did the maneuver, we had a spectacular rope break...I could see the rope break simultaneously at the tow plane end and the glider end and fall away.

This has an aerodynamically interesting ending.

The instructor could hear the broken rope segment on our end making noise against the fuselage. We had plenty of height, so we let the tow plane land, and moved over the runway to drop our short length of rope so the tow ring, etc could be recovered easily. When I pulled the nose tow release to drop the rope, a second or two later I noticed something at the open canopy window to my left. There was a foot or less of rope flapping around just inside the cockpit, so I pulled gently on it, and the entire three feet or so of the broken rope segment with the tow ring on the end came in through the window. It was trapped in some low pressure region against the fuselage which was connected to the flow through the window!

I agree with the wave/propagation idea.


Before the rope breaks, it is stretched a considerable percentage, storing energy in the fibers. When the rope breaks at some point, this energy is released in the form of a travelling wave from the point of breakage in both directions with the long portion having the greatest energy. Upon reaching either end, it encounters an impedance discontinuity (the tow release) and is reflected backwards along the rope. This reflection can add to the still oncoming wave, amplifying its magnitude. If this exceeds the ultimate strength of the rope at this point, it will, too, break.

This travelling wave phenomena also occurs in electronics, and is exploited in antennas.

Tom


To invoke any theory involving waves there needs to be a reason to think that there is a wave created of some sort. Waves necessitate two forms of energy storage with oscillation between them. I'm not seeing how that works in the towrope. It seems like the energy stored in the elastic rope will get dissipated as heat as the rope progressively shortens after breaking. I can visualize that at the breaking impulse maybe a wee bit of energy would get spit out as transverse displacement wave but that would be second order and not significant; the main happening is longitudinal. What wave are we talking about?
  #14  
Old October 20th 18, 06:01 AM posted to rec.aviation.soaring
2G
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 1,439
Default How does an aerotow rope break in two places?

On Friday, October 19, 2018 at 7:45:29 PM UTC-7, Steve Koerner wrote:
On Friday, October 19, 2018 at 4:12:53 PM UTC-7, 2G wrote:
On Friday, October 19, 2018 at 8:46:48 AM UTC-7, Bret Hess wrote:
Direct observation of a simultaneous break on both ends:

Three years ago I was flying in the front seat of a Grob 103 (nose tow hook) with an instructor for a spring checkout. He wanted me to try a slack rope recovery method that was very different from normal (and later we agreed was not the right approach). When I did the maneuver, we had a spectacular rope break...I could see the rope break simultaneously at the tow plane end and the glider end and fall away.

This has an aerodynamically interesting ending.

The instructor could hear the broken rope segment on our end making noise against the fuselage. We had plenty of height, so we let the tow plane land, and moved over the runway to drop our short length of rope so the tow ring, etc could be recovered easily. When I pulled the nose tow release to drop the rope, a second or two later I noticed something at the open canopy window to my left. There was a foot or less of rope flapping around just inside the cockpit, so I pulled gently on it, and the entire three feet or so of the broken rope segment with the tow ring on the end came in through the window. It was trapped in some low pressure region against the fuselage which was connected to the flow through the window!

I agree with the wave/propagation idea.


Before the rope breaks, it is stretched a considerable percentage, storing energy in the fibers. When the rope breaks at some point, this energy is released in the form of a travelling wave from the point of breakage in both directions with the long portion having the greatest energy. Upon reaching either end, it encounters an impedance discontinuity (the tow release) and is reflected backwards along the rope. This reflection can add to the still oncoming wave, amplifying its magnitude. If this exceeds the ultimate strength of the rope at this point, it will, too, break.

This travelling wave phenomena also occurs in electronics, and is exploited in antennas.

Tom


To invoke any theory involving waves there needs to be a reason to think that there is a wave created of some sort. Waves necessitate two forms of energy storage with oscillation between them. I'm not seeing how that works in the towrope. It seems like the energy stored in the elastic rope will get dissipated as heat as the rope progressively shortens after breaking. I can visualize that at the breaking impulse maybe a wee bit of energy would get spit out as transverse displacement wave but that would be second order and not significant; the main happening is longitudinal. What wave are we talking about?


First, before breaking, the rope is stretched considerably beyond its resting length - this undeniably stores energy in the rope (the same as a spring). Second, when the rope breaks this stored energy is released by accelerating the end of the rope, like the cracking of a whip or an earthquake starting a tsunami. This energy travels the rope until it reaches the terminated end, where it is reflected in the opposite direction.
Here is a video of a steel rope breaking; single-frame from 33 sec to see the wave-like action:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W6gZawDnthI

Tom
  #15  
Old October 20th 18, 08:35 AM posted to rec.aviation.soaring
Steve Koerner
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 430
Default How does an aerotow rope break in two places?

On Friday, October 19, 2018 at 10:01:22 PM UTC-7, 2G wrote:
On Friday, October 19, 2018 at 7:45:29 PM UTC-7, Steve Koerner wrote:
On Friday, October 19, 2018 at 4:12:53 PM UTC-7, 2G wrote:
On Friday, October 19, 2018 at 8:46:48 AM UTC-7, Bret Hess wrote:
Direct observation of a simultaneous break on both ends:

Three years ago I was flying in the front seat of a Grob 103 (nose tow hook) with an instructor for a spring checkout. He wanted me to try a slack rope recovery method that was very different from normal (and later we agreed was not the right approach). When I did the maneuver, we had a spectacular rope break...I could see the rope break simultaneously at the tow plane end and the glider end and fall away.

This has an aerodynamically interesting ending.

The instructor could hear the broken rope segment on our end making noise against the fuselage. We had plenty of height, so we let the tow plane land, and moved over the runway to drop our short length of rope so the tow ring, etc could be recovered easily. When I pulled the nose tow release to drop the rope, a second or two later I noticed something at the open canopy window to my left. There was a foot or less of rope flapping around just inside the cockpit, so I pulled gently on it, and the entire three feet or so of the broken rope segment with the tow ring on the end came in through the window. It was trapped in some low pressure region against the fuselage which was connected to the flow through the window!

I agree with the wave/propagation idea.

Before the rope breaks, it is stretched a considerable percentage, storing energy in the fibers. When the rope breaks at some point, this energy is released in the form of a travelling wave from the point of breakage in both directions with the long portion having the greatest energy. Upon reaching either end, it encounters an impedance discontinuity (the tow release) and is reflected backwards along the rope. This reflection can add to the still oncoming wave, amplifying its magnitude. If this exceeds the ultimate strength of the rope at this point, it will, too, break.

This travelling wave phenomena also occurs in electronics, and is exploited in antennas.

Tom


To invoke any theory involving waves there needs to be a reason to think that there is a wave created of some sort. Waves necessitate two forms of energy storage with oscillation between them. I'm not seeing how that works in the towrope. It seems like the energy stored in the elastic rope will get dissipated as heat as the rope progressively shortens after breaking.. I can visualize that at the breaking impulse maybe a wee bit of energy would get spit out as transverse displacement wave but that would be second order and not significant; the main happening is longitudinal. What wave are we talking about?


First, before breaking, the rope is stretched considerably beyond its resting length - this undeniably stores energy in the rope (the same as a spring). Second, when the rope breaks this stored energy is released by accelerating the end of the rope, like the cracking of a whip or an earthquake starting a tsunami. This energy travels the rope until it reaches the terminated end, where it is reflected in the opposite direction.
Here is a video of a steel rope breaking; single-frame from 33 sec to see the wave-like action:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W6gZawDnthI

Tom


Tom: As you know, cracking a whip happens because the whip is excited with a transverse wave. We're not doing that; our excitation is longitudinal. As I said before, there is likely a small amount of incidental motion that goes to making a transverse wave as there is in the video you reference; but that's second order and I think too small to matter.

I don't see that there is anything about the longitudinal accelerating rope that can then oscillate energy back into stored state as rope tension. Hence, you do not have a longitudinal wave scenario. Without a wave mechanism, you don't get to talk about reflection. The energy in the rope just goes to heat.

The basic problem is that you can't push a rope. If we were talking about a spring, then yes, you could push on a spring and get energy stored in compression and have a longitudinal wave with energy oscillating between longitudinal kinetic motion and compression. Such wave would reflect at the far end and maybe do something interesting. But when you push on a rope, you get nothing.
  #16  
Old October 20th 18, 02:52 PM posted to rec.aviation.soaring
Steve Koerner
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 430
Default How does an aerotow rope break in two places?

On Saturday, October 20, 2018 at 12:35:33 AM UTC-7, Steve Koerner wrote:
On Friday, October 19, 2018 at 10:01:22 PM UTC-7, 2G wrote:
On Friday, October 19, 2018 at 7:45:29 PM UTC-7, Steve Koerner wrote:
On Friday, October 19, 2018 at 4:12:53 PM UTC-7, 2G wrote:
On Friday, October 19, 2018 at 8:46:48 AM UTC-7, Bret Hess wrote:
Direct observation of a simultaneous break on both ends:

Three years ago I was flying in the front seat of a Grob 103 (nose tow hook) with an instructor for a spring checkout. He wanted me to try a slack rope recovery method that was very different from normal (and later we agreed was not the right approach). When I did the maneuver, we had a spectacular rope break...I could see the rope break simultaneously at the tow plane end and the glider end and fall away.

This has an aerodynamically interesting ending.

The instructor could hear the broken rope segment on our end making noise against the fuselage. We had plenty of height, so we let the tow plane land, and moved over the runway to drop our short length of rope so the tow ring, etc could be recovered easily. When I pulled the nose tow release to drop the rope, a second or two later I noticed something at the open canopy window to my left. There was a foot or less of rope flapping around just inside the cockpit, so I pulled gently on it, and the entire three feet or so of the broken rope segment with the tow ring on the end came in through the window. It was trapped in some low pressure region against the fuselage which was connected to the flow through the window!

I agree with the wave/propagation idea.

Before the rope breaks, it is stretched a considerable percentage, storing energy in the fibers. When the rope breaks at some point, this energy is released in the form of a travelling wave from the point of breakage in both directions with the long portion having the greatest energy. Upon reaching either end, it encounters an impedance discontinuity (the tow release) and is reflected backwards along the rope. This reflection can add to the still oncoming wave, amplifying its magnitude. If this exceeds the ultimate strength of the rope at this point, it will, too, break.

This travelling wave phenomena also occurs in electronics, and is exploited in antennas.

Tom

To invoke any theory involving waves there needs to be a reason to think that there is a wave created of some sort. Waves necessitate two forms of energy storage with oscillation between them. I'm not seeing how that works in the towrope. It seems like the energy stored in the elastic rope will get dissipated as heat as the rope progressively shortens after breaking. I can visualize that at the breaking impulse maybe a wee bit of energy would get spit out as transverse displacement wave but that would be second order and not significant; the main happening is longitudinal. What wave are we talking about?


First, before breaking, the rope is stretched considerably beyond its resting length - this undeniably stores energy in the rope (the same as a spring). Second, when the rope breaks this stored energy is released by accelerating the end of the rope, like the cracking of a whip or an earthquake starting a tsunami. This energy travels the rope until it reaches the terminated end, where it is reflected in the opposite direction.
Here is a video of a steel rope breaking; single-frame from 33 sec to see the wave-like action:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W6gZawDnthI

Tom


Tom: As you know, cracking a whip happens because the whip is excited with a transverse wave. We're not doing that; our excitation is longitudinal. As I said before, there is likely a small amount of incidental motion that goes to making a transverse wave as there is in the video you reference; but that's second order and I think too small to matter.

I don't see that there is anything about the longitudinal accelerating rope that can then oscillate energy back into stored state as rope tension. Hence, you do not have a longitudinal wave scenario. Without a wave mechanism, you don't get to talk about reflection. The energy in the rope just goes to heat.

The basic problem is that you can't push a rope. If we were talking about a spring, then yes, you could push on a spring and get energy stored in compression and have a longitudinal wave with energy oscillating between longitudinal kinetic motion and compression. Such wave would reflect at the far end and maybe do something interesting. But when you push on a rope, you get nothing.


But wait just a minute, Steve: Certainly a rope under tension can support a longitudinal wave. We all know about the tin can telephone that works by longitudinal waves when a string is tensioned.

Yesterday, Steve, you were putting forth how it takes time for the tow rope to relax after breaking. If the speed of relaxation is slower than the speed of wave propagation (it probably is), then wouldn't there be a brief period after breaking that an impulse generated longitudinal wave can propagate to the other end of the rope and do mischief?
  #17  
Old October 23rd 18, 05:07 AM posted to rec.aviation.soaring
2G
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 1,439
Default How does an aerotow rope break in two places?

On Saturday, October 20, 2018 at 6:52:11 AM UTC-7, Steve Koerner wrote:
On Saturday, October 20, 2018 at 12:35:33 AM UTC-7, Steve Koerner wrote:
On Friday, October 19, 2018 at 10:01:22 PM UTC-7, 2G wrote:
On Friday, October 19, 2018 at 7:45:29 PM UTC-7, Steve Koerner wrote:
On Friday, October 19, 2018 at 4:12:53 PM UTC-7, 2G wrote:
On Friday, October 19, 2018 at 8:46:48 AM UTC-7, Bret Hess wrote:
Direct observation of a simultaneous break on both ends:

Three years ago I was flying in the front seat of a Grob 103 (nose tow hook) with an instructor for a spring checkout. He wanted me to try a slack rope recovery method that was very different from normal (and later we agreed was not the right approach). When I did the maneuver, we had a spectacular rope break...I could see the rope break simultaneously at the tow plane end and the glider end and fall away.

This has an aerodynamically interesting ending.

The instructor could hear the broken rope segment on our end making noise against the fuselage. We had plenty of height, so we let the tow plane land, and moved over the runway to drop our short length of rope so the tow ring, etc could be recovered easily. When I pulled the nose tow release to drop the rope, a second or two later I noticed something at the open canopy window to my left. There was a foot or less of rope flapping around just inside the cockpit, so I pulled gently on it, and the entire three feet or so of the broken rope segment with the tow ring on the end came in through the window. It was trapped in some low pressure region against the fuselage which was connected to the flow through the window!

I agree with the wave/propagation idea.

Before the rope breaks, it is stretched a considerable percentage, storing energy in the fibers. When the rope breaks at some point, this energy is released in the form of a travelling wave from the point of breakage in both directions with the long portion having the greatest energy. Upon reaching either end, it encounters an impedance discontinuity (the tow release) and is reflected backwards along the rope. This reflection can add to the still oncoming wave, amplifying its magnitude. If this exceeds the ultimate strength of the rope at this point, it will, too, break.

This travelling wave phenomena also occurs in electronics, and is exploited in antennas.

Tom

To invoke any theory involving waves there needs to be a reason to think that there is a wave created of some sort. Waves necessitate two forms of energy storage with oscillation between them. I'm not seeing how that works in the towrope. It seems like the energy stored in the elastic rope will get dissipated as heat as the rope progressively shortens after breaking. I can visualize that at the breaking impulse maybe a wee bit of energy would get spit out as transverse displacement wave but that would be second order and not significant; the main happening is longitudinal. What wave are we talking about?

First, before breaking, the rope is stretched considerably beyond its resting length - this undeniably stores energy in the rope (the same as a spring). Second, when the rope breaks this stored energy is released by accelerating the end of the rope, like the cracking of a whip or an earthquake starting a tsunami. This energy travels the rope until it reaches the terminated end, where it is reflected in the opposite direction.
Here is a video of a steel rope breaking; single-frame from 33 sec to see the wave-like action:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W6gZawDnthI

Tom


Tom: As you know, cracking a whip happens because the whip is excited with a transverse wave. We're not doing that; our excitation is longitudinal. As I said before, there is likely a small amount of incidental motion that goes to making a transverse wave as there is in the video you reference; but that's second order and I think too small to matter.

I don't see that there is anything about the longitudinal accelerating rope that can then oscillate energy back into stored state as rope tension. Hence, you do not have a longitudinal wave scenario. Without a wave mechanism, you don't get to talk about reflection. The energy in the rope just goes to heat.

The basic problem is that you can't push a rope. If we were talking about a spring, then yes, you could push on a spring and get energy stored in compression and have a longitudinal wave with energy oscillating between longitudinal kinetic motion and compression. Such wave would reflect at the far end and maybe do something interesting. But when you push on a rope, you get nothing.


But wait just a minute, Steve: Certainly a rope under tension can support a longitudinal wave. We all know about the tin can telephone that works by longitudinal waves when a string is tensioned.

Yesterday, Steve, you were putting forth how it takes time for the tow rope to relax after breaking. If the speed of relaxation is slower than the speed of wave propagation (it probably is), then wouldn't there be a brief period after breaking that an impulse generated longitudinal wave can propagate to the other end of the rope and do mischief?


Steve,
It is a well known effect (hazard) that when a steel cable breaks under tension, it comes flying back, snaking all over the place. Now, steel stretches very little at failure, so this snaking is due to a transverse wave being induced. I suspect that the same thing can occur in a poly rope.
Tom
  #18  
Old October 23rd 18, 10:08 AM posted to rec.aviation.soaring
Tom[_21_]
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 48
Default How does an aerotow rope break in two places?

As this has happened to me (rope broke in severe turbulence) and both the glider and towplane returned with their respective rings, the rope is in the woods somewhere - my guess is that the rope broke at the weakest points, the 180 degree bend at both ends.

Regards Tom
  #19  
Old October 23rd 18, 06:52 PM posted to rec.aviation.soaring
Steve Koerner
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 430
Default How does an aerotow rope break in two places?

It is a well known effect (hazard) that when a steel cable breaks under tension, it comes flying back, snaking all over the place. Now, steel stretches very little at failure, so this snaking is due to a transverse wave being induced. I suspect that the same thing can occur in a poly rope.
Tom


I think I can see why steel cable does what it does on breaking and why towrope wouldn't really behave the same. Upon breaking, the stretch of steel cable is released with a lot of acceleration and because of its momentum, it overshoots its neutral length. The cable has rigidity and buckles energetically when it recoils and pushes upon itself throughout its length. By contrast, poly rope has no need of buckling; it can go placid as it arrives at neutral length. Once placid, it won't support wave propagation in transverse or longitudinal mode. So, if there's any waves generated at the first breakage, those waves need to finish their work before the rope finishes unstretching.
 




Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

vB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Forum Jump

Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Aerotow Regulations and Rope Specifications Markus Graeber Soaring 21 May 21st 15 04:30 AM
Actual Rope Break Kevin Christner Soaring 30 June 4th 14 04:59 PM
Rope Break! Waveguru Soaring 9 August 28th 12 03:17 AM
Rope Break Walt Connelly Soaring 4 April 12th 11 09:04 PM
Aerotow rope drogue chute? John Galloway Soaring 18 December 11th 03 06:37 AM


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 08:08 PM.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004-2024 AviationBanter.
The comments are property of their posters.