If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
3 more Qs
1. Like there are crosswind landings, are there crosswind takeoffs too?
If yes, what's the procedure of takeoff? 2. In crosswind landings, it's recommended that one lands on only the upwind wheel. Since this would almost always tilt the upwind wing groundward, would there not be an engine strike? I'm especially thinking of aircraft like the 737 and A320... 3. How to slip an aircraft sideward? I'm visualizing a situation on final when a draft of air suddenly blows the aircraft a bit off-center and when it might be a bit late to try and bank the craft to get it back into proper alignment. Thanks, Ramapriya |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
1) Yes, on a crosswind takeoff you put aileron into the wind and use
rudder to stay aligned with the runway. One instructor had me do an exercise in which I lifted up on one wheel in a crosswind takeoff and proceeded a good distance down the runway in that condition. 2) Airliners bank into the wind too, but the degree of bank is much less, since the crosswind is a smaller percentage of airspeed. I'm sure engine strikes have happened, but it's not a common problem. 3) In gusty winds, it's often necessary to make sudden corrections of both the rudder and aileron to stay centered on the runway. Many years ago I had the wind change from a right to a left crosswind at the instant of touchdown. Slammed me into the runway on the nosewheel and right main. Thought for sure I had broken the airplane. -- Gene Seibel Confessions of a Pilot - http://pad39a.com/publishing/ Because I fly, I envy no one. |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
"Gene Seibel" wrote
2) Airliners bank into the wind too, but the degree of bank is much less, since the crosswind is a smaller percentage of airspeed. I'm sure engine strikes have happened, but it's not a common problem. Not really Gene...airliners with wing mounted engines almost always crab into the crosswind rather than banking. Engine strikes are a serious problem. In the B-707 that I flew for 17 years, we crabbed and then using the rudder, "kicked-out" the crab at the last second before touchdown. Boeing said that if one was not comfortable doing that, just touchdown in the crab. Of course autoland approaches always use the crab into the wind method with the autopilot taking out the crab just before touchdown. Bob Moore CFI ATP B-707 B-727 |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
|
#5
|
|||
|
|||
Thanks for the correction. Shouldn't have speculated beyond on my
experience. -- Gene Seibel Gene & Sue's Aeroplanes - http://pad39a.com/gene/planes.html Because I fly, I envy no one. |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
Bob Moore wrote:
the crab at the last second before touchdown. Boeing said that if one was not comfortable doing that, just touchdown in the crab. Of course autoland approaches always use the crab Sorry for being naive here Bob, but does touching down with the nose not pointed down the center of the airstrip, which is what I presume would happen if you touched down in the crab, bust the wheels? I'm thinking of the stress my ankles would be under if I had to jump down from somewhere at an angle to my eventual follow-through (unsure whether or not that's a silly comparison). Ramapriya |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
"Ramapriya" wrote
Sorry for being naive here Bob, but does touching down with the nose not pointed down the center of the airstrip, which is what I presume would happen if you touched down in the crab, bust the wheels? Certainly not good for light general aviation aircraft, but the Boeings seem to take it easily. Bob |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
Ramapriya wrote: 1. Like there are crosswind landings, are there crosswind takeoffs too? If yes, what's the procedure of takeoff? Yes. The aileron on the upwind wing is raised as if you were banking the aircraft in that direction. The aircraft is kept straight by use of rudder. The nosewheel or tailwheel is usually kept down a bit longer for steering. With light planes, flaps may be retracted so that the plane leaves the ground at a higher speed than normal. Once the plane leaves the ground, the pilot adjusts the controls to achieve co-ordinated flight. 2. In crosswind landings, it's recommended that one lands on only the upwind wheel. Since this would almost always tilt the upwind wing groundward, would there not be an engine strike? I'm especially thinking of aircraft like the 737 and A320... Yes. In aircraft with engines under the wing, the plane is usually landed by either landing sideways and allowing the gear to kick it straight or (more usually) coming in at an angle and kicking the aircraft in line with the runway by using the rudder just before touchdown. This latter method is called the "crab and kick" method. There are several old videos floating around of 747s landing at Hong Kong's old airport. In one, the plane obviously touches down at at least a 20 degree angle to the runway. The amount of smoke from the tires is impressive. In another, the plane banks just before touching down and loses an engine when the engine hits the pavement. 3. How to slip an aircraft sideward? I'm visualizing a situation on final when a draft of air suddenly blows the aircraft a bit off-center and when it might be a bit late to try and bank the craft to get it back into proper alignment. When you bank an aircraft and use the rudder to counter the yaw effect, it will turn. If, however, you don't counter the yaw, it will slide sideways towards the low wing. If you actually push the rudder in the opposite direction to enhance yaw, the plane will fly sideways. This is a slip. One use for a slip is to keep the plane lined up with the runway when a crosswind is trying to blow the plane sideways. Another use is to increase the rate of descent if you're too high on final. The gusty wind situation you describe is usually handled by normal maneuvers (such as a small S-turn) while using throttle to keep from touching down. In extreme cases, the pilot aborts the landing and climbs back up to try again. Slips are, however, one tool that a pilot can use to handle gusts, so it wouldn't be unusual for a pilot to do so. George Patterson The desire for safety stands against every great and noble enterprise. |
#9
|
|||
|
|||
Ramapriya wrote: I could be wrong but I got the impression that the 707s made more noise than comparable-sized aircraft... 707s are old planes by now. Jet engines have gotten quieter over the years. Any 707 that still has the original engine design is going to be very loud and smoke a lot on takeoff. Even if the engines have been replaced with newer designs, they'll be noisier than a 727. They 707 also has four of them versus the 727's three. When I was working at Hartsfield in the late 70s, it amused me that I never once saw a 707 land there, but I could count on seeing several DC-3s every day if I were working a site that allowed me to see a runway. Ten years or so before that, every article or column about the 707 called it a classic, with the implication that they would be flying for decades, but they were gone by that time and the old Gooney Birds were still trucking passengers. George Patterson The desire for safety stands against every great and noble enterprise. |
#10
|
|||
|
|||
"Ramapriya" wrote in message oups.com... Bob Moore wrote: the crab at the last second before touchdown. Boeing said that if one was not comfortable doing that, just touchdown in the crab. Of course autoland approaches always use the crab Sorry for being naive here Bob, but does touching down with the nose not pointed down the center of the airstrip, which is what I presume would happen if you touched down in the crab, bust the wheels? Think of it this way. All that mass is moving straight down the runway, still pretty fast. It is going to try to keep going straight pretty fast. The only thing to cause enough stress on the gear to try to break the gear is the tires. What happens when the tires first touch down? A big puff of smoke, as the tires spin up to speed. Just a little bit of force involved to do that. It would take a whole lot more force to make that big bird go sideways, right? So what happens? The tires skid a bit sideways for a while, until the FO (the captain wouldn't have screwed up by not kicking the crab out, right? g ) wakes up and corrects to get the thing pointed straight down the runway, right? It has been my experience, from riding the heavy iron, that the combination of a slightly low wing and kicking the crab out is what is used. I say that only from observation, as it feels like one side hits, followed *very quickly* by the other side landing. Sometimes, it does feel like you are taking a quick ride towards the lights. -- Jim ( I'm grading your landings, Captains) in NC :-) |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|