If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#71
|
|||
|
|||
SAFE Winch Launching
Frank,
I believe that John Kangas is also mowing the King Mountain Glider Park "Frank Whiteley" wrote in message ... On Jul 13, 10:42 am, "Wayne Paul" wrote: I concur that the US needs an economical way to launch sailplanes. As elsewhere in the world, a good winch seems to be the answer. I don't have a ground-launch endorsement in my log book; however, I hope to get the training in the near future. In order for the endorsement to have any value, I will need to install a CG hook on my HP-14 and travel to a facility with a winch. There are a couple of auto/truck ground launching operation less then 300 mile; however, I will have the travel about 700 mile to use a winch. This should give you some sense of the US lack of winch launch accessibility. Wayne, I was talking with Bill Corbin today about the prospect of finding a winch for King Mountain. Any old Gehrlein model 62's languishing about out there readers? We may be launching with one starting Tuesday. I spent 8 hours on the tractor mowing the launch and recovery area and runways today, such is the rain we've had in Colorado this year. Frank Whiteley |
#72
|
|||
|
|||
SAFE Winch Launching
Frank,
John Kangas mowed the King Mountain Glider Park (http://www.kingmountaingliderpark.com/) last week end. He also installed tie-downs getting ready for the Aug 17 "grand opening" . (Are you planning to attend?) As you know, one of John's goals is the installation of a winch. He feels the field's proximity to the mountain and associate know areas which generate thermals will make flying cross-country from a winch a "piece of cake." I am sure he would be interested in knowing about an old Gehrlein that is languishing somewhere here in the US. (There is also a glider operation "start up" in Baker City, OR that is looking for an old winch.) I flew my Gold 300km triangle out of Mackay, Idaho and one of the turnpoints was the King Mountain Glider Park coordinates. (http://www.soaridaho.com/Flights/6F_Gold_Distance.html) With the proximity of both the King Mountain Glider Park and Baker City, a CG hook for my HP-14 is on my winter project list. Wayne http://www.soaridaho.com/ "Frank Whiteley" wrote in message ... On Jul 13, 10:42 am, "Wayne Paul" wrote: "Del C" wrote in ... At 15:01 13 July 2009, Wayne Paul wrote: I concur that the US needs an economical way to launch sailplanes. As elsewhere in the world, a good winch seems to be the answer. I don't have a ground-launch endorsement in my log book; however, I hope to get the training in the near future. In order for the endorsement to have any value, I will need to install a CG hook on my HP-14 and travel to a facility with a winch. There are a couple of auto/truck ground launching operation less then 300 mile; however, I will have the travel about 700 mile to use a winch. This should give you some sense of the US lack of winch launch accessibility. Wayne, I was talking with Bill Corbin today about the prospect of finding a winch for King Mountain. Any old Gehrlein model 62's languishing about out there readers? We may be launching with one starting Tuesday. I spent 8 hours on the tractor mowing the launch and recovery area and runways today, such is the rain we've had in Colorado this year. Frank Whiteley |
#73
|
|||
|
|||
SAFE Winch Launching
Unfortunately, I have a wedding here in Colorado to attend, so I won't
be able to come to Idaho. Frank On Jul 14, 6:12*am, "Wayne Paul" wrote: Frank, I believe that John Kangas is also mowing the King Mountain Glider Park"Frank Whiteley" wrote in ... On Jul 13, 10:42 am, "Wayne Paul" wrote: I concur that the US needs an economical way to launch sailplanes. As elsewhere in the world, a good winch seems to be the answer. I don't have a ground-launch endorsement in my log book; however, I hope to get the training in the near future. In order for the endorsement to have any value, I will need to install a CG hook on my HP-14 and travel to a facility with a winch. There are a couple of auto/truck ground launching operation less then 300 mile; however, I will have the travel about 700 mile to use a winch. This should give you some sense of the US lack of winch launch accessibility. Wayne, I was talking with Bill Corbin today about the prospect of finding a winch for King Mountain. *Any old Gehrlein model 62's languishing about out there readers? *We may be launching with one starting Tuesday. *I spent 8 hours on the tractor mowing the launch and recovery area and runways today, such is the rain we've had in Colorado this year. Frank Whiteley |
#74
|
|||
|
|||
SAFE Winch Launching
Bob wrote:
Snip... Maybe the “new” technology is better, but keeping it in context – it is a potential alternative to the proven traditional technology, not *THE* definitive answer. This is what is being lost in this ongoing point and counter- point dialog. Indeed... - - - - - - There are many of us who believe in the merits of winch launching; and that U.S. glider pilots would benefit from the widespread adoption of the technique. And I'm one of 'em. Soaring as an activity is sufficiently arcane and the group (worldwide) that practices it sufficiently thinly spread that internecine warfare fits the "foot shot" definition, in my book. - - - - - - It would benefit the soaring community if the polarized principals in this personal disagreement would spend their time advocating winch launching as a method, rather than publicly arguing over technical details that may or may not be relevant. "Roger that!" (What a concept!!!) - - - - - - Snip... If we could re-focus this obsessive, bias, and argumentative dialog into promoting the use of ground launching it would be of greater benefit to the soaring community at large. Anyone agree? "Ayup..." - - - - - - Bob Lacovara (Winch pilot, winch driver, winch advocate) Ditto your sig-line and tack-on 'engineer/*soaring* advocate.' (Sadly, sometimes that last does NOT go without saying!) :-) Bob - all soaring is good - W. |
#75
|
|||
|
|||
SAFE Winch Launching
Just exacly where are you making these tensions measurements????
Are you making them at the weak link?? Are you making these measurements at the winch end of things? I'd really like to know... |
#76
|
|||
|
|||
SAFE Winch Launching
At 22:34 14 July 2009, Gary Emerson wrote:
Just exacly where are you making these tensions measurements???? Are you making them at the weak link?? Are you making these measurements at the winch end of things? I'd really like to know... That is the question that is puzzling me too. The tension sensed by the winch will, and should be constantly changing during the launch, measuring that would be, how can I put it, useless. The tension at the glider release hook will be relatively constant but measuring that introduces the problem of the addional weight of the device that does it and a reliable transmission of data to the ground. |
#77
|
|||
|
|||
SAFE Winch Launching
At 22:34 14 July 2009, Gary Emerson wrote:
Just exacly where are you making these tensions measurements???? Are you making them at the weak link?? Are you making these measurements at the winch end of things? I'd really like to know... I'm going to throw in my two cents here. I've been trying to get hard data and information from first hand experiences for several years, now, there just isn't much real stuff publicly available. There is, however, a growing body of theory (which is good), speculation (not so good), and a lot of bold statements that I have been, so far, unable to verify. First, as far as I find out, the only tension/torque controlled winches currently in day to day use use either electric or hydraulic drive systems. For an electric winch, the torque applied to the drum can be controlled based on drive current and drum speed. In the hydraulic case, torque control is achieved by adjusting hydraulic pressure. In both cases, this allows applying a specific amount of torque to the drum, which approximates the desired amount of tension on the rope. In neither case is the actual rope tension being measured. Drum inertia, rope oscillations, etc., will also affect the rope tension. Apparently, though, at least some of these winches provide tension controlled launches on a practical basis. There is one winch with an automated controls system under development in the US, which uses a diesel engine and automatic transmission, with a running line tensiometer (RLT) at the winch end. I have not been able to obtain any information on whether the tension control program is actually in use, and whether it is resulting in any real improvement over more conventional winch launches. One group in the UK has flown with a recording load cell to collect data during a dispute with the manufacturer of their (conventional) winch. The load cell was apparently placed at the weak link end of the rope. I've seen about 10 distinct graphs produced by this device, and they look terrible (large excursions in tension). However, despite loud proclamations that "hundreds" of similar flights have been recorded on several winches, I've never been able to get hold of any further data. I also have been unable to obtain information on the device itself, how it was calibrated, the circumstances under which the data was recorded, and whether there were electrical, mechanical, driver, and/or pilot related issues that could affect the data. It does look rather straightforward to put a recording or wireless load cell at the glider end of the rope, or use an RLT or even measure the load directly from the winch axle (which I'll have provision for in the winch I'm designing). So, I expect we'll be seeing more data in the future. That's all I know at the moment, if there is anyone lurking out there with solid data, I'd love to hear about it... Marc |
#78
|
|||
|
|||
SAFE Winch Launching
At 00:30 15 July 2009, Don Johnstone wrote:
At 22:34 14 July 2009, Gary Emerson wrote: Just exacly where are you making these tensions measurements???? Are you making them at the weak link?? Are you making these measurements at the winch end of things? I'd really like to know... That is the question that is puzzling me too. The tension sensed by the winch will, and should be constantly changing during the launch, measuring that would be, how can I put it, useless. The tension at the glider release hook will be relatively constant but measuring that introduces the problem of the addional weight of the device that does it and a reliable transmission of data to the ground. That is the bit that the proponents of constant tension winch launching seem to gloss over. How do you measure tension in a long and thrashing cable that is being wound into a winch at up to 70 knots as the glider lifts off? There are gadgets called running line tensiometers that are used in underground cable laying, but they don't work at the sort of speeds required. The other approach is to mount a load cell at the glider end and transmit the data back to the winch in some way, such as a radio link. Even if you can directly measure tension in the cable, you have to bear in mind that the glider has to pull against that tension and that changes in its pitch angle due to pilot inputs or gusts will temporarily increase or reduce the tension. You would therefore have to damp the system or it would tend to hunt. I know as a glider pilot and winch driver myself, that the less you can change the pitch angle of the glider and the throttle setting of the winch, the steadier the launch becomes. If the pilot is trying to control the airspeed with the stick at the same time that the winch is trying to sense and maintain a constant tension, there is a risk that they will end up chasing each other, especially when separated by a long, sagging (even Dyneema sags slightly) and slightly elastic cable. In practice the Skylaunch approach of limiting the power setting as appropriate to the glider type, headwind component and weak link strength seems to work well. If the pilot pulls back harder, or the glider runs into a thermal, it slows the winch engine down by just the right amount. Easing forward or hitting sink allows the engine to speed up. Since we replaced Tost winches with Skylaunches, broken weak links have almost become a thing of the past and the vast majority of the launches are correctly speeded given correct pilot inputs. The pilot can control the airspeed by changing the pitch angle. Derek Copeland |
#79
|
|||
|
|||
SAFE Winch Launching
People trying to design tension controlled winches are re-inventing
the wheel. Conventional winches already do that. IF the power setting is retained constant in conventional winches with a torque converter, the tension will be constant excluding the inertia factor. Every winch will have inertia and delay and none will be able to respond instantaneously to changes in wire load. A tension meter can be installed in any type of winch, electric, hydraulic or conventional. There is no difference between the different types there and power can be controlled by one if desired. The issue is, does it make sense? Is the approximation calculated by the British design good enough? Or do we need a real time tension control winch? Would the inertia i the system even make this possible or desirable? I would say that setting the desired tension according to type and conditions by approximation, ala Skylaunch, and not worrying about the fluctuations is plenty good enough. The main reason is because designing a winch to be truly controlled in real time by the actual and current tension, micro second by microsecond, is probably very expensive, unproven and would not solve the inertia delay issue of the winch. Trying to chase the gusts so to speak - how would that work? A conventional winch type already lets the drum slow down and/or pulls the engine revs down if the cable tension increases due to a gust or thermal - thus reducing the tension - this is already a mechanically built in constant torque effect. This is by no means perfect, but certainly good enough to give mostly smooth launches. In gusty conditions, there is no winch in the world, not even on paper, that can react fast enough to dampen away the oscillations in cable tension and airspeed, due to the time delay in reacting to the changes in cable tension. We just need to figure out how to make a cheap reliable winch and find places to use them at. At $10-$15 a launch, a glider club or operator would quickly make a nice income, like European clubs do. The real cost of a winch launch is something like $3-5 per launch including maintenance, reserves and replacements. 30 launches a week x $10 profit = $1,200 extra a month. That's one very nice glider upgrade every 5 years. This is one of the main reasons why European clubs have such nice equipment. Tom |
#80
|
|||
|
|||
SAFE Winch Launching
At 04:19 15 July 2009, tommytoyz wrote: We just need to figure out how to make a cheap reliable winch and find places to use them at. At $10-$15 a launch, a glider club or operator would quickly make a nice income, like European clubs do. The real cost of a winch launch is something like $3-5 per launch including maintenance, reserves and replacements. 30 launches a week x $10 profit = $1,200 extra a month. That's one very nice glider upgrade every 5 years. This is one of the main reasons why European clubs have such nice equipment. There are winches already in operation in the US, there are groups who want to operate them, and there are groups trying to design and manufacture them. I think we need all of the above. I'm part of a wanna-be operating group, with limited funds. That pretty much means either finding a rebuildable Gehrlein, importing an inexpensive used winch from Europe, or homebrewing a new winch (based on the UK spec). I prefer the latter, as I think there is still plenty of room for optimization, both in fabrication and operation. While I respect those who are trying to push the envelope with advance power systems and launch automation, a simple single drum winch based on automotive components will be good enough for our local group get started. If you aren't a member of the Yahoo Winch Design group, please consider joining. While we have our share of spats, there is progress being made towards coming up with component designs for a cheap reliable non-automated winch... Marc |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
Winch Launching in US | john hawkins | Soaring | 11 | June 10th 09 12:18 PM |
Winch Launching | Rolf | Soaring | 27 | January 7th 09 02:48 AM |
Ka8b winch launching | Jimmie L. Coulthard | Soaring | 11 | September 9th 08 08:38 AM |
Aerotow Fuel Costs & Winch Launching | Derek Copeland[_2_] | Soaring | 2 | May 26th 08 03:14 PM |
LIppmann reports a 950 meter winch launch with their Dynatec winch line - anything higher? | Bill Daniels | Soaring | 20 | December 27th 04 12:33 AM |