If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
cylinder replacement
Hi,
I've owned my airplane, a '69 piper Cherokee, for about 5 years now, and it's finally time that one "annual from hell" that happens to everyone at some point or another to hit. The engine is a lycoming O-360 and currently has around 850 SMOH. It's been overhauled once in it's lifetime. It started with some aluminum shavings which led us to suspect bad piston pin plugs. My A&P pulled the cylinders, found that the piston pin plugs were indeed bad, and sent the cylinders to a cylinder shop for evaluation. Unfortunately, the shop has found that one cylinder had a cracked exhaust port and is unservicable. It needs to be replaced. I'm still waiting to hear on the other three, but at minimum they need to be rechromed and possibly some repair work as well. My A&P says that the lower half of the engine is in excellent condition, so there is no need for a full overhaul. This leaves me with three options: A) Replace all four cylinders with new at a cost of $1500 each. Times four that is $6000. B) Replace all four cylinders with "used" (reconditioned?) at a cost of $900 each. Total of $3700. C) Replace only the bad one and get the three remaining good ones rechromed and/or repaired. I don't know what the rechroming/repair fee will be on the other three yet, so that option is unknown. I'm supposed to hear back from the shop by tomorrow with an estimate. Of course, added to these costs are whatever labor and parts my A&P has accumulated during the annual, the labor to put the replacement cylinders back on, torque everything down, etc. Generally the rest of the annual went very well (which is the sole bit of good news). Anyway, my question to the other airplane owners out there -- which of the three options A, B, or C would you choose? In generally, my philosophy has been to avoid using "used" parts when at all possible, but of course these are very expensive parts. Unfortunately I have no budget saved up for this, so cost is a major factor to me. I'm probably looking at owning the airplane for another 400-500 hours maximum. Thus when I go to sell, the ad would read something like "1250 SMOH 400 STOH". Is the top-overhaul a selling point? Is the buyer going to care significantly whether I use new cylinders or used/reconditioned? Thanks! ----------------------------------------------------------- Posted using Android Newsgroup Downloader: .... http://www.sb-software.com/android ----------------------------------------------------------- |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
cylinder replacement
|
#3
|
|||
|
|||
cylinder replacement
In researching a crash of a Cessna 414, I found the following just this
morning. The crash was in 2001, and the full NTSB narrative written in 2003. I found the information below very interesting as we have 3 ECi cylinders on our Aztec. Maybe we should think more about the heads than the cylinders. YMMV Jim Excerpt from NTSB narrative: "Lycoming makes use of only new cylinder heads and new barrels in all of its cylinder assemblies, which are ultimately used on their factory new engines, engine overhauls, and rebuilt engines. Lycoming does not repair any component of its cylinder assemblies. Teledyne Continental makes use of only new cylinder heads and new barrels in its manufacture of new and rebuilt engines. ECi received FAA STC (SE4408SW) approval for the repair of 38 different Lycoming engine cylinder assemblies ranging from 320-720 series engines. The STC authorizes ECi to repair cylinder assemblies by removing and reusing used cylinder heads onto new ECi barrels, regardless of the cylinder head's time in service or number of times that it had been reassembled onto a cylinder head. The "serviceable" yellow tags for all the cylinders from the left engine do not make any reference that the assembly is an STC. The only regulatory reference provided on these tags was listed as: "Item Has been repaired by FAA approved process as follows:" Replacement parts per FAA approved applications listing" For product definition Refer to ECI's FAA approved Class Reference Manual." A cylinder assembly consists of two main components, the aluminum alloy head and the steel alloy barrel, which according to assembly procedures provided by the FAA, are screwed together while the head is at an elevated temperature in the vicinity of 600 ºF. |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
cylinder replacement
"Jim Burns" wrote in message ... In researching a crash of a Cessna 414, I found the following just this morning. The crash was in 2001, and the full NTSB narrative written in 2003. I found the information below very interesting as we have 3 ECi cylinders on our Aztec. Maybe we should think more about the heads than the cylinders. YMMV Jim Excerpt from NTSB narrative: "Lycoming makes use of only new cylinder heads and new barrels in all of its cylinder assemblies, which are ultimately used on their factory new engines, engine overhauls, and rebuilt engines. Lycoming does not repair any component of its cylinder assemblies. Teledyne Continental makes use of only new cylinder heads and new barrels in its manufacture of new and rebuilt engines. ECi received FAA STC (SE4408SW) approval for the repair of 38 different Lycoming engine cylinder assemblies ranging from 320-720 series engines. The STC authorizes ECi to repair cylinder assemblies by removing and reusing used cylinder heads onto new ECi barrels, regardless of the cylinder head's time in service or number of times that it had been reassembled onto a cylinder head. The "serviceable" yellow tags for all the cylinders from the left engine do not make any reference that the assembly is an STC. The only regulatory reference provided on these tags was listed as: "Item Has been repaired by FAA approved process as follows:" Replacement parts per FAA approved applications listing" For product definition Refer to ECI's FAA approved Class Reference Manual." A cylinder assembly consists of two main components, the aluminum alloy head and the steel alloy barrel, which according to assembly procedures provided by the FAA, are screwed together while the head is at an elevated temperature in the vicinity of 600 ºF. That does not mean NEW ECi cylinders have used heads. WWW.ECI2Fly.com You are comparing apples to oranges. Allen |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
cylinder replacement
You can do the 150-160 upgrade during a top overhaul. It doesn't involve the
bottom. "Bob Noel" wrote in message ... In article , wrote: [snip] Anyway, my question to the other airplane owners out there -- which of the three options A, B, or C would you choose? In generally, my philosophy has been to avoid using "used" parts when at all possible, but of course these are very expensive parts. Unfortunately I have no budget saved up for this, so cost is a major factor to me. how much time on each cylinder? (if you have a 150hp cherokee, then I'd overhaul the engine and upgrade it to 160hp). I personally would opt for new cylinders. I'm probably looking at owning the airplane for another 400-500 hours maximum. Thus when I go to sell, the ad would read something like "1250 SMOH 400 STOH". Is the top-overhaul a selling point? Is the buyer going to care significantly whether I use new cylinders or used/reconditioned? To me, "STOH" is completely meaningless. 1250 SMOH would be the driving factor. However, I would be very doubtful of used/reconditioned cylinders. -- Bob Noel Looking for a sig the lawyers will hate |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
cylinder replacement
"Allen" wrote in message
That does not mean NEW ECi cylinders have used heads. WWW.ECI2Fly.com You are comparing apples to oranges. Allen Completely correct. I was not intending to compare a used cylinder to a new cylinder. Nor did I say that. It may not have been evident from the excerpt that I quoted, but the engine failure was due to cylinder head fatigue. What I gathered from this is that you should be aware that, unless you buy new cylinders, you may be buying a new barrel and a used head because some companies mate used heads to new barrels and market them under STCs as cylinder replacements. The other point being that the FAA doesn't limit the hours on a head that can be mated to a new barrel. Jim |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
cylinder replacement
Ah ha.. I missed that point.
Please ignore my previous post. I know nothing about O-360 upgrades. "xyzzy" wrote in message ups.com... did they make 150hp O-360's? |
#9
|
|||
|
|||
cylinder replacement
"Jim Burns" wrote in message ... "Allen" wrote in message That does not mean NEW ECi cylinders have used heads. WWW.ECI2Fly.com You are comparing apples to oranges. Allen Completely correct. I was not intending to compare a used cylinder to a new cylinder. Nor did I say that. It may not have been evident from the excerpt that I quoted, but the engine failure was due to cylinder head fatigue. What I gathered from this is that you should be aware that, unless you buy new cylinders, you may be buying a new barrel and a used head because some companies mate used heads to new barrels and market them under STCs as cylinder replacements. The other point being that the FAA doesn't limit the hours on a head that can be mated to a new barrel. Jim That's true. They also do not limit the hours that can be on a crankshaft or crankcase, or the number of times it has been overhauled. You can get a NEW or REBUILT engine from TCM with a .010 under crankshaft and is still considered within NEW limits. Allen |
#10
|
|||
|
|||
cylinder replacement
If you REALLY plan on offing the bird in 400-500 hours, you may get away
with overhauls. But, if I were on the "receiving" (buying) end, I would give you zip for overhauled cylinders and consider the engine a runout. My bird got .010 oversized "first run" overhauls 800 hours ago from a "big name" shop. I am about to replace the THIRD cylinder. How much did I save??? (answer: nothing). Some say they get good service from overhauls. Other say they are junk. I don't understand how you get from approx $3700 to $7000 on a set of Superiors. Your wrench may charge you 20 hours for the swap. Even at $100/hour you should not break $6k total. Keep asking questions. Good Luck, Mike This leaves me with three options: A) Replace all four cylinders with new at a cost of $1500 each. Times four that is $6000. B) Replace all four cylinders with "used" (reconditioned?) at a cost of $900 each. Total of $3700. C) Replace only the bad one and get the three remaining good ones rechromed and/or repaired. I don't know what the rechroming/repair fee will be on the other three yet, so that option is unknown. I'm supposed to hear back from the shop by tomorrow with an estimate. |
|
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
Bad cylinder | Denny | Owning | 17 | September 12th 05 06:04 PM |
Path of an airplane in a 1G roll | Chris W | Piloting | 47 | July 4th 05 10:53 PM |
Path of an airplane in a 1G roll | Chris W | Aerobatics | 20 | June 29th 05 09:35 AM |
Path of an airplane in a 1G roll | Chris W | Home Built | 22 | June 29th 05 09:35 AM |
Start Anywhere Cylinder (SSA rules proposal) | Mark Navarre | Soaring | 15 | September 25th 03 01:13 PM |