wrote in message
ups.com...

You also stated multiple versions with different
circumstances, not just different wording. It is not clear
that you realize that.

I did phrase the question poorly. I have said that *several* times and
attempted to clarify the wording - not change the intent of the original
question.

Now that that's over, I still find that it is an interesting problem in
relativity and deserved rational discussion.

Rich S.