Chris wrote:
According to AOPA CJ is correct.

http://www.aopa.org/members/files/topics/pic.html

Any Pilot that is rated for the aircraft, meaning ASEL if the plane is
single engine land, can log PIC time for the time he is sole
manipulator of the controls. This is true whether or not he has a
current medical, BFR or, if the plane meets the criteria, the
endorsements required for high performance and/or complex aircraft.
However, there must be a pilot in the plane that DOES meet all the
requirements for the plane being flown.

Typical FAR's...clear as mud!

If you looked in Part 61, you would see that Part 61 with regards logging
PIC is pretty darn clear, you just need to read it in B&W without trying to
read between the lines.

BTW: This AOPA text is exactly consistent with what Bob and I wrote and
inconsistent with what CJ wrote.

Hilton