![]() |
If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#11
|
|||
|
|||
![]()
Tina wrote:
Still waiting for the conservation of momentum derivation. My husband, also trained as an engineer, casually remarked he didn't think you could get from Newton's First Law to the that confirms my memory, but we are both willing to have that belief rebutted. You can't get conservation of momentum from F = m*a (or vice versa) since the latter is not a statement about anything being conserved. But you can get "For every force there is an equal opposite force" from conservation of momentum, and vice versa, with a small number of assumptions. You can use derivatives to derive one way and integration to derive the other. Here are several conservation laws that share a common derivation, starting with: Center of Mass is Conserved --------------------------- Center of mass of a closed system of particles of mass m1, m2, m3, ... mn must remain fixed for all time, which with a suitable selection of coordinate origins may be stated mathematically as: (a) m1*x1 + m2*x2 + m3*x3 + ... = 0 m1*y1 + m2*y2 + m3*y3 + ... = 0 m1*z1 + m2*z2 + m3*z3 + ... = 0 Note that this doesn't say that, for example, x1 can't vary with time. It only says that if it does then m1, m2, m3, x2 or x3 or other masses or positions must somehow change so the left hand side still remains zero. Momentum is Conserved --------------------- If position with respect to time is continuous (no discontinuities; e.g. no jumps) then we can take the time derivative of the above, yielding: (b) m1*dx1/dt + m2*dx2/dt + m3*dx3/dt + ... = 0 (And so on for the other coordinate axis.) This is of course just the conservation of momentum equations because dx1/dt = Vx1, a velocity. Note that d(m1*x1)/dt would have been more appropriate if the mass of particles varies with time. Force is Conserved ------------------ Given the continuity assumption above, then we can keep taking time derivatives of the above, yielding the next conservation statement: (c) m1*d^2(x1)/dt^2 + m2*d^2(x2)/dt^2 + m3*d^2(x3)/dt^2 + ... = 0 (And so on for the other coordinate axis.) This is of course just the old equal and opposite action statement in mathematical form because d^2(x1)/dt^2 = ax1, an acceleration. So if one claims any _one_ of the above conservation laws exists then the other two appear to follow with only a small set of (presumably reasonable) assumptions. |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
![]() |
||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
How much lift do you need? | Dan Luke | Piloting | 3 | April 16th 07 02:46 PM |
Theories of lift | Avril Poisson | General Aviation | 3 | April 28th 06 07:20 AM |
what the heck is lift? | buttman | Piloting | 72 | September 16th 05 11:50 PM |
Lift Query | Avril Poisson | General Aviation | 8 | April 21st 05 07:50 PM |
thermal lift | ekantian | Soaring | 0 | October 5th 04 02:55 PM |