USS Liberty Challenge/Reward

wrote in message . com...

[snip]

(Issac Goldberg) wrote in message . com...
The main point, which Hillel does his best to avoid is:

Congress never conducted an investigation solely concerning
the USS Liberty affair, and Cristol's web page does not refute
that.

Congress never conducted an investigation of *MOST* affairs. Congress
usually investigates only if there is a high profile case or there
are indications that the executive branch lied; e.g. Joseph McCarthy
communists' hunt, Iran-Contra affair, Watergate.

Congress has thoroughly investigated every disaster involving
the US Navy EXCEPT for the USS Liberty.

[snip]

#Congress never conducted an investigation of *MOST* affairs. Congress
# usually investigates only if there is a high profile case or there
# are indications that the executive branch lied; e.g. Joseph McCarthy
# communists' hunt, Iran-Contra affair, Watergate.

(Issac Goldberg) wrote in message . com...
Congress has thoroughly investigated every disaster involving
the US Navy EXCEPT for the USS Liberty.

Really?!
Would you like to compare the The USS Stark Incident
(see http://eightiesclub.tripod.com/id344.htm), with
37 American seamen dead, to the Liberty?

Can you please tell us what special investgation Congress did about
the Stark and not about the Liberty? Come on, you made a claim now
prove it.

BTW my impression is that Congress usually accepts the Navy's Court
of inquiry conclusions; e.g. USS Greeneville. If you have some
counter examples, where Congress rejected the Navy's Court
of inquiry conclusions, then please post them.