A aviation & planes forum. AviationBanter

If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.

Go Back   Home » AviationBanter forum » rec.aviation newsgroups » Piloting
Site Map Home Register Authors List Search Today's Posts Mark Forums Read Web Partners

Can a Plane on a Treadmill Take Off?



 
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
  #1  
Old February 4th 06, 02:33 PM posted to rec.aviation.student,rec.aviation.piloting
external usenet poster
 
Posts: n/a
Default Can a Plane on a Treadmill Take Off?


"cjcampbell" wrote in message
oups.com...
Saw this question on "The Straight Dope" and I thought it was amusing.

http://www.straightdope.com/columns/060203.html

The question goes like this:

"An airplane on a runway sits on a conveyer belt that moves in the
opposite direction at exactly the speed that the airplane is moving
forward. Does the airplane take off?" (Assuming the tires hold out, of
course.)


AH! ...here's the problem! Are the airplane and the belt moving at equal
speeds in opposite directions
relative to the world? (-X mph for the belt & +X mph for the plane = eg.
airspeed of 100mph &
wheel speed of 200mph) If so the airplane could take off. The answer to this
question would be easy --
is the airspeed high enough or not?

......OR relative to each other? If so, there could be just enough thrust
applied to overcome frictional
forces and the airplane doesn't move relative to the world so airspeed is 0.

BUT WAIT!!! .... ANY two objects can be said to be moving (or not) at equal
speeds relative to each other. A point
on the conveyer belt moving east at 4mph and a jet moving west at 600mph
each have a relative velocity of 604
with respect to each other and there could be an observer who sees each
object moving in opposite directions
at 302mph. The only real question is how fast is the airplane moving with
respect to the air(world).

Thrust is an external force applied to the conveyer belt/airplane system.


Cecil Adams (world's smartest human being) says that it will take off
normally.


He likely had a little more information than is available in the OP.


  #2  
Old February 4th 06, 03:31 PM posted to rec.aviation.student,rec.aviation.piloting
external usenet poster
 
Posts: n/a
Default Can a Plane on a Treadmill Take Off?


"muff528" wrote in message
news:OW2Ff.179$DV2.5@trnddc07...

.....OR relative to each other? If so, there could be just enough thrust
applied to overcome frictional
forces and the airplane doesn't move relative to the world so airspeed is

0.

That would have to be either a very underpowered airplane, or wheels with a
lot of friction.

BUT WAIT!!! .... ANY two objects can be said to be moving (or not) at

equal
speeds relative to each other. A point
on the conveyer belt moving east at 4mph and a jet moving west at 600mph
each have a relative velocity of 604


But there's the trick. A treadmill belt isn't really moving at all, it's
turning.
Try this for a brain scrambler. Think about a tire on your car, driving down
the highway. At the point where the tire contacts the ground, it's speed is
zero. 180° away, at the top, it is moving forward at twice the speed of the
car.


  #3  
Old February 4th 06, 04:00 PM posted to rec.aviation.student,rec.aviation.piloting
external usenet poster
 
Posts: n/a
Default Can a Plane on a Treadmill Take Off?


"Michael Ware" wrote in message
. ..

"muff528" wrote in message
news:OW2Ff.179$DV2.5@trnddc07...

.....OR relative to each other? If so, there could be just enough thrust
applied to overcome frictional
forces and the airplane doesn't move relative to the world so airspeed

is
0.

That would have to be either a very underpowered airplane, or wheels with

a
lot of friction.


Yes!..that's why I said "COULD be just enough thrust..." More thrust than is
necessary
to overcome friction would result in the airplane moving forward relative to
the air. Then
it's only a question of how much thrust would be necessary to move the plane
forward fast
enough through the air to overcome gravity :-) A little less thrust would
result in the airplane
going backwards but not as fast as the conveyer. In any case the relative
velocities of the
plane to the conveyer would be equal to observers on either object but NOT
to an observer
standing on dirt.


BUT WAIT!!! .... ANY two objects can be said to be moving (or not) at

equal
speeds relative to each other. A point
on the conveyer belt moving east at 4mph and a jet moving west at 600mph
each have a relative velocity of 604


But there's the trick. A treadmill belt isn't really moving at all, it's
turning.


Again, Yes....but that's why I said "a POINT on the conveyer.." not the
conveyer
system itself.

The trick is that the original question as posted asks a question (will the
plane take off) and gives just enough info
to cause assumptions that aren't specified.

Try this for a brain scrambler. Think about a tire on your car, driving

down
the highway. At the point where the tire contacts the ground, it's speed

is
zero. 180° away, at the top, it is moving forward at twice the speed of

the
car.


Yes, but only for a very brief instant in time. And since velocity is
measured as a function of
time, is that point on the tire really moving at all at that one brief
instant when the measurement
is taken? :-)




  #9  
Old February 5th 06, 04:27 AM posted to rec.aviation.student,rec.aviation.piloting
external usenet poster
 
Posts: n/a
Default Can a Plane on a Treadmill Take Off?

Dave Doe wrote:


Try this for a brain scrambler. Think about a tire on your car, driving down
the highway. At the point where the tire contacts the ground, it's speed is
zero. 180° away, at the top, it is moving forward at twice the speed of the
car.


Negative - yer forgetting centripetal force.

http://www.wordiq.com/definition/Centripetal


Well, I'm impressed that you know of the existence of centripetal
force. But in what possible way do you think it negates the comment
about the speeds (relative to the ground) of points at the top and
bottom of the tire on a moving car?
--
Alex -- Replace "nospam" with "mail" to reply by email. Checked infrequently.
  #10  
Old February 4th 06, 10:31 PM posted to rec.aviation.student,rec.aviation.piloting
external usenet poster
 
Posts: n/a
Default Can a Plane on a Treadmill Take Off?

Let' say it this way. The airplane is moving forward at 60 kts. Does
that make it more clear?

The airplane is moving forward at 60, the belt, using the model in the
OP, is moving backwards at 60. The wheels are turning at 120 kts. If
it's a 172 it'll lift off into, on a calm day, 60 kts of airspeed over
the wings.

It's a nicely phrased question that caught me at first as well.
Substitute real speeds into what had been posted and the answer becomes
clear to me, although a lawyer in the group might find a (ground) loop
hole.

 




Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

vB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Forum Jump

Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Passenger crash-lands plane after pilot suffers heart attack R.L. Piloting 7 May 7th 05 11:17 PM
Navy sues man for plane he recovered in swamp marc Owning 6 March 29th 04 12:06 AM
rec.aviation.aerobatics FAQ Dr. Guenther Eichhorn Aerobatics 0 October 1st 03 07:27 AM
rec.aviation.aerobatics FAQ Dr. Guenther Eichhorn Aerobatics 0 September 1st 03 07:27 AM
rec.aviation.aerobatics FAQ Dr. Guenther Eichhorn Aerobatics 0 August 1st 03 07:27 AM


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 02:57 PM.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004-2025 AviationBanter.
The comments are property of their posters.