A aviation & planes forum. AviationBanter

If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.

Go Back   Home » AviationBanter forum » rec.aviation newsgroups » Soaring
Site Map Home Register Authors List Search Today's Posts Mark Forums Read Web Partners

How dangerous is soaring?



 
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
  #1  
Old November 2nd 07, 12:32 AM posted to rec.aviation.soaring
Ian
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 306
Default How dangerous is soaring?

On 1 Nov, 22:46, Chris Reed wrote:

If we ignore the past, however, each day's chance is the same at 0.5.
Thus Ray (may he live forever) is able to state that next year his
chances will be pretty much the same, if he makes it that far.


That's not his claim, though. He seems to be saying that his chance of
dying tomorrow is 1 in 80, his chance of dying the day after that is 1
in 80 and so on to 1st November 2008, but that his chance of dying at
all during that year is still only 1 in 80. I do hope he'll explain,
in case I'm missing something obvious ...

Cumulation of probabilities is what the human brain does automatically.
Suppose the chance of being killed on a glider flight is 1 in 1,000. The
mind (without extensive training) deals with this in a number of ways:


The prblem, of course, is that one cannot be killed twice, so it does
not make sense to combine (simply) the probabilities of dying on
different days. Multiple survival is the aim, and survival
probabilities can be combined quite easily. Just recast our statement
as "The chance of surviving a glider flight is 999 in 1,000"...

3. At my club we fly 1,000 flights a year between us, so one of us is
sure to die flying.


There's actually a 63% chance that one of you will have bought the
farm by the end of the year. Get a new safety officer!

a. In the UK where I fly, gliding fatalities are on average around 2.5
per annum out of 5,000 pilots, so my "statistical" risk is around 1 in
2,000 of dying through gliding each year.


Agreed.

b. I can do a number of things to reduce my personal risk to less than 1
in 2,000, so I'll try to do those things.


Agreed.

c. This is, to me, an acceptable level of risk for the pleasure I get
from gliding.


Agreed.

The good thing is that these probabilities are not cumulative. I've been
flying for 11 years, so if they were cumulative my "statistical" risk
might be down to under 1 in 20. It ain't.


Your chance of making it through the next 11 years is still 99.5% I
reckon you can improve that to 99.95% by application of non-stupidity!

Ian

  #2  
Old November 2nd 07, 12:21 PM posted to rec.aviation.soaring
1LK
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 11
Default How dangerous is soaring?

On Nov 1, 7:32 pm, Ian wrote:
On 1 Nov, 22:46, Chris Reed wrote:

If we ignore the past, however, each day's chance is the same at 0.5.
Thus Ray (may he live forever) is able to state that next year his
chances will be pretty much the same, if he makes it that far.


That's not his claim, though. He seems to be saying that his chance of
dying tomorrow is 1 in 80, his chance of dying the day after that is 1
in 80 and so on to 1st November 2008, but that his chance of dying at
all during that year is still only 1 in 80. I do hope he'll explain,
in case I'm missing something obvious ...

Cumulation of probabilities is what the human brain does automatically.
Suppose the chance of being killed on a glider flight is 1 in 1,000. The
mind (without extensive training) deals with this in a number of ways:


The prblem, of course, is that one cannot be killed twice, so it does
not make sense to combine (simply) the probabilities of dying on
different days. Multiple survival is the aim, and survival
probabilities can be combined quite easily. Just recast our statement
as "The chance of surviving a glider flight is 999 in 1,000"...

3. At my club we fly 1,000 flights a year between us, so one of us is
sure to die flying.


There's actually a 63% chance that one of you will have bought the
farm by the end of the year. Get a new safety officer!

a. In the UK where I fly, gliding fatalities are on average around 2.5
per annum out of 5,000 pilots, so my "statistical" risk is around 1 in
2,000 of dying through gliding each year.


Agreed.

b. I can do a number of things to reduce my personal risk to less than 1
in 2,000, so I'll try to do those things.


Agreed.

I appologise for starting a statistical discussion; there's enough of
that at work. The important point is the one made in Chris's post
that gliding carries a risk in the range of one to between two and
three thousand depending on what denominator is used. Serving in Iraq
carries a similar risk, but the population isn't uniform; there's
clearly a difference in being in being part of the rear echelon vs
patrolling the streets. Our population is similarly stratified in
terms of risk.

There are also, unfortunately, factors beyond personal control in
play. As I've aged, I've noted that I need a bit more distance
between myself and the car in front of me. My head needs to swivel to
a greater degree to see things in the periphery. These effects can be
measured/quantified. Medical events such as stroke or MI have been
suggested as the cause of a number of accidents; the ones that killed
the student who soloed ahead of me where I learned to fly in SoCal and
that of a friend who crashed during the return to Kitty Hawk were
likely caused by medical incapacitation. As I age, my risk of such
events increases.

The important thing, IMHO, is to recognize the risk, decide what
you're willing to accept, and, if you choose to go forward, control
what you can and hope that what you can't won't kill you.

Ray Warshaw
1LK


c. This is, to me, an acceptable level of risk for the pleasure I

get
from gliding.


Agreed.

The good thing is that these probabilities are not cumulative. I've been
flying for 11 years, so if they were cumulative my "statistical" risk
might be down to under 1 in 20. It ain't.


Your chance of making it through the next 11 years is still 99.5% I
reckon you can improve that to 99.95% by application of non-stupidity!

Ian



  #3  
Old November 2nd 07, 01:14 PM posted to rec.aviation.soaring
Tom Gardner
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 141
Default How dangerous is soaring?

On Nov 2, 12:21 pm, 1LK wrote:
Serving in Iraq
carries a similar risk, but the population isn't uniform; there's
clearly a difference in being in being part of the rear echelon vs
patrolling the streets.


It is always worth comparing one risk with another, as
a sanity check.

During the first Gulf War in 1991, it was safer to be a black GI
on active service in the Gulf than it was to be a black civilian
in Washington DC.

In this case "safer" means probability of non-accidental death
per 100,000 people.

When I first heard that I was sufficiently suspicious that I went
down the library (it was just as the web was arriving) and checked
the sources myself.

The other surprising statistic is the age at which you are
most likely to be a homicide victim in the UK. Most people
presume 16-24, but actually it is three times more
likely to be deliberately killed when you are under 1 year
old. And 55% of those homicides are committed by females.

(N.B. I used "homicide" very deliberately, not murder)

 




Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

vB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Forum Jump

Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Those *dangerous* Korean War relics Kingfish Piloting 192 June 19th 06 07:06 PM
Okay, so maybe flying *is* dangerous... Jay Honeck Piloting 51 August 31st 05 03:02 AM
Dangerous Stuff [email protected] Rotorcraft 21 July 16th 05 05:55 PM
New news Soaring is dangerous ? R Barry Soaring 29 October 3rd 04 03:40 AM
small airplanes are dangerous JimTheBoatMan Piloting 31 April 29th 04 10:44 PM


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 07:11 AM.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004-2025 AviationBanter.
The comments are property of their posters.