21m tipped Lak 17b!

You mean 850Kg?

If a 21m Lak 17B were to have a wing area similar to the
12.25m2 of the JS1C 21m then at 850kg MAUW it would have a
wingloading of over 69kg/m2! I am not sure where the water
would go. With the JS1C 21m you need to fill the wings, the
21m tips, have fuselage tanks full of water or fuel and a not too
lightweight pilot to get to the MAUW 720kg and 59kg/m2

Furthermore an 21m Lak 17 is likely to have an even smaller
wing area (and ?less water capacity) because the 18m Lak has
a wing area of 10.32m2 compared to 11.21m2 for an 18m JS1.

John Galloway




At 15:32 21 October 2013, Sean F F2 wrote:
They need a strong US (or Canadian) pilot RACING the glider
in US contests.
Period.

The Uvalde and Euro pilots have not been top shelf. JS1 is
better
connected and has many top pilots flying their hardware in
contrast.

I agree the 21 meter version needs to be at 850 if it is going
to be
seriously competitive at a world level BUT...in the US east
coast contest
environment it would probably be just fine if it was not able to
achieve
850.

I'll check and see what the specs say on the website...

No specs on the website yet - but announced on Blanik America site and in
the article on the Mini Lak on their news pages about the tips.

I'm presuming you can fly at 15. 18 and 21m with the same ship? Which will
probably make it a popular ship in the US- and agree with Sean bargain
and piloting points.

Upping to 850 kg probably not on- but maybe around the 650-700kg mark?
which would probably give it a similar wing loading to the JS1 with the
smaller wing area.

Now I wonder if the asg 29 is going to be tipped to 21m? (I know its a
tipped 27! and they have the ASH 31).



At 16:36 21 October 2013, John Galloway wrote:
You mean 850Kg?

If a 21m Lak 17B were to have a wing area similar to the
12.25m2 of the JS1C 21m then at 850kg MAUW it would have a
wingloading of over 69kg/m2! I am not sure where the water
would go. With the JS1C 21m you need to fill the wings, the
21m tips, have fuselage tanks full of water or fuel and a not too
lightweight pilot to get to the MAUW 720kg and 59kg/m2

Furthermore an 21m Lak 17 is likely to have an even smaller
wing area (and ?less water capacity) because the 18m Lak has
a wing area of 10.32m2 compared to 11.21m2 for an 18m JS1.

John Galloway




At 15:32 21 October 2013, Sean F F2 wrote:
They need a strong US (or Canadian) pilot RACING the glider
in US contests.
Period.

The Uvalde and Euro pilots have not been top shelf. JS1 is
better
connected and has many top pilots flying their hardware in
contrast.

I agree the 21 meter version needs to be at 850 if it is going
to be
seriously competitive at a world level BUT...in the US east
coast contest
environment it would probably be just fine if it was not able to
achieve
850.

I'll check and see what the specs say on the website...

Paul,

I just got an email back from Vytas (owner of Lak factory). Here is his statement: "MAX mass remains 600 kg as 18 m class mass, as no space for more water."

That makes sense to me. I think there is ZERO chance the ASG29 will ever get 21 meter tips OR 800kg max weight as its wing is simply not designed for the loads (just like the 17b). Also, the 18 meter tips barely fit in the trailer. Makes me wonder how the Lak17b could fit all these wingtips in a trailer as well. Anyway, the requirement for a 21 meter single for Schleicher has been fulfilled by the ASG 31.

Info on ASG31 --- http://www.alexander-schleicher.de/p...h31_main_e.htm

The 31, as with most motor gliders, has too much wing loading in 18 meter configuration when flying in weak lift. It is better at 21 meters where it can go to 700 kg and 10.8 lbs/sqft wing loading (no, not 800!). Min wing loading looks to be about 8.82 (with a 200 lb pilot) in 18 meter and 8.09 in 21 meter.

Hope this helps to answer your questions on the Schleicher's.

Sean


On Monday, October 21, 2013 1:20:15 PM UTC-4, Paul T wrote:
No specs on the website yet - but announced on Blanik America site and in

the article on the Mini Lak on their news pages about the tips.



I'm presuming you can fly at 15. 18 and 21m with the same ship? Which will

probably make it a popular ship in the US- and agree with Sean bargain

and piloting points.



Upping to 850 kg probably not on- but maybe around the 650-700kg mark?

which would probably give it a similar wing loading to the JS1 with the

smaller wing area.



Now I wonder if the asg 29 is going to be tipped to 21m? (I know its a

tipped 27! and they have the ASH 31).







At 16:36 21 October 2013, John Galloway wrote:

You mean 850Kg?



If a 21m Lak 17B were to have a wing area similar to the

12.25m2 of the JS1C 21m then at 850kg MAUW it would have a

wingloading of over 69kg/m2! I am not sure where the water

would go. With the JS1C 21m you need to fill the wings, the

21m tips, have fuselage tanks full of water or fuel and a not too

lightweight pilot to get to the MAUW 720kg and 59kg/m2



Furthermore an 21m Lak 17 is likely to have an even smaller

wing area (and ?less water capacity) because the 18m Lak has

a wing area of 10.32m2 compared to 11.21m2 for an 18m JS1.



John Galloway









At 15:32 21 October 2013, Sean F F2 wrote:

They need a strong US (or Canadian) pilot RACING the glider

in US contests.

Period.



The Uvalde and Euro pilots have not been top shelf. JS1 is

better

connected and has many top pilots flying their hardware in

contrast.



I agree the 21 meter version needs to be at 850 if it is going

to be

seriously competitive at a world level BUT...in the US east

coast contest

environment it would probably be just fine if it was not able to

achieve

850.



I'll check and see what the specs say on the website...

Blanik America leaves a little to be desired in terms of website quality, for sure ;-)

For that matter, all the glider manufacturers websites are fairly poor to be honest.

Sean

On Monday, October 21, 2013 2:36:51 PM UTC-4, Sean F (F2) wrote:
Paul,



I just got an email back from Vytas (owner of Lak factory). Here is his statement: "MAX mass remains 600 kg as 18 m class mass, as no space for more water."



That makes sense to me. I think there is ZERO chance the ASG29 will ever get 21 meter tips OR 800kg max weight as its wing is simply not designed for the loads (just like the 17b). Also, the 18 meter tips barely fit in the trailer. Makes me wonder how the Lak17b could fit all these wingtips in a trailer as well. Anyway, the requirement for a 21 meter single for Schleicher has been fulfilled by the ASG 31.



Info on ASG31 --- http://www.alexander-schleicher.de/p...h31_main_e.htm



The 31, as with most motor gliders, has too much wing loading in 18 meter configuration when flying in weak lift. It is better at 21 meters where it can go to 700 kg and 10.8 lbs/sqft wing loading (no, not 800!). Min wing loading looks to be about 8.82 (with a 200 lb pilot) in 18 meter and 8.09 in 21 meter.



Hope this helps to answer your questions on the Schleicher's.



Sean





On Monday, October 21, 2013 1:20:15 PM UTC-4, Paul T wrote:

No specs on the website yet - but announced on Blanik America site and in



the article on the Mini Lak on their news pages about the tips.







I'm presuming you can fly at 15. 18 and 21m with the same ship? Which will



probably make it a popular ship in the US- and agree with Sean bargain



and piloting points.







Upping to 850 kg probably not on- but maybe around the 650-700kg mark?



which would probably give it a similar wing loading to the JS1 with the



smaller wing area.







Now I wonder if the asg 29 is going to be tipped to 21m? (I know its a



tipped 27! and they have the ASH 31).















At 16:36 21 October 2013, John Galloway wrote:



You mean 850Kg?







If a 21m Lak 17B were to have a wing area similar to the



12.25m2 of the JS1C 21m then at 850kg MAUW it would have a



wingloading of over 69kg/m2! I am not sure where the water



would go. With the JS1C 21m you need to fill the wings, the



21m tips, have fuselage tanks full of water or fuel and a not too



lightweight pilot to get to the MAUW 720kg and 59kg/m2







Furthermore an 21m Lak 17 is likely to have an even smaller



wing area (and ?less water capacity) because the 18m Lak has



a wing area of 10.32m2 compared to 11.21m2 for an 18m JS1.







John Galloway



















At 15:32 21 October 2013, Sean F F2 wrote:



They need a strong US (or Canadian) pilot RACING the glider



in US contests.



Period.







The Uvalde and Euro pilots have not been top shelf. JS1 is



better



connected and has many top pilots flying their hardware in



contrast.







I agree the 21 meter version needs to be at 850 if it is going



to be



seriously competitive at a world level BUT...in the US east



coast contest



environment it would probably be just fine if it was not able to



achieve



850.







I'll check and see what the specs say on the website...

Sean I'll raise my hand if you find one to fly

Sorry - tounge in cheek comment about the 29 - I'm English. The problem
with ASH 31 (not ASG 31) is the motor and too much wing area -it was
designed more as a recreational self launcher than a competitive ship

Looks like the JSIc will be the best bang for the buck if your serious
competing in both 18 and Open Class - the Lak 17b maybe for 15 and 18m?
(depending on what the Ventus 2 replacement will be like!- but that'll
probably cost a lot more)

The JS1C certainly seems competetive with the Quintus and EB29 which cost a
fair bit more - but your also paying for the ability to self launch I geuss
with the latter two.

But I like the concept of a ship that can be flown at 3 diffferent spans!
Did Vytas say it can be flown at 15, 18, and 21m?



At 18:36 21 October 2013, Sean F F2 wrote:
Paul,

I just got an email back from Vytas (owner of Lak factory). Here is his
st=
atement: "MAX mass remains 600 kg as 18 m class mass, as no space for
more=
water."

That makes sense to me. I think there is ZERO chance the ASG29 will ever
g=
et 21 meter tips OR 800kg max weight as its wing is simply not designed
for=
the loads (just like the 17b). Also, the 18 meter tips barely fit in
the
=
trailer. Makes me wonder how the Lak17b could fit all these wingtips in
a
=
trailer as well. Anyway, the requirement for a 21 meter single for
Schleic=
her has been fulfilled by the ASG 31. =20

Info on ASG31 ---
http://www.alexander-schleicher.de/p.../ash31/ash31_=
main_e.htm

The 31, as with most motor gliders, has too much wing loading in 18 meter
c=
onfiguration when flying in weak lift. It is better at 21 meters where
it
=
can go to 700 kg and 10.8 lbs/sqft wing loading (no, not 800!). Min wing
l=
oading looks to be about 8.82 (with a 200 lb pilot) in 18 meter and 8.09
in=
21 meter.

Hope this helps to answer your questions on the Schleicher's.

Sean=20


On Monday, October 21, 2013 1:20:15 PM UTC-4, Paul T wrote:
No specs on the website yet - but announced on Blanik America site and
in
=20
the article on the Mini Lak on their news pages about the tips.
=20
=20
=20
I'm presuming you can fly at 15. 18 and 21m with the same ship? Which
wi=
ll
=20
probably make it a popular ship in the US- and agree with Sean
bargai=
n
=20
and piloting points.
=20
=20
=20
Upping to 850 kg probably not on- but maybe around the 650-700kg mark?
=20
which would probably give it a similar wing loading to the JS1 with the
=20
smaller wing area.
=20
=20
=20
Now I wonder if the asg 29 is going to be tipped to 21m? (I know its a
=20
tipped 27! and they have the ASH 31).
=20
=20
=20
=20
=20
=20
=20
At 16:36 21 October 2013, John Galloway wrote:
=20
You mean 850Kg? =20
=20

=20
If a 21m Lak 17B were to have a wing area similar to the=20
=20
12.25m2 of the JS1C 21m then at 850kg MAUW it would have a=20
=20
wingloading of over 69kg/m2! I am not sure where the water=20
=20
would go. With the JS1C 21m you need to fill the wings, the=20
=20
21m tips, have fuselage tanks full of water or fuel and a not too=20
=20
lightweight pilot to get to the MAUW 720kg and 59kg/m2
=20

=20
Furthermore an 21m Lak 17 is likely to have an even smaller=20
=20
wing area (and ?less water capacity) because the 18m Lak has=20
=20
a wing area of 10.32m2 compared to 11.21m2 for an 18m JS1.
=20

=20
John Galloway
=20

=20

=20

=20

=20
At 15:32 21 October 2013, Sean F F2 wrote:
=20
They need a strong US (or Canadian) pilot RACING the glider=20
=20
in US contests.
=20
Period.
=20

=20
The Uvalde and Euro pilots have not been top shelf. JS1 is=20
=20
better
=20
connected and has many top pilots flying their hardware in=20
=20
contrast. =20
=20

=20
I agree the 21 meter version needs to be at 850 if it is going=20
=20
to be
=20
seriously competitive at a world level BUT...in the US east=20
=20
coast contest
=20
environment it would probably be just fine if it was not able to=20
=20
achieve
=20
850.
=20

=20
I'll check and see what the specs say on the website...
=20

=20

=20

Yep, 17b can be flown in all 3 spans if you want to lug all those tips around! Maybe even 4 (13.5)....! I think that glider is just a 17b with a cap on the base wing?

JS1c is an awesome, proven machine for sure. Sorry on the ASH ;-).

Sean

When clean, LAK goes like mothe..XXXXX. Beats V2 side by side on fast glide every time. Tried it dozens of times. Any rain or impurity, it suffers a lot and V2 climbs away as well as glides to sunset.

On Tuesday, October 22, 2013 1:42:22 PM UTC-7, Sean F (F2) wrote:
Yep, 17b can be flown in all 3 spans if you want to lug all those tips around! Maybe even 4 (13.5)....! I think that glider is just a 17b with a cap on the base wing?


Can I get a 13.5 meter option too? That would be awesome!

Yes. You can fly 13.5 as well!