For Keith Willshaw...

In article ,
on 16 Jun 2004 12:46:12 GMT,
Denyav attempted to say .....


It was long presumed that as Japanase Fleet approached Hawaii it maintained
complete radio silence.This is a total lie.The Fleet barely barely observed
discredition,let alone silence.
McCollums OPI intercepted and translated various Naval dispatches some clearly
revealing that That PH was the target.
The Most significant of them the was following,sent from Adm.Yamamato to the
Japanase first air fleet on November 26.
"The Task force,keeping its movement strickly secret and maintaining close
guard aganist submarines and aircraft,shall advance into HAwaian waters and
upon the very opening of the hostilities shall attack main force of US fleet
and deal it a mortal blow.First air raid planned for the dawn of x-day.Exact
date to be given by later order"

Umm, you do know that Adm Yamamoto was in the home waters on one of the
battleships ?
And that the "First Air Fleet" WAS the Pearl Harbor attack force.
So this aledged interecpts was of a transmision to NOT from the attack
force.

Also, just where does that quote come from ?


--
When dealing with propaganda terminology one sometimes always speaks in
variable absolutes. This is not to be mistaken for an unbiased slant.

Umm, you do know that Adm Yamamoto was in the home waters on one of the
battleships ?
And that the "First Air Fleet" WAS the Pearl Harbor attack force.
So this aledged interecpts was of a transmision to NOT from the attack
force.

Yes,as I clearly stated in the post this message dated Nov,26 is from Yamamato
to First Air Fleet.

There are 2 seperate things in this story
1)Did US (or Brits,Dutch) break Japanase naval code JN25b before Pearl Harbor?
2)Did Task force break radio sience break radio silence between Nov.26 and Dec7
?

1)Naval code was surely broken on Nov,16(also before Task force left home
waters)but probably earlier.
2)Task Force did break radio silence at least 28 times.

lso, just where does that quote come from ?

From Crane IN,
Current position: Yes they decoded it but they were unable to translate it
because of shortage of personel.If you buy it.