![]() |
If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
|
#1
|
|||
|
|||
![]()
On Wednesday, January 31, 2018 at 11:12:45 AM UTC-8, Clay wrote:
Something is keeping pilots from racing in droves. The pilots I have asked will (and often do) fly the same terrain on the same day - they aren't beginners and this is not beginner terrain where we fly. Several have participated in a few races, then quit doing so because they felt they needed to violate their minimum safety criteria to have any chance. You can't have it both ways: "if you don't like it don't race" and "we want more people to race". The idea that folks should show up, pay the entry fee, take the time off, just to participate for fun using a different standard of safety with the knowledge that this will make them uncompetitive isn't attractive to a lot of pilots. They can go fly and have a nice cross country day anytime, anywhere, without any of that. By keeping the sport confined to your definition of pure, you are making it vanish. In almost all speed sports, rules have been put in place to curtail extreme behavior for the sake of fair and safe competition. Why is soaring so different? P3 has floated the idea of skill/experience-based classes. When I road-raced motorcycles, that was the system. It is fun to race against people of similar experience, and not be getting stuffed by the fast guys in every corner. The trophies come quicker too. In soaring, even in Sports Class, you'll be competing against WGC caliber pilots. Kinda exciting, but not so much when you get smoked by 20 mph. But I don't know if we really have the level of participation to do this kind of format, or even if it would solve anything. To be clear, experience is not the issue in the pilots I mention. However the local racing events run at our glider port are handicapped by pilot skill. (I can hear the gasps and harrumpfs already.) It isn't a perfect system, but gives the hope - and sometime the reality - that a less experienced pilot can win or place. It is self correcting in that the handicap is increased with wins or places so it becomes harder to win as the pilot goes faster.. This makes everyone try harder. This has definitely increased participation as it challenges everyone, skilled and novice. The original notion of sports class was to keep the high rated pilots out, but that got thrown away in the interest of filling the grid. |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
![]()
Along this line, and only in region 2 AFAIK.....there were "little guys meets". These were run on 2 successive weekends (no vacation time) and were broken into silver and gold classes.
I believe they were handicapped in both classes, did the full "regional contest routine" (pilots meetings, tasking, turnpoints, final reporting, everything) EXCEPT it was not a sanctioned contest so no points on the line. The dividing line was basically level of SSA badge until you "overflew the silver class" and were bumped into the gold class. So yes, a glass gold pilot may be up against Ron Schwartz in his 1-26, Ron may very well win a day! This was a good way to get started, I know, that was my first couple "contests". I believe P3 and others in the area did the same. This was waaaayyyyyyy before "rookie camps" as run in some locations now. I think both have a place as a starter to contests. Part of it is, when you may not fly on a local given day, a "contest" means, "go fly, do your best". I know several at our club (WH and others) were brought up with this mindset. While I have not flown much recently, I used to drag peeps out on a lot of days just to "go somewhere" as well as Hank and others. Heck, sometimes I went "blasting off" in our 1-26 (sn002) prompting glass guys to follow. Figured my performance handicap would make others feel better following in a 30-40:1 ship compared to the "light wing floater". I have no good answer to elevating contest participation. I know there was a time that for me, work travel, family stuff (2 growing kids), etc. made it hard to go to contests. Since then, lack of currency (my past comment that our "rule" was 40+Hrs in that ship, that season before contest day 1) was sorely tested. Frankly, I don't do 40hrs a season now......hope to change that. Just sorta watching to see where peeps are going with this, adding comments as I think fits. Carry on. |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
![]() |
||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
The Melting Deck Plates Muddle - V-22 on LHD deck.... | Mike | Naval Aviation | 79 | December 14th 09 06:00 PM |
hard wax application | Tuno | Soaring | 20 | April 24th 08 03:04 PM |
winter is hard. | Bruce Greef | Soaring | 2 | July 3rd 06 06:31 AM |
It ain't that hard | Gregg Ballou | Soaring | 8 | March 23rd 05 01:18 AM |
Who says flying is hard? | Roger Long | Piloting | 9 | November 1st 04 08:57 PM |