If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
Continental A-65 engine stall?
Yesterday, I flew to an airport for breakfast and as I turned off onto
the taxiway, the engine quit. It's never done that before. Re-started fine. Did not quit when I returned to my home airport. Maybe the turbulence was enough to fix it Some history...the plane had been sitting for for several years and I started flying it again last fall. It seemed to be OK last fall but I had another issue (that turned out to be a big intake leak that prevented it from starting) that I now have fixed. So, could this stalling be something like the float sticking? After I started it, it seemed to "load up" a bit and took some RPM to clear it out. Maybe this is a clue? Scott Corben Junior Ace |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
Continental A-65 engine stall?
Dear Scott,
Your symptoms match those of carb icing. -R.S.Hoover |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
Continental A-65 engine stall?
Scott wrote:
Yesterday, I flew to an airport for breakfast and as I turned off onto the taxiway, the engine quit. It's never done that before. Re-started fine. Did not quit when I returned to my home airport. Maybe the turbulence was enough to fix it I've had that happen, and have been with another small-Continental- powered aircraft where that happened. Instant re-starts in both cases. I tend to agree with Bob...carb ice. On approach, with the engine idling for a bit, the carb heat muff may have cooled down to the point where it couldn't prevent the ice any more. If it re-occurs, there are some potential hardware problems that could going on. Here's a Harry Fenton article on the subject: http://www.bowersflybaby.com/tech/fenton.htm#a65-quits Ron Wanttaja |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
Continental A-65 engine stall?
Ron Wanttaja wrote:
Scott wrote: Yesterday, I flew to an airport for breakfast and as I turned off onto the taxiway, the engine quit. It's never done that before. Re-started fine. Did not quit when I returned to my home airport. Maybe the turbulence was enough to fix it I've had that happen, and have been with another small-Continental- powered aircraft where that happened. Instant re-starts in both cases. I tend to agree with Bob...carb ice. On approach, with the engine idling for a bit, the carb heat muff may have cooled down to the point where it couldn't prevent the ice any more. If it re-occurs, there are some potential hardware problems that could going on. Here's a Harry Fenton article on the subject: http://www.bowersflybaby.com/tech/fenton.htm#a65-quits Ron Wanttaja OK...but if it was carb ice, would the engine restart immediately after getting out to hand prop? My "heat muff" is a replica of an Aeronca 7 series heat muff...just an aluminum "cover" that clamps around the "Y" of the exhaust pipe. Is there an easy way to get more heat such as wrapping a spring or something around the pipes to get more thermal mass? Ideas anyone??? Scott |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
Continental A-65 engine stall?
Scott wrote:
OK...but if it was carb ice, would the engine restart immediately after getting out to hand prop? Sure...the flow of cooling air would stop, and the carb would quickly warm up by conduction. Frank Courtney, in his book "The Eighth Sea," claims to be the discoverer of carburetor icing...not the first to HAVE carb ice, but the first to discover what was causing some otherwise-unexplainable engine failures. He had been participating in a cross-country race with an engine with an updraft carb and no air filter. The engine quit, he set the plane down, and climbed out. He reached the engine just in time to see a chunk of ice drop out of the carburetor throat. My "heat muff" is a replica of an Aeronca 7 series heat muff...just an aluminum "cover" that clamps around the "Y" of the exhaust pipe. Is there an easy way to get more heat such as wrapping a spring or something around the pipes to get more thermal mass? Ideas anyone??? IIRC, Tony Bingelis recommends exactly your approach; wrapping screen-door springs around the pipes. You need more surface area inside the heat to pick up heat to transfer to the air. You might ask at the Aeronca Aviators Club forum page... http://www.aeronca.typeclubs.org/BB3/ ....or ping Harry Fenton directly via the links at the start of the page I previously posted. Ron Wanttaja |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
Continental A-65 engine stall?
Ron Wanttaja wrote:
You might ask at the Aeronca Aviators Club forum page... http://www.aeronca.typeclubs.org/BB3/ ...or ping Harry Fenton directly via the links at the start of the page I previously posted. Ron Wanttaja Will do, Ron, THANKS! As far as starting right up again, yes, I figured it probably does as the engine is still quite warm after landing and without air flowing to move the heat through, the carb would warm up fairly quickly and melt the ice... Do you know what is the mechanism that causes power loss (and ultimately quitting) due to carb ice? The book drawings show that ice builds up in the throat of the carb (if I recall) so it looks like the diameter of the throat is reduced? What does that do to make the engine run at reduced power and/or eventually die? I suspect that it impedes the air flow through it, effectively making the mixture richer until eventual death. Am I close? Scott |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
Continental A-65 engine stall?
Scott wrote:
Yesterday, I flew to an airport for breakfast and as I turned off onto the taxiway, the engine quit. It's never done that before. Re-started fine. Did not quit when I returned to my home airport. Maybe the turbulence was enough to fix it Some history...the plane had been sitting for for several years and I started flying it again last fall. It seemed to be OK last fall but I had another issue (that turned out to be a big intake leak that prevented it from starting) that I now have fixed. So, could this stalling be something like the float sticking? After I started it, it seemed to "load up" a bit and took some RPM to clear it out. Maybe this is a clue? Scott Corben Junior Ace the "loading up" part - could be ice related, or - Fixed ignition timing can cause that problem if allowed to idle too long. |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
Continental A-65 engine stall?
On Jul 12, 11:52 am, Scott wrote:
Do you know what is the mechanism that causes power loss (and ultimately quitting) due to carb ice? The book drawings show that ice builds up in the throat of the carb (if I recall) so it looks like the diameter of the throat is reduced? What does that do to make the engine run at reduced power and/or eventually die? I suspect that it impedes the air flow through it, effectively making the mixture richer until eventual death. Am I close? Getting warm, but still a ways from the truth. There are two factors that cause the temperature drop in the carb: The venturi accelerates the air, thereby dropping its pressure and temperature. We need that pressure drop to suck fuel from the nozzle, but could do without the temp drop. The laws of physics being what they are, we have to deal with it. A similay pressure and temperature drop takes place at the throttle plate when it's closed or mostly closed; the air squeezing past the edge of the plate accelerates a whole bunch and gets cold, however briefly. The other factor is the fuel itself. As it sprays into the airflow, it vaporizes. Anytime we turn a liquid into a vapor, we effect a heat transfer; in this case it's from the air to the liquid as it turns to a vapor. So the air gets mighty chilly. Same effect you get if you dip your hand in gasoline then hold it up and let it dry;your hand gets cold. The fuel sprays from the main nozzles when the power level is higher, and from the idle ports in the carb wall, next to the edge of the throttle plate, at lower settings. So the air, and any water vapor in it as it passed through the carb, is chilled. The vapor, if there's enough of it, will condense, and if the temperature drop is large enough, it will freeze to anything handy. Carb ice. The total temperature drop caused by both venturi effect and evaporation of the fuel can be as much as 38°C, or about 71°F. We can expect carb ice at ambient temps of up to 38°C or 100°F if the humidity is near 100%, or the temp/dewpoints are almost the same. If I want to go diving off some cliff into the water, I want to know what the water conditions are, and what's under the surface. If I want to go flying, I need to know what the atmosphere is up to. That includes temperture and dewpoint spread; if they're close together, I will expect carb ice so I'm not surprised when the engine starts acting up. If your engine quit on the rollout due to carb icing, either your system is leaking and the carb isn't getting warm enough air, or you're not applying it soon enough and getting the carb warmed up some before reducing power. Or you're making long glides without running the power up and warming the carb periodically. What sort of RPM drop do you get when you pull the carb heat in cruise? When are you applying carb heat? How long was the power-off glide? What were the temp and dewpoint on the day in question? Dan |
#9
|
|||
|
|||
Continental A-65 engine stall?
|
#10
|
|||
|
|||
Continental A-65 engine stall?
To All:
Of the two methods of absorbing heat (ie, acceleration of the air & change-of-state for the gasoline) the endotherm resulting from the vaporization of the gasoline can be as much as 100 times colder than the venturi-effect. As for the amount of water in the atmosphere, we know there is ALWAYS some... at least, on this particular planet. The FAA provides a chart that allows you to figure out your probable icing point. What gets people in trouble is the assumption that the ambient air temperature plays a SIGNIFICANT role in carb icing. Not so -- at least not with regard to the 'significant' business. Indeed, when you have a nice WARM day you are more likely to develop carb or manifold icing than on a nice COLD day. Personally, rather than try to figure out the humidity, freezing point and so forth, I assume icing IS probable and shuffle the knobs accordingly. Works for me. As for heat muffs, the FAA expects ours to provide a 90F rise in the inlet temp to the carb. Truth is, most muffs don't come anywhere near that amount due to a lack of heat in the exhaust stacks OR insufficient surface area for the heat to transfer two. Annd if you've done like most of us and wrapped an over-stretched screen-door spring around the exhaust stack, odds are it rusted itself into FOD during the Eisenhower administration. What you wanna do is getta pound of .035 safety wire and wind it into a coil around a piece of rod and use that instead of your door spring. OR get yourself about four of those stainless steel pot-scrubbers and use that. OR get yourself about fifty feet of .010 stainless steel 'razor blade stock;' about 1" wide and bend that into angle stock and wrap that around AT LEALST TWO of your exhaust stacks, because the SIGHNIFICANT factors in the equation are surface are surface area and thermal flow, so that while the Choir Girl pads are hands-down winners for surface area they screw the pooch when it comes to thermal transfer AND cause too much restriction to begin with. So give the razor-blade stock a try. Snip it four or five times per revolution and give each resulting fin a bit of a twist... then go back and crimp each of the 'fins' with a pair of fluting pliers so the fin ends up sorta wavy. Nothing here is carved in stone but a weekend experimenting with a lawn-mower engine and an IR temperature sensor is equal to a couple of months sitting in a classroom. -R.S.Hoover |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
Infamous engine stall on takeoff | James Robinson | Piloting | 8 | January 4th 07 05:08 PM |
Continental engine E185 | Philippe | Home Built | 4 | July 14th 04 01:14 PM |
Continental Tierra 285 Engine | chip | Aviation Marketplace | 5 | May 8th 04 01:02 PM |
Continental Tierra 285 Engine | chip | Home Built | 4 | April 30th 04 02:12 AM |
Continental A65 engine | Philippe Vessaire | Home Built | 0 | July 10th 03 05:49 PM |